Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

No Lynch

[Caz]

With this plan we can also NL our way into all having spotlight, btw.

Did we break it T_T

[Caz]

No Lynch

[ToonyMan]

There are still ways for mafia to mess with us, but I will feel bad if this works out perfectly and I didn't notice before the game started.

[Caz]

(Also if anyone has flaws that might cause their shield-giving to fail tonight, probably better off to claim that now)

[Nirur Torir]

Problems:
If scum are set to give scum a shield, they get a non-shield action.
  If one of them is already merchant, they can give a sword instead of a shield, giving them a kill N2.
Scum can dip Fool to get a redirect, and know exactly who that will leave vulnerable that same night. Alternatively, it can be used to frame.

I don't think these are enough to counter it.

[Caz]

We can still PoE everyone who did give a shield to their designated player, though, which will be useful enough.

[TricMagic]

If you already have a shield from Night 0 or if you're an Antmen that's fine, don't stray from the plan still.

TricMagic Sell Shield ToonyMan
ToonyMan Sell Shield Caz
Caz Sell Shield FallacyofUrist
FallacyofUrist Sell Shield Vector
Vector Sell Shield Luckyowl
Luckyowl Sell Shield Secretdorf
Secretdorf Sell Shield mightymushroom
mightymushroom Sell Shield juicebox
juicebox Sell Shield Egan BW
Egan BW Sell Shield Nirur Torir
Nirur Torir Sell Shield webadict
webadict Sell Shield Jim Groovester
Jim Groovester Sell Shield Toaster
Toaster Sell Shield TricMagic

Let's get rich quick boys.

Does anybody see any problems with this?

Yes. Why exactly do you want everyone to become Merchants and sell shields as their only actions? I for one have a very different plan in mind. You're welcome to have others buy into this plan, but keep me out of it.

Seriously. Are there any abilities to bypass protects, let me check real quick.

[ToonyMan]

We can still PoE everyone who did give a shield to their designated player, though, which will be useful enough.

Yes.

(Also if anyone has flaws that might cause their shield-giving to fail tonight, probably better off to claim that now)

I have no flaws that will effect this plan.

[mightymushroom]

There are Flaws that would make some people unable to do their part in the chain for non-alignment reasons.

Going down the list: Minimalist, Hazy, Blinkered(sorta), Lender, Magnetic, Intermittent, Wasteful, Afflicted(potentially), Unreliable, Corrupt, Tricksome.

I find it difficult to believe all of the town started with L1 powers, or advanced powers but missed that entire list.
For the plan to begin to work we would need a mass flawclaim, and I'm not sure I'm comfortable turning this into policy-lynch-the-flaws.
I agree with Vector:

This seems Not Fun :V

ninja'ed

[Caz]

Everyone who disagrees with The Plan must volunteer to get lynched, no backsies

[notquitethere]

MOD Question:
Spotlight can stack, right? If there's more than one spotlight each one will roll 50% for each action?

Correct.

[TricMagic]

FLOWERMAIDEN! Assassins, and to a lesser extent Doge and Thieves(On the first time before shields show up) can bypass such actions And level 2 Merchants can give out a Duel ability, which shields would stop from occurring, so you'd protect the mafia.. Monks can also delay an action so this plan has been flaed from the start Toonyman


I'd place the mafia team as Toonyman, Caz, and one other. No lynching day 1 offers no info to town.

Everyone who disagrees with The Plan must volunteer to get lynched, no backsies

Go die on a sword heretic. I already did so last game. Pretty easy way to get rid of town right?

[webadict]

I am against the plan on both principle and role-related reasons.

[ToonyMan]

@TricMagic:

Seriously. Are there any abilities to bypass protects, let me check real quick.

Sure, somebody could get poisoned or doped on Night 1 (not infected).

But they will know they were poisoned or doped and can claim tomorrow. Thus scum is outed.

This just relies on the town not being stupid. Scum and bad town players will want to cast doubt on this plan because it's really good, hehe.


@mightymushroom:

There are Flaws that would make some people unable to do their part in the chain for non-alignment reasons.
Going down the list: Minimalist, Hazy, Blinkered(sorta), Lender, Magnetic, Intermittent, Wasteful, Afflicted(potentially), Unreliable, Corrupt, Tricksome.
I find it difficult to believe all of the town started with L1 powers, or advanced powers but missed that entire list.
For the plan to begin to work we would need a mass flawclaim, and I'm not sure I'm comfortable turning this into policy-lynch-the-flaws.

I am 100% willing to claim any flaws if they affect this plan. I just happen to have none that do.

We can simply write down a list of players that can't do this plan because they are unlucky town or mafia.

I agree with Vector:

This seems Not Fun :V

ninja'ed

Too bad.


@Everyone:

Everyone who disagrees with The Plan must volunteer to get lynched, no backsies

I will vote anybody who opposes The Plan instead of no lynching. If you simply cannot follow the plan then make your voice heard and we will try to work around it. You don't need to claim anything but the flaw that is preventing it. I think that's worth the sacrifice.

MOD Question:
Spotlight can stack, right? If there's more than one spotlight each one will roll 50% for each action?

Correct.

Excellent.


PPE:

FLOWERMAIDEN! Assassins, and to a lesser extent Doge and Thieves(On the first time before shields show up) can bypass such actions And level 2 Merchants can give out a Duel ability, which shields would stop from occurring, so you'd protect the mafia.. Monks can also delay an action so this plan has been flaed from the start Toonyman

So what? Mafia need to out themselves to do anything you're mentioning here.

You're mafia or an idiot.

No lynching day 1 offers no info to town.

Wrong. Not in this case, our chance of lynching mafia on Day 2 instead is astronomically higher than today with The Plan.