Likely Townnotquitethere: scum!NQT fades into the shadows harder than a chameleon hiding behind a raven in a tunnel on a moonless night. Sure, it's painful that they only realised that the inspection immunity claims could be mind games aimed at cults, but I think this was genuine and town. That said, not sure where this new strategy is going, but I like it better than the graphs.
EganBW: Still quite a new player and often folds a bit as mafia. They've been using their vote, giving the right answers to questions, and seem at home in the game, so I think town.
TricMagic: I've seen Tric hold information before so not a scumtell. They're aggressive, highly focused on particular targets, refusing to explain their reasoning and inexplicably self-voting. I thiiiink this is Town-Tric.
EuchreJack: mild town gut read, other people are better than me at understanding EJ tbh. Although I'd really love to repeatedly ask them why they haven't found scum despite having two of the twelve available votes, that was irritating as hell in FBYOR5 when they did it to me.
NullMax: hasn't been massively helpful, has been defending people. If anything, I'd say slight town lean, but I can't really read them. Expecting something more useful than just putting a vote on KW today.
Toony: I've never read scum!Toony successfully. I've caught them once, by explicitly interacting with them at night because I couldn't read them, and even then we barely won despite getting incredibly lucky and having Vector. Firm null.
Maybe CultWeb: He doesn't really want to argue with me this game, which is unusual, or with anyone other than NQT, which is unusualler. Even his standard sounding people out has been mild. Either he's 100% convinced on many people's alignment already, or he's willing to be opportunistic about the elim a la FBYOR5. Went after NQT in that one, funnily enough, I suspect because he was mally and could read him as town. Which means he shouldn't be going after NQT here as either alignment, unless scum!web gave up on a D1 cult elim. Which they'd only do if it was Toony, Jim or Max. Weak read because Web is a strong player.
Jim: It's mostly been fluff and reasonable but quite mild analysis/readslists. I can usually read scum!Jim because his powerwolf play is extremely obvious when you consider the rationale behind powerwolfing and Jim's specific scum philosophy, but the last game means people would actually be on the lookout for this. While town!Jim can be very slow and reasonable, I don't actually see someone really looking hard for the right elimination, he's busier just laughing at weaker players. Subject to change if he actually produces a case or a strong opinion or something. Not a strong read because this looks more like his standard town play than standard scum!Jim, but given the circumstances, not a weak one either. Aaand... yeah, I realise now I argued something similar along those lines when I was scum in the Armed Forces game, and that was just a wack justification to kill him... so now I'm being undermined by my past self.
Toaster: Ok, a bunch of strong players and students of character have told me this is just Toaster's meta, and I see no reason for anyone to mislead me there. On the other hand: his
second post was activelurking, he
exaggerated a mild case into a "slip", and the most of his other posts are basically chitchat or defending himself. I would be in favour of a Toaster elim, but I don't think I'm going to get it.