Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[4maskwolf]

Game 1 had a Demon/Devil, not Wererat/Necromancer.

Otherwise pretty spot on in terms of analysis.

[notquitethere]

Ahh I must have transposed it over from 3. Fixed:

Spoiler: Fixed Composition (click to show/hide)

1- 13 players: 3 werewolves, 2 third parties (Devil/Demon), 8 town
2- 12 players: 3 cult killers, 1 third party (Ghoul), 8 town (one revived as Demon)
3- 13 players: 2 vampire cultists, 2 third parties (Wererat, Necromancer), 9 town
4- 14 players: 2 vampire cultists, 2 third parties (Guardian Angel, Devil), 10 town (1 revived as demon)
5- 14 players: 3 werewolves inc priest, 1 third party (wererat), 10 town (1 revived as lone vampire)
6- 11 players: 3 cultists inc converter, 0 third party, 8 town
7- 13 players: 1 dark magus, 2 third party (Werebear SK, Necromancer), 10 town
8- 14 players: 3 cult killers, 2 third party (Guardian Angel, Necromancer), 9 town
9- 9 players: 2 cult killers, 2 third party (Devil, Ghoul), 5 town

[Mephansteras]

The Scribe's Tally Sheet
4maskwolf: 1: Luckyowl
IcyTea31: 1: Persus13
juicebox: 2: BluarianKnight, TricMagic
Luckyowl: 2: 4maskwolf, ToonyMan
Toaster: 1: notquitethere


Day ends ~5pm Pacific Wednesday

Juicebox has requested a replacement. I've reached out to Heydude6 about it.

[TricMagic]

Facedesk

[TricMagic]

Seriously, two for two?

[Persus13]

I don't understand why you're facedesking here. Juicebox has been struggling to provide activity for most of this game. Him requesting a replacement seems perfectly warranted.

[TricMagic]

Perhaps, but you still haven't really provided anything. It makes lynching them frustrating when they switch like that. The new person will be playing, and the old data must be ignored. Headache-inducing for me.

[4maskwolf]

Interesting that you're more concerned with lynching someone than with reading them.

[4maskwolf]

Also you don't by any stretch have to throw out what the previous player in that slot did, it's absolutely valid (if slightly annoying to be on the receiving end of) to have part of your read on a slot based on its previous holder.

It very much sounds like you're just pissed an easy ML on a lurker might slip through your fingers.

Considering that the last time I heard someone complaining like that it was a wolf bitching about it in deadchat.

[TricMagic]

Persus still hasn't really given anything useful, and he was the last replacement. Is anyone thinking on pushing him, or going for the luckyowl policy lynch? It's impossible to actually decipher things as town when the ones you can really push either don't give anything or disappear. I am half tempted to just come back on day 3 given day 2 is likely to be a repeat of day 1 but with a luckyowl lynch on the table.

[4maskwolf]

Persus still hasn't really given anything useful, and he was the last replacement. Is anyone thinking on pushing him, or going for the luckyowl policy lynch? It's impossible to actually decipher things as town when the ones you can really push either don't give anything or disappear. I am half tempted to just come back on day 3 given day 2 is likely to be a repeat of day 1 but with a luckyowl lynch on the table.

LuckyOwl isn't a policy lynch, it's a very pragmatic one: flipping him town gives us a guaranteed (or at least I assume it's guaranteed, I don't think I've ever seen a town priest revive someone as mafia) not-mafia player in Blue and flipping him wolf tells us what wolf team we're up against and gives us another probable non-town (and likely scum) in blue again. It gives us a ton of information and in the worst case scenario it's also basically necessary for the town to have a chance of winning.

[Vector]

1.

Persus still hasn't really given anything useful, and he was the last replacement. Is anyone thinking on pushing him, or going for the luckyowl policy lynch? It's impossible to actually decipher things as town when the ones you can really push either don't give anything or disappear. I am half tempted to just come back on day 3 given day 2 is likely to be a repeat of day 1 but with a luckyowl lynch on the table.

Pardon my language, but fuck off

2. NotQuiteThere, who do you think the original converter was?

[Persus13]

Perhaps, but you still haven't really provided anything. It makes lynching them frustrating when they switch like that. The new person will be playing, and the old data must be ignored. Headache-inducing for me.

Persus still hasn't really given anything useful, and he was the last replacement. Is anyone thinking on pushing him, or going for the luckyowl policy lynch? It's impossible to actually decipher things as town when the ones you can really push either don't give anything or disappear. I am half tempted to just come back on day 3 given day 2 is likely to be a repeat of day 1 but with a luckyowl lynch on the table.

There are 13 players in this game. You seem to think there are three of them and you. Interact with more people. Also its amusing to be told by you that I've done nothing when as far as I can tell you've done nothing except confuse people and you've done absolutely nothing as I recall to interact with me.

Also you don't by any stretch have to throw out what the previous player in that slot did, it's absolutely valid (if slightly annoying to be on the receiving end of) to have part of your read on a slot based on its previous holder.

It very much sounds like you're just pissed an easy ML on a lurker might slip through your fingers.

Considering that the last time I heard someone complaining like that it was a wolf bitching about it in deadchat.

All of this.

[IcyTea31]

Been traveling most of this day so I'm not completely in the loop. I'll be posting more after a night's sleep.

[notquitethere]

Vector

2. NotQuiteThere, who do you think the original converter was?

If I had to shoot a converter right now, I'd pick Toaster. He's in the suspicious pool and has no claims. Killing the converter specifically is not as pressing if there's a charismatic cult. Shooting Lucky would be a step towards finding out, but I'd rather hit someone we don't know anything about to maximise chance of hitting scum. Who do you favour for today?