Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

Yes

14 (60.9%)

No

8 (34.8%)

Other (explain)

1 (4.3%)

Total Members Voted: 23

[Alexhans]

@SniHjen: Why was Josh's quote Anti town ?
--------------------
@inaluct: Anything else you want to say?
--------------------
@ToonyMan: Acting crazy already?
--------------------
#55
Cool thought Josh...

What if there ISN'T a town Medium?  And if there is... what if he is killed? How am I supposed to contribute to this game like that?  What If the medium is a lurker?  There's too many ifs to seriously consider your proposal.

We could say the same for any experienced player... lynch him because if he is a dopp... But then... what if he is town and the remaining experienced players are not...

What you're doing is trying to push a policy lynch (or kill?) in the weirdest way possible...

Usually... bad or lurky players are lynched to avoid having them in the final stages of the game... but you're proposing KILLING an experienced player, just in case he is scum and being very optimistic about my chances of involvement with the game.

Do you not care if I have a relevant role or not?

Are you earnest about this proposal? 
----------------------
@Janus: Can you develop on the supposed slip?  You think he was claiming an anti town role?  Why would he do that after voting as opposed to giving a reason for his vote?
-------------------- 

[ToonyMan]

I'm just posting what I have said so far for everybody.

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Hey everybody!

3 dopps and 3 cultist Sir Josh.

Cultist are like human dopps.

lol for the Multiple personality Frelock Janus...

I'm gonna go ahead and vote Toonyman because he will probably try to hide behind his insane avatar and pass off as a crazy person to be allowed to act scummy.

Vote ToonyMan

I gotta go now but I'll come later to see what the hell this cult thing is all about.

Oh... And I've just read my pm...

what's a Dee O Pee Pee?   

But then I hit preview and...

Cult = second mafia group

Really, that's about it.

Is that the only difference?  2 scum groups hurt each other more (and are better for town) than 1 scum group of more people vs town... so they must be full of PRs or something to make things balanced...

then I hit preview again and there's a lot of posts... too bad... I'll check them later... bye...

I'm totally serious on this thread.  I don't want Meph to modkill me.   

Gotta point that arrow the other way.

Hello Duke!  I hope you're not anti-town!

Don't forget the aliens!

Don't worry inaluct, I'll defend you!

They do lack substance though, that's for sure.  Ah well.  It is day 1.

[JanusTwoface]

@Alexhans
At this point, I'm not really convinced or even too terribly worried that SniHjen is a dopp.  Just storing it in the back of my mind for later in the game.  This is why I was a little paranoid in the last game about fixing grammatical errors (fat lot of good that did me :-D).

@Everyone
On another note, it is interesting watching chaoticjosh and Alexhans (two good players from last game, no idea before that) go after each other like this.  I almost wonder if they are both either dopps or cultists, just *acting* angry at each other?  I'm not sold on the idea yet, but it bears keeping in mind.

[JoshuaFH]

Josh: Skill at the game shouldn't be an excuse to preemptively kill someone. What if the medium is a dopp (since that can happen this game). What if Alex is an AWV or agent, or some similarly useful role that won't be nearly as useful if he's dead?

The same could be said of anyone Rysith, remember how we accidentally killed both the AWV and the PWV on the first two nights last game, purely through accident?

Also, the dopp medium can be circumvented quite easily: By neither Alex or the medium using the dead chat. The medium can simply PM Alex, and they can talk in that fashion. That's how I talked with Nuke almost the entire time I was dead, and it hasn't been outlawed since.

Alex, you can believe I'm very earnest about a "policy" lynch. Your particular skill set lets you be mafia way better than it lets you be town. Preventing you from gaining the upper hand seems like a better idea than waiting until you do, then being forced to sift through whatever nightmare of preparatory excuses you have ready, and then reluctantly lynch you based on that.

Prevention > cure, is what I'm trying to say.

I'll think it over though Alex, and If I think of a great reason to unvote you, then I will.

[ToonyMan]

Alexhans is only voting me because of who I am!  That's profiling!

[inaluct]

@inaluct: Anything else you want to say?

Yes.

[EchoP]

I echo the comments that there are many, many players. Especially when they can generate four pages of posts before I notice that it's started. I'll random vote for EchoP, though. He hasn't posted yet, and getting everyone to speak up a bit is good, especially the new players.

Hey. I have no suspicions as of yet, but I will look into it.

[Rysith]

Josh: Skill at the game shouldn't be an excuse to preemptively kill someone. What if the medium is a dopp (since that can happen this game). What if Alex is an AWV or agent, or some similarly useful role that won't be nearly as useful if he's dead?

The same could be said of anyone Rysith, remember how we accidentally killed both the AWV and the PWV on the first two nights last game, purely through accident?

Very true. I'm not trying to say that lynching Alex is a bad idea (I'm leaning towards not lynching him, but I'm not really sure enough to commit one way or the other), just that lynching Alex because he is a good player, and then counting on a medium to allow him to still help us is not a good reason to lynch him, at least without hunting around for other people to go after.

Also, the dopp medium can be circumvented quite easily: By neither Alex or the medium using the dead chat. The medium can simply PM Alex, and they can talk in that fashion. That's how I talked with Nuke almost the entire time I was dead, and it hasn't been outlawed since.

Ah, I was thinking of the case where either there is a dopp medium posing as town medium, or dopp medium and no town medium. Both would prevent a dead player from helping out.

Prevention > cure, is what I'm trying to say.

Perhaps. We should be going for the best possible lynch, though, and to me it's a question of whether a better result would happen by lynching someone else while maintaining awareness of Alex's acting abilities, rather than lynching alex without hunting for other suspicious people.

Fake edit: unvote, since EchoP posted. Echo, any comments on the game thus far, even if you have no suspicions?

Vote Servant Corps, again for not posting.

[Mr.Person]

Vote Rysith for pulling up BS to vote for Alexhans. You don't vote in mafia based on skill, never.

[JanusTwoface]

... I'll random vote for EchoP, though. He hasn't posted yet, and getting everyone to speak up a bit is good, especially the new players. ...

Vote Servant Corps, again for not posting.

Vote Rysith for pulling up BS to vote for Alexhans. You don't vote in mafia based on skill, never.

me == confused

[Mephansteras]

The Whiteboard
A_Fey_Dwarf : Kashyyk
Alexhans: chaoticjosh
Cheeetar : Beacon80
Rysith : Mr.Person
Servant Corps : Rysith
ToonyMan : Alexhans
chaoticjosh : Frelock, SniHjen
No Lynch: JanusTwoFace


Hopefully that's correct. You'll have to double-check your votes on these, since with this many players it'll be easy for me to miss something.

[Mr.Person]

... I'll random vote for EchoP, though. He hasn't posted yet, and getting everyone to speak up a bit is good, especially the new players. ...

Vote Servant Corps, again for not posting.

Vote Rysith for pulling up BS to vote for Alexhans. You don't vote in mafia based on skill, never.

me == confused

Oh sorry, You're right, I meant to vote chaoticjosh

[JoshuaFH]

You say that like it's common knowledge Mr.Person. Please, share with us, what is the basis behind NEVER voting for someone based on skill?

[ToonyMan]

The Whiteboard
A_Fey_Dwarf : Kashyyk
Alexhans: chaoticjosh
Cheeetar : Beacon80
Rysith : Mr.Person
Servant Corps : Rysith
ToonyMan : Alexhans
chaoticjosh : Frelock, SniHjen
No Lynch: JanusTwoFace


Hopefully that's correct. You'll have to double-check your votes on these, since with this many players it'll be easy for me to miss something.

Wow, I was expecting that.  So many single votes.

[Mr.Person]

You say that like it's common knowledge Mr.Person. Please, share with us, what is the basis behind NEVER voting for someone based on skill?

Alright, let's lynch all the experienced players. Let's start with you.