Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[hector13]

What is "PPE"?

Eh? What's this? Why do I get the train when I vote someone else, and ignored for the lynch when I vote myself?

Pre-post edit. If someone posts and you want to respond to it before you’ve finished your own, PPE.

What did you do N1?

[sofanthiel]

why would hector go after snowkiller?

Maybe hector isn't playing rationally?  What if there's a chance he was affected by the mysterious entity that goes by the name "Emotions"...

[Crystalizedmire]

My target was Snowkiller.

Assuming Elephant parade is telling the truth and hector did attack snowkiller, why would hector go after snowkiller? To me at least, it would be more plausible for hector to kill sofanthiel. My only plausible explanation is that MS voted snowkiller and snowkiller is thus more likely to be seen as townie than sofanthiel which doesn't make sense when you realize that MS also voted sofanthiel.

Unless I'm missing something, Hector could've also gone after sofanthiel, not that that would have made much sense. He may have targeted Snowkiller on the basis of Maximumspin's push on him making him look very strongly town and his uselessness making him an unlikely protection target, unlike myself and Caz. There is an unlikely but plausible second reason for Hector to target Snowkiller that I don't intend to explain.

You're right about how hector could've possibly tried to go after sofanthiel, but for some reason didn't because I'm evidently still alive(possibly because he isn't lying or for another unknown reason).

[Elephant Parade]

Okay so that's CM cleared barring MS/sofanthiel/CM (no) or a scum jailkeeper (what).

Too many becauses. Wouldn’t kill either of them because there were townier people, basically.

My secret second reason fully explains why you would target Snowkiller.

I’m also curious why I’d hamstring myself by eliminating my teammate in D1 instead of going for the no lunch and claiming internet issues or whatever, given the timescale left at the end of the day.

PPE: I’m a knight brah, I can’t do anything at night other than be hardcore and dodge your goddamn arrows.

PPE2: Jesus h man you’re throwing around speculation as to my night actions. Unless Meph is being very weird, there’s one scum left, meaning at least two of me you and CM are telling the truth. That means, unless CM is scum, they can block me in the night if Snowkiller isn’t scum, or Snowkiller if I’m not scum.

PPE3: CM is assuredly telling the truth then.

What did Snowkiller do in the night, I think is a good question to ask right now.

Because you knew Toonyman was going to vote MS at the last second and you wanted the towncred for doing it yourself rather than the scumcred for not doing it despite claiming to hate no lynches so much you'd sooner lynch yourself. ToonyMan actually did post before the deadline, so he would've.

[hector13]

Yes my play screams irrational, particularly given the what, 36 hours I would’ve had to consider my actions and responses if I were scum, and my complete non-interest in the night game if I were a knight?

PPE:TOONYMAN HAD ALREADY VOTED MAX YOU BUFFOON

[Elephant Parade]

Wait actually

I did not realize that at the time and have not realized it at any point since

Oh my god

[hector13]

EP.

Just vote Snowkiller :p

[Crystalizedmire]

My target was Snowkiller.

Assuming Elephant parade is telling the truth and hector did attack snowkiller, why would hector go after snowkiller? To me at least, it would be more plausible for hector to kill sofanthiel. My only plausible explanation is that MS voted snowkiller and snowkiller is thus more likely to be seen as townie than sofanthiel which doesn't make sense when you realize that MS also voted sofanthiel.

Unless I'm missing something, Hector could've also gone after sofanthiel, not that that would have made much sense. He may have targeted Snowkiller on the basis of Maximumspin's push on him making him look very strongly town and his uselessness making him an unlikely protection target, unlike myself and Caz. There is an unlikely but plausible second reason for Hector to target Snowkiller that I don't intend to explain.

You're right about how hector could've possibly tried to go after sofanthiel, but for some reason didn't because I'm evidently still alive(possibly because he isn't lying or for another unknown reason).

After post edit: you're right there are multiple reasons for why hector didn't go after sofanthiel.

[ToonyMan]

@Sofanthiel:
That's a really good point. Hector could have just...tied the vote to keep Max alive. Sure it looks awful, but it's probably a better plan than this suffering today.

Snowkiller voting themselves looks pretty serious though. They could be given up scum, which would explain the congratulations on the Max read.

[Elephant Parade]

OK I have double-checked and Hector is right. I still think they're a sussy baka who could've done it for towncred but I'm going to have to reevaluate my feelings on them.

EP.

Just vote Snowkiller :p

No. They basically can't be scum.

[ToonyMan]

Wait even better, Hector didn't even need to do anything for the vote to remain tied right? So just "disappearing" would have definitely been the best plan. He purposely acted to have a lynch happen, which resulted in Max's death.

[hector13]

How can they not be scum?

If someone can prove to me I wasn’t targeted I will never play mafia in this forum ever again.

Or I’ll just… we’ll I’m already voting for myself, but yeah.

[ToonyMan]

I don't think you can suspect Hector here unless you suspect me just as much.

[hector13]

Why is my autocorrect so terrible

[hector13]

I’m sorry I’m getting so worked up but the game is so obviously over to me, and I’m struggling to see how everyone other than EP can’t see that.