Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[webadict]

Mephansteras: If a guard and a killing role both target a sneak who isn't home, does the guard get attacked.

No. Since the Sneak isn't attacked, the Guard's ability never activates.

[Mephansteras]

Mephansteras: If a guard and a killing role both target a sneak who isn't home, does the guard get attacked.

No. The kill is cancelled (rather than prevented), so the guard's ability isn't triggered.

[RoseHeart]

Sure. Who is the last Doppelganger?

I don't know. I feel you are the most dangerous if you are.

That answer isn't good enough. You need to find the last Doppelganger.

Neither is that reply, one you were the one I was bringing attention to. Of the two of us, you have the most clear path to victory.

[Caz]

If webadict is dopp, what's the explanation for no kill last night?

[RoseHeart]

If webadict is dopp, what's the explanation for no kill last night?

Only the mafia knows. What is the significance of this question?

[Luckyowl]

Well 4maskwolf told me that if the answer to that question is a no. Then that means the dopp tried to target web last night. He also said that it dammed Roseheart pointless N2 information.

and here is 4maskwolf whole arguement against Roseheart.

Alright fine I'll make webadict's case for him.

1. Roseheart's role is a much more powerful scum role than Juicebox's, so if Roseheart was scum it would make sense why the telepath was performing the NK (as compared to, say, someone like you, whose role requires no actions and would thus be a preferable killer for the dopps)
2. Roseheart refuses to provide N2 results as a role whose results are now irrelevant, which smacks of a scum who can't come up with a good fakeclaim (if I was roseheart I would have claimed investigating Caz)
3. Roseheart doesn't even appear to be reading the thread, pushing an agenda about how webadict is trying to lynch Caz next when webadict is Caz's staunchest defender and someone he actively confided in.
4. Even beyond the refusal to provide N2 results, Roseheart has just been really weird ever since Web accused him, and doesn't seem interested in finding scum so much as just not getting lynched. Even after web claimed something that was contrary to Roseheart's claim, Rose didn't start accusing or pushing him until Webadict basically demanded it.

On the off chance Roseheart isn't scum, I'd say Persus is the next most likely: his claims (protecting Juicebox then webadict) is a convenient claim for a dopp guard (actual actions: protecting Juicebox, attempting to kill webadict).

[TricMagic]

Alright. This is pissing me off.

Ask one simple sentence per person, and I will respond to it.


no lynch

I find it fun that this comes from me targeting a Sneak-claim I chose to chance. So a question becomes us. Why did you target webadict night 2?

nin.

You say that, but from what I recall you targeted me for investigation night one. Given the fluff, what did you find in my house?

[RoseHeart]

I don't think anything wolf has to say, is worthwhile evidence I am scum.

I'm not making any pushes because I am green and warry of agendas, and litterally, physically can't keep up with how this thread has been.

This pace we are going at now is nice. No question is off the table, and I will come out with any theory against me refuted or with any option to refute it.

[RoseHeart]

You say that, but from what I recall you targeted me for investigation night one. Given the fluff, what did you find in my house?

I met your dog. Good boy.

[TricMagic]

Well, that probably confirms his investigative ability. But damns him if webadict isn't pulling another ploy with role claims. As is, if rose is town, webadict is next on the list.

[webadict]

You say that, but from what I recall you targeted me for investigation night one. Given the fluff, what did you find in my house?

I met your dog. Good boy.

Actually, it's a girl, but yes.

[webadict]

I was the one in the Attic, rose.

[Caz]

The whole game of mafia is figuring out the alignment of players by their actions, arguments and available facts.

There is a good reason why there would be no kill if roseheart is dopp (webadict hid, and his claim d1 made him a very likely target)

No good reason why webadict wouldn't have killed, that I can see.

The roles as they are seem insanely townsided to me though. Theres probably an alien or something horrible coming around the corner.


Also why are we still wondering if roseheart is confirmed as a detective, i already investigated him and told for that even tho he couldnt claim his own role name correctly.

[webadict]

The whole game of mafia is figuring out the alignment of players by their actions, arguments and available facts.

There is a good reason why there would be no kill if roseheart is dopp (webadict hid, and his claim d1 made him a very likely target)

No good reason why webadict wouldn't have killed, that I can see.

The roles as they are seem insanely townsided to me though. Theres probably an alien or something horrible coming around the corner.


Also why are we still wondering if roseheart is confirmed as a detective, i already investigated him and told for that even tho he couldnt claim his own role name correctly.

Wait, then you saw me in roseheart's house, right?

[TricMagic]

You say that, but from what I recall you targeted me for investigation night one. Given the fluff, what did you find in my house?

I met your dog. Good boy.

Actually, it's a girl, but yes.

And this confirms webadict was there, she is a good girl.