Bah, has it really been two days? I've been having trouble focusing on this game, so apologies for that.
Super. Why haven't we killed him already?
Please elaborate. Specifically, you seem to be saying you're fine with killing him
right now, without further discussion. And by "right now" I mean "yesterday."
Both: Current scumpicks, read of the other, and you take on a final verdict over yesterday's disagreement would be welcome.
No strong scumpicks. Yes, I realize that's a rather serious problem.
I just don't feel like going after Akhier anymore, which either means I think he's town or I can't get any effort
at all on this game. I assume it's the former, but if it's the latter it should correct itself as soon as I get myself together.
Final verdict, then, is that he's inexperienced town, and therefore panicked and made up an excuse after the fact to avoid looking scummy/letting scum go, and then kept on either misunderstanding or obfuscating for the same reason.
I do have one peculiar suspicion, however:
All of these are directed at me, in some way or another. Why? "because he seems flaky" is not a reason.
Book: I am undecided, but I have a feeling he is scum. (As explained before, I have a feeling about him)
So, Super, lack of reasons are good enough for you to suspect me, but not good enough for him to suspect you?
The fact that you specifically brought up yourself seems funny somehow. It's certainly a justified example, but it still feels off.
There's also the fact that all of your scumpicks are rather... easy. It's hard to fault you for finding Super or Org scummy, but you're not exactly being adventurous here- you've got three bandwagon magnets as your scumpicks. Do you not have an opinion on anyone else, or do you find them relatively townlike? How convinced are you that Super isn't just being a noob?
In the least if he was scum he would have others to tell him what it actually does.
Not necessarily. I've seen clueless scum before (KM4: where scumchat was basically all evil laughing, until I decided to lynch Jack. Then it was all "Oh fuck").
Darvi is correct. Sorcerer's Apprentice III had a particularly heinous example of scum doing something their teammates would never have allowed if they had a say in it. While it's worth keeping in mind, it's by no means guaranteed that more experienced scum will be able or willing to put a cap on the worst scumtells.
Because it was a general feeling, I had my reasons, but they are lost to time now, I have moved on.
Also, have you nothing better to do than tunnel me for an unexplained vote from the last day?
You said he was "very" scummy, but now can't even remember why? Have you also forgotten why Super was scummy?