Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Mr.Person]

om nom nom delicious hats

I'll have to reread the thread. I'm going to start with Webadict's other picks of Jokerman and Pandarsenic. I get the feeling he was right on the money about them and their lurking.

Wasn't one of his picks, uh, you?

That's why I said other picks.

[SirBayer]

I thought Tack was acting scummy all game (which he was), but I didn't really suspect web was mafia.

SirBayer, you pretty much drove the van that ran over Tack, with a roof-mounted laser-guided bee-cannon on top aimed at Webadict.

Okay, so your argument on me is that I helped lynch a ridiculously scummy player, and that Webadict just so happened to die when he was my secondary target?

You're giving in to the WIFOM OR you're spreading it incompetently. I'm not quite sure which.

[Elegy]

Webadict was killed because he was pretty much confirmed down by Tack's death. We should all go back and take a look at his prime suspicions, because he knows best and blah blah metagaming etc.

[SirBayer]

Webadict was killed because he was pretty much confirmed down by Tack's death. We should all go back and take a look at his prime suspicions, because he knows best and blah blah metagaming etc.

Okay, let's review exactly why that makes you stupid.

A. No, he was not confirmed town, because it's absurdly easy for scum to do what he did, because they know who's town.
B. I was very specifically not on his suspicions list. He thought I was stupid, but not scum.
C. So if you want to chase after his prime suspicions, try Mr. Person or Pandarsenic.

[Jokerman-EXE]

Oh my God.

I just realized that I'm still in this game.

Totally my fault, I confused it with BYOR5 in which I was killed. Fffffffffffffucking hell, I'm sorry.

[SirBayer]

Oh my God.

I just realized that I'm still in this game.

Totally my fault, I confused it with BYOR5 in which I was killed. Fffffffffffffucking hell, I'm sorry.

JOE

PULL IT TOGETHER, SCUM

YOU CAN GET THE TOWN

REALLY

[Zai]

Sorry for not being on in days. Been busy in real life and exhausted when I was at home. I'll read tomorrow. Probably. Hopefully.

[Zai]

Webadict was killed because he was pretty much confirmed down by Tack's death. We should all go back and take a look at his prime suspicions, because he knows best and blah blah metagaming etc.

No.

You are completely incompetent. If I am reading this post right, you're saying Web became CT when Tack died? No. Completely impossible. That's not how it works. At all.

It just sounds like the ridiculous logic you used to decide who to NK.

Also. You say "Webadict was killed because..." and then go on to provide a (completely illogical (which fits perfectly with how you've been playing)) reason why. HOW THE FUCK WOULD YOU KNOW WHY HE WAS NIGHTKILLED IF YOU'RE TOWN?

[Elegy]

Because it makes perfect sense.

[Zai]

Because it makes perfect sense.

No, it doesn't. And you didn't include a "probably" (or the like) in your "Webadict was killed because" statement.

Nobody can become CT in this game. Nobody. Get that through your thick head. How is it that Web could become CT after Tack's death?

[Elegy]

The way he was playing and defending Tack the entire game seemed unbecoming of someone who could have, at any time as mafia, probably gotten him lynched with ease. At the end of day 2 it really came down to SirBayer vs Webadict with both pushing for and against lynching Tack. A mafia would have nothing to gain by defending a player acting that scummy all game, as it brings a lot of attention to themselves in a bad way. The fact that web defended Tack anyway should have been some indication that he was town and he though Tack was, too. Of course, there's no way we could have known that until after Tack died, but as soon as he did, the mafia did a really quick job in getting rid of one of the strongest players who would have been very nearly confirmed as town.

That's my reasoning.

[ToonyMan]

That's just all assumptions, you are saying Webadict was clear cut confirmed town and now he's dead.

[Zai]

The fact that web defended Tack anyway should have been some indication that he was town and he though Tack was, too. Of course, there's no way we could have known that until after Tack died, but as soon as he did, the mafia did a really quick job in getting rid of one of the strongest players who would have been very nearly confirmed as town.

No.

It's called a gambit, you dumbass. Web would not have become CT because as scum he could have been using one. Defending someone you know is town is completely possible as scum.

You thinking he would have been confirmed is pretty ridiculous. You pretty much said you knew why he was NKed ("he wood of ben confirm'd gaiz"). The only thing is that no scumbuddies present over the Night would have let you kill Web for that exact reason. However, they may have let you kill Web because he wanted to get out of the game anyway. Or some other reason.

[Mr.Person]

That's just all assumptions, you are saying Webadict was clear cut confirmed town and now he's dead.

Why did you post this, ToonyMan?

[ToonyMan]

That's a stupid question that can apply to everything Mr.Person.  Bring some finer detail to your "attacks".

Lurkers are tearing shit up as well.  I hate this game but I have a policy to play.