Honestly, I thought this game was dead. I really don't know what's going on at all, except for this:
Update: Progressing. FYI. I actually lost my notes dedicated to who-found-what (and at one point, frankly, considered everyone random/insane) so I'm copying this to the end to add to save me effort.
N1:
*Jack A T: Tiruin, Mafia
*Tiruin: TDS, Town
*FallacyofUrist: Jack, Mafia
*kanoguti (BHK): origamiscienceguy, Town
*Bearshogun (TMS): Tiruin, Mafia
*TheDarkStar: Fallacy, Town
*juicebox: Fallacy, Mafia
N2:
*Jack A T: BHK, Mafia
*Tiruin: GA/UXLZ, Mafia
*kanoguti (BHK): ...?
*Bearshogun (TMS): BHK, Mafia
*TheDarkStar: Tiruin, Town
*juicebox: BHK, Mafia
And the Jack A T stuff here is correct.
...if sanity guarantees nothing, do we just play mountainous?
...What do you mean by your whole post there? That I'm Mafia? :v
...If this is a Mafia ruse, I'll both have a deadpan expression in seeing this being thrown out the window after Jack's performance earlier (if Mafia :v) and also pretty much be ":v".
Until I remembered you are replacing Jack.
So yeah. "Sanity" does guarantee something. However the problem is or was seeing my ideas as sane or insane in the first place--is what I've concluded when looking back. There WAS something weird with UXLZ--and nothing is coming forth on his side (and he's been lurking -_-) inclusive with him not making a visible stance towards it. [I could pretty much be a good scapegoat here, but there's a total lack of proactivity on all fronts lately...]
Jack was one of the first to make an anti-framer theory out there, something which I still find agreeable with in hindsight, and looking at Uxie's history--there was little to make him a major target of speculative investigation the day beforehand...if you don't mind GA's many mentions of how weird his role and persona has been, in many conflicting or contradictory statements. That however said, it makes Uxie a very good notice--that he isn't actually hidden Mafia.
...Given the lacking initiative of anyone else even talking about Uxie, I'm either inferring that the framer-esque person is either hiding or not drawing attention to the issue, or that there is a dislike towards the limelight being put onto him (Uxie could also be a good scapegoat here--nobody latched on, much. Probably other than me? :v)
And I'm the only one left alive who hadn't replaced out! @_@
BlackHeartKabal kanoguti TheBiggerFishie
Tiruin
GayArchaea UXLZ
Oragamiscienceguy vishdafish Starver
Jack A.T. TheWetSheep
The Moonlit Shadow BearShogun1692 Sprityo
But I voted vishdafishie, but he was under replacement, so my vote has vanished into reset'ness. I'm still leaning biasedly onto Starver, because either the theme of 'ONE GRAND POWERFUL FOE' comes up or 'TWO MAFIA' is the key. Either/or, TMS and Jack are linked given their initial dialogue and conversations early in the day as well as proceeding follow up.
It's either the pair or the single. :/ And we need FOUR PEOPLE to vote, sans any vote value/stealing shenanigans.
Starver: Can you list a fullclaim for yourself at this point in time?
Same goes with TWS and TBF.