Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

Yes

14 (60.9%)

No

8 (34.8%)

Other (explain)

1 (4.3%)

Total Members Voted: 23

[Mr.Person]

There's too many players!

Random vote on Twiggie while I start making a graph.

[Alexhans]

Hi... I'm back...

what's a Dee O Pee Pee?

Unvote
Vote Alexhans

Is it serious?

A dopp with an intriguing strategy?
A cultist trying to make us think he's a dopp?

totally... those 2... Because making you think I'm a dopp if I'm a cultist will help me very much... XD

I'm not sure what Alex is doing, I thought that was one of his weird jokes.

BINGO!  However.  It may have useful connotations.

Yeah, what IS the meaning of that Alexhans? You told me specifically last game that it's counter-productive to WIFOM the town, and you're acting skills are much too finely honed to allow you to continue a masquerade. You proved that to everyone last game.

Ok... first of all... I'm allowed to joke in the first few posts... like everybody else.  later on, when I get totally serious, people hate me. 
Second... this was such an obvious joke that it doesn't even enter the land of WIFOM.  Wifom could be set if someone starts calling for their own lynch to prove their townieness so everyone gets cold feet or something.

Thanks for the... err... praise? but I don't get what masquerade are you talking about.  Nor what did I prove last game...
--------
wow... 23 players... New record, right?

6/23 = 26 % scum.  Seems ok. 

[ToonyMan]

Don't forget the aliens!

[JanusTwoface]

Don't forget the aliens!

[Alexhans]

There are 3 Doppelgangers and 3 Cultists of the Great Old Ones! Town has to kill all 6 enemies, and each hostile group must kill off everyone else. Aliens do their normal thing, of course.

oh... I thought that this quote meant that there were no exterminator aliens... because we don't need to kill the survivor unlesss we are in a complicated situation but the Ext must die for us to win.

So we might have to face an EXT with his operative too?  (as much as it sucks to have so much anti town role, I still love the Ext Alien with his Operative)

[Mephansteras]

There can be the usual compliment of aliens. But, as usual, you don't get to know about them ahead of time the way you do with the Dopps and Cultists.

[SniHjen]

Yeah, what IS the meaning of that Alexhans? You told me specifically last game that it's counter-productive to WIFOM the town, and you're acting skills are much too finely honed to allow you to continue a masquerade. You proved that to everyone last game.

Unvote

Vote chaoticjosh

I call a Anti town

[inaluct]

Huh. I'm in, I guess. Yey.

since Inaluct is always scum

I'm never scum! :O

[ToonyMan]

Don't worry inaluct, I'll defend you!

[JanusTwoface]

Still under half of the people in the game have posted. (11/23 by my count).  Interesting to have such a large game.

Unvote

Vote chaoticjosh

I call a Anti town

That's an interesting choice of wording.  If I'm not mistaken, that means you're claiming to be either a dopp, cultist, or a more aggressive alien.  What's stopping us from lynching you right now?

[JoshuaFH]

Whatever Alex, I won't argue with you over the ethics of being serious over being jocular at the start of the game.

I just want people to consider this: if Alex is indeed a dopp or cultist, then he'll be the best one with his cool attitude, clear thinking, and impressive acting skill, and I'll wager that it's a better idea to kill him before he manages to weasel into a forming town base and destroys the town from the inside out. What I'm saying is that it's better to get rid of a possible major threat than a possible minor one. Even if I'm blatantly wrong, Alex can still lend his skill to the town through the Medium PM'ing him, if there is one.

Duke, can you give us your opinion on the situation? I know you're new, but it's best to get you involved when your still learning than later when it might be harder to relearn. You don't have to bother with the roleplaying stuff, you can just talk normally.

[JanusTwoface]

@Duke 2.0
Just my 2 cents, I'm always a fan of roleplaying.  One idea though, but it in italics to separate it from everything else.  Then, the people that enjoy it can read it and the people that want to focus on the logic and lynching (chaotic josh for one) can focus on that.

@SniHjen
Any words in your defense?

[SniHjen]

Still under half of the people in the game have posted. (11/23 by my count).  Interesting to have such a large game.

Unvote

Vote chaoticjosh

I call a Anti town

That's an interesting choice of wording.  If I'm not mistaken, that means you're claiming to be either a dopp, cultist, or a more aggressive alien.  What's stopping us from lynching you right now?

I'll change my wording then:

I call that chaoticjosh is anti town.

do I need to engrave it in stone?

[JanusTwoface]

I'll change my wording then:

I call that chaoticjosh is anti town.

do I need to engrave it in stone?

That's much better and makes a lot more sense.  I won't ignore the possibility that you made some sort of psychological slip, but I'll go back to contemplating chaoticjosh's spider for a while.

[Rysith]

I echo the comments that there are many, many players. Especially when they can generate four pages of posts before I notice that it's started. I'll random vote for EchoP, though. He hasn't posted yet, and getting everyone to speak up a bit is good, especially the new players.

Josh: Skill at the game shouldn't be an excuse to preemptively kill someone. What if the medium is a dopp (since that can happen this game). What if Alex is an AWV or agent, or some similarly useful role that won't be nearly as useful if he's dead? Not that I'm accusing you or anything, I remember Alex's deception from last game. Just pointing out that preemptively killing skillful players isn't quite as good as it used to be, and so should be used more cautiously.