Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[scriver]

Also don't forget Zoroastrianism.

And the Chinese religion is "Dharmic" too now, or rather "Eastern".

[smjjames]

And Judaism.

[Il Palazzo]

Is there something I don't understand about laws, or is there something borked after Holy Fury? I'm running empire of Russia, with high crown authority, which is supposed to prevent vassals fighting each other, and titles passing outside the realm through succession. And yet, I keep seeing my vassals fighting wars over each other's counties, and an occasional inheritance warning.

Also, earlier, before I switched to ultimogeniture, I had agnatic elective gavelkind, and switched to agnatic-cognatic due to the risk of my only male heir leaving this mortal coil. The law is supposed to make women be eligible for inheritance once no male heirs are left. But my two daughters showed up in the inheritance queue, and started competing for votes with my son.

What is going on there? Anyone has a scholarship focus on this topic?

[ChairmanPoo]

I dont think high crown authority will prevent either external inheritance or vassal wars by itself. There are specific laws for that that you have to pass (and for which I think crown authority is a prerreq). Scroll up and down, sometimes they are hidden
You can sorta intervene in vassal wars and ask them to make peace btw. It might not work and it might cost you though.

Regardinh external inheritances... best workaround I've found (if you cant implement the law) is to sequentially murder all external heirs until it defaults to someone within the realm 

[Il Palazzo]

I dont think high crown authority will prevent either external inheritance or vassal wars by itself.

That's what the popup says. Medium authority for inheritance, high for internal wars (edit: the other way around). And there are no separate laws for it that I can see.

[dennislp3]

Does my reforming character become a god (dogmatic + divine blood+ temporal) after he dies? Or does some event pop off for it.

what are you talking about?

Also...been 6 years...still no holy warriors...

do you have the charlemagne dlc?

The different reformed religion options you have in holy fury can be combined for special effects. for instance, Dogmatic + divine marriage + temporal leadership makes your current character the "High God" of the religion. Sadly in this case there are no mechanical benefits and its just a flavor/RP thing

other combined reform options do have mechanical effects though.

Also I have all the DLC..so not sure why my holy order never fired

List of currently known synergies
https://www.reddit.com/r/CrusaderKings/comments/9zazyz/reformation_combinations/eado38x

[ChairmanPoo]

I dont think high crown authority will prevent either external inheritance or vassal wars by itself.

That's what the popup says. Medium authority for inheritance, high for internal wars (edit: the other way around). And there are no separate laws for it that I can see.

I'm certain, like 99% certain, that external vassal wars anf inheritance are separate from crown authority, or at least I've seen them as separate.

I have all the dlc (and a couple of mods which dont impact realm laws afaik..)  could it be that's the cause?

[Il Palazzo]

Could be. I don't have Conclave, Republic, Charlemagne, and the eastern DLCs. As a feudal empire I can only change crown authority, centralization, and adopt imperial administration.

[USEC_OFFICER]

Did you check what kind of wars your vassals are fighting among themselves? If I remember correctly, rebellions aren't stopped by the laws, only wars to press claims and conquest between different vassals. So if you're seeing the later along with the former then something is definitely messed up.

[Il Palazzo]

All kinds of wars, including de jure claims they fabricated themselves.

[hector13]

Yeah those things are separate from crown authority. As poo says, authority only gives you access to them as opposed to implementing them immediately.

I know vassal inheritance laws are the first thing in the laws screen - choices being free and illegal - and I’m reasonably sure the vassal wars thing is next below that, which I think gives you the option for free, external, and illegal.

As for the agnatic-cognatoc thing, if your daughters are competing for votes, you’re not ultimogeniture. I’m reasonably sure you can only change inheritance laws once per character, so you have to wait ‘til your next character to switch it to ultimogeniture.

Unless your game is completely borked, anyway.

[Il Palazzo]

Yeah those things are separate from crown authority.

No, that's only if you have Conclave DLC. I don't.

[hector13]

So they are.

According to the wiki, things get a bit weird if have liege kingdoms that aren’t dejure part of your empire, or there are different religions involved. They can basically ignore your laws in some situations.

[ZeroGravitas]

So they are.

According to the wiki, things get a bit weird if have liege kingdoms that aren’t dejure part of your empire, or there are different religions involved. They can basically ignore your laws in some situations.

that was my thinking when i read it. crown laws only work in your de jure land

[Il Palazzo]

So they are.

According to the wiki, things get a bit weird if have liege kingdoms that aren’t dejure part of your empire, or there are different religions involved. They can basically ignore your laws in some situations.

The exceptions listed there don't apply here. That's been all happening within the de jure Russian empire. I hold all kingdom titles, and the empire, with identical laws across the board.

I used to play essentially the same setup before Holy Fury, and seem to remember the Pax Russiana among my vassals working as intended. But my memory might simply be getting wonky.
I'd like to know if anyone has had similar experience, and if it's normal, resulting just from me not understanding how the laws work, or if it's a post-dlc bug infestation.

As for the agnatic-cognatoc thing, if your daughters are competing for votes, you’re not ultimogeniture. I’m reasonably sure you can only change inheritance laws once per character, so you have to wait ‘til your next character to switch it to ultimogeniture.

That's not the point. As I wrote I was elective gavelkind. This is about the gender part of inheritance laws. Agnatic-cognatic, as per its description, should not allow women to be considered while eligible male heirs exist - is what I understood it to mean.
Also, iirc, when my son was eventually elected, the laws otherwise worked as advertised, in that my daughters did not get a share of my demesne.