Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Egan_BW]

That's reasonable. I did No Action.

[ToonyMan]

That's reasonable. I did No Action.

Why?

[Knightwing64]

Knightwing: Should we narrow down who killed Persus?

I mean, yeah? That seems kinda like the point of mafia, I don’t know why you have to vote me for that

[Knightwing64]

I don’t believe 2 people did no action.

[ToonyMan]

I don’t believe 2 people did no action.

It's possible. Vector claims no-action (which I can confirm), and also had a day ability like Egan claims. This would involve believing Egan though.

[Lenglon]

update 3 of N1 actions:
notquitethere -- unclaimed action, Roleblocked by Max
Knightwing64     -- Offered Jack a Devil Deal
Maximum Spin     -- Roleblocked NQT
4maskwolf        -- Transformed Lenglon into someone that can Jailkeep
Egan_BW          -- No Action, currently reviving Tric At Day's End
EuchreJack       -- Stole roleblock + prevent mafiakill from Max, got another Monster ability (undisclosed).
hector13         -- unclaimed action
Jim Groovester   -- Lookout (or Watch) on Hector, nobody visited Hector.
Lenglon          -- Bug Max (action succeeded), gift monster action of NQT's to Jack
ToonyMan         -- Tracked Vector, claims Vector no-visited
Vector           -- no-actioned, limited kills to Perseus and Hector as D1 action, seen as no-visiting by Toony.
So Perseus was killed by one of the following:
A Liar
Hector13
Perseus themselves.

[Lenglon]

or NQT with a non-roleblockable kill.

[Maximum Spin]

Or a(nother) multitasker. I feel like Knightwing or 4mask are the people whose actions I could most believe could coexist with another action.

[Knightwing64]

I’m going to bed, please don’t let Max convince you to vote me out before I get my screw you message fully written.

[Knightwing64]

or NQT with a non-roleblockable kill.

If that was the case, it was probably a one shot, in which case we don’t have to worry any more

[ToonyMan]

Town would have claimed a redirect so I don't see any situation where Evil accidentally killed their own.

This bothers me because it means some scenario like the following happened:

#1
Evil!NQT tries to kill Hector?, gets blocked by Max
Somebody not part of the Evil team kills Persus

This seems the most likely.

#2
Evil!NQT or SK!NQT superkills Persus, bypassing Max's block

Unlikely. NQT would have to be SK here unless he's insane, but then where does mafiakill go?

#3
Persus used some sacrifice ability

Seems unlikely especially because Vector picked two players that can be killed, what are the chances?

#4
Somebody multi-tasked and killed Persus like a baller

Unlikely

[Maximum Spin]

update 3 of N1 actions:
notquitethere -- unclaimed action, Roleblocked by Max
Knightwing64     -- Offered Jack a Devil Deal
Maximum Spin     -- Roleblocked NQT
4maskwolf        -- Transformed Lenglon into someone that can Jailkeep
Egan_BW          -- No Action, currently reviving Tric At Day's End
EuchreJack       -- Stole roleblock + prevent mafiakill from Max, got another Monster ability (undisclosed).
hector13         -- unclaimed action
Jim Groovester   -- Lookout (or Watch) on Hector, nobody visited Hector.
Lenglon          -- Bug Max (action succeeded), gift monster action of NQT's to Jack
ToonyMan         -- Tracked Vector, claims Vector no-visited
Vector           -- no-actioned, limited kills to Perseus and Hector as D1 action, seen as no-visiting by Toony.
So Perseus was killed by one of the following:
A Liar
Hector13
Perseus themselves.

Let me see...
Actions I personally feel super confident about:
notquitethere -- unclaimed action, Roleblocked by Max
Maximum Spin     -- Roleblocked NQT
EuchreJack       -- Stole roleblock + prevent mafiakill from Max [...]
Lenglon          -- Bug Max (action succeeded), [...]

These involve me directly and I can confirm everything everyone else has said makes sense. (Technically, I can't confirm NQT's action that isn't even claimed, but I'm including it here because my roleblock succeeded. Maybe I got redirected to a no-actor or something, though.)

Actions that seem probably true as a result:
Knightwing64     -- Offered Jack a Devil Deal
4maskwolf        -- Transformed Lenglon into someone that can Jailkeep
EuchreJack       -- [...] got another Monster ability (undisclosed).
Lenglon          -- [...] gift monster action of NQT's to Jack

These are all confirmed by someone who seemed to be telling the truth in the first section.

That leaves:
Egan_BW          -- No Action, currently reviving Tric At Day's End
hector13         -- unclaimed action
Jim Groovester   -- Lookout (or Watch) on Hector, nobody visited Hector.
ToonyMan         -- Tracked Vector, claims Vector no-visited
Vector           -- no-actioned, limited kills to Perseus and Hector as D1 action, seen as no-visiting by Toony.

[ToonyMan]

My current speculation is that NQT tried to mafiakill and couldn't.

I think Egan, Hector, and Jim are the most likely to have killed Persus. I think 4mask is possible and KW is very unlikely.

I'm kind of confused because Good wins when all Evil players are removed. I'm not really understanding the structure that's going on here. I really don't think a Good player killed Persus, but then if some other non-Good player killed them then Good isn't suppose to care even if they're SK? That doesn't work.

[EuchreJack]

Max & now my ability don't say Evil kill, but explicitly Mafia.

[EuchreJack]

NQT's ability is a redirect. It picks two targets and redirects them to each other.