Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[TheBiggerFish]

Could be the traditional role (usually atop another), but my reading is that it's possibly one-directional. This was mod-engineered, remember, not how it usually happens.

I have contradictory evidence.

That is, to the unidirectional theory.

[Starver]

Fair enough, but I'm willing to bet that there's a catch in there.

It doesn't really matter, on my current theory trajectory, as I don't intend to invoke anything surrounding it. Either way (or both!).

Though nobody other than you has answered my original post's questions, which is odd and may lead to suspicions.

[hector13]

I think it's reasonable for me to not answer that question.

[Starver]

If it means there are three of us (or four, with EP) who even know what I'm talking about, you have no worries from me.

Whichever version it is.

[Elephant Parade]

Our wincons state that we win if the Evil role is eliminated. Though this very heavily implies that such a role exists, it doesn't explicitly mean as much.

Also, I totally called this D2, though I was working with more information than anyone else.

No Lynch

[Tomasque]

Round Over - Town Wins!

Votecount
hector13 (0)
FallacyofUrist (0)
TheBiggerFish (0)
Starver (0)
Elephant Parade (0)
No Lynch (4) - Elephant Parade, FallacyofUrist, TheBiggerFish

 Not Voting: hector13, Starver


FallacyofUrist gets one victory point.
TheBiggerFish gets one victory point.
Starver gets one victory point.
hector13 gets one victory point.
Elephant Parade gets one victory point.

Spoiler: Player Roles (click to show/hide)

 

Preacher
"Tell me good sir, do you have room for god's LOVE? Has your heart the room for it, or must you confess first?"
Archetype: Investigative role
Wincon: You win if the Evil role is eliminated.

(n) Confession: Target must reveal their role to a person of their choice.

Hippie
"What's up with all that negativity? Just focus on the peace and LOVE, and we'll all be happy... man."
Archetype: Special Town role
Wincon: You win if the Evil roles are eliminated, or if you are alive at the end of day 3.

(a) Pacifist: Your no-lynch votes count double.

Parent
"I know, honey, it's just that I LOVE you and would hate for anything bad to happen to you."
Archetype: Town Weakness role
Wincon: You win if the Evil role is eliminated, or if you survive until the end of Day 3.
 SECRET: (n, 1-shot) Adopt: You must use this ability if the Lovers die. If target player dies, so do you.

Lover
"They just don't understand that we LOVE each other, but I know I can get it to work out!"
Archetype: Town Weakness role
Wincon: You win if the Evil role is eliminated, or if you survive until the end of Day 3.

(a) Heartbreak: If hector13 dies, so do you.

Lover
"We'll just run away then! Our LOVE will find a way!"
Archetype: Town Weakness role
Wincon: You win if the Evil role is eliminated, or if you survive until the end of Day 3.

(a) Heartbreak: If TheBiggerFish dies, so do you.

Spoiler: Action Log (click to show/hide)

 Night 0
FallacyofUrist confessionizes hector13
hector13 confesses to Elephant Parade

 Night 1
FallacyofUrist confessionizes Starver
Starver confesses to Elephant Parade

 Night 2
FallacyofUrist confessionizes TheBiggerFish
TheBiggerFish confesses to Starver

[Elephant Parade]

Huh, I figured that there were two pairs of one-way lovers.

[FallacyofUrist]

And of course, there's an ACTUAL hippy later in the game. Well then.
~~~
GG. Victory for everybody. Though the list of roles is a bit messed up when it comes to Hector.

[TheBiggerFish]

Huh, I figured that there were two pairs of one-way lovers.

There weren't.  I and hector were a two-way pair.  The formatting is all messed up.

[Elephant Parade]

Huh, I figured that there were two pairs of one-way lovers.

There weren't.  I and hector were a two-way pair.  The formatting is all messed up.

No—I meant that I thought that there were two pairs of one-way lovers, and was somewhat surprised when I turned out to be wrong.

[TheBiggerFish]

Huh, I figured that there were two pairs of one-way lovers.

There weren't.  I and hector were a two-way pair.  The formatting is all messed up.

No—I meant that I thought that there were two pairs of one-way lovers, and was somewhat surprised when I turned out to be wrong.

Ohhhh.

[Starver]

I rather thought it might be a chain, once I was sure that Fish knew what had been revealed to me.  Fish dies if Hector dies, Hector dies if (in one theory) EP dies, (maybe EP was Evil, even, except for the not entirely favourable stance, but relying upon now winning if the Evil role was eliminated), and the objective of the Efil one (either Fallacy, or using Fallacy's reports) was to use his one-shot surefire kill (day or night) to topple the whole lot of us by attacking the one person who would send the rest into freefall...  Like the Driver kill I had in the hitchhiker round.

I had considered a "secret lover" component for myself, but did throw that away away once Fish confirmed knowing about his Heartbreak.

I was somewhat disappointed not to get EP helping untangle things.  Hector I could understand, but I tried to make it not useful to reply to but not informatve without annoying my current knowledge that I obviously wasn't acting upon.  Fallacy didn't say much, but I'd asked an impossible question I realise, so no argument there.

I think Tomasque expected more paranoia.  But my paranoia (and not any wish to win by justvsitting it out, although it did resolve that way) went beyond that. Imagining that my voting could activate a form of Jester whose win would invalidate the rest of our wins... Or (not far from the truth) trigger a domino effect.

(When I first read the revealed roles, my brain 'autocorrected' Hector into the Moonlit slot. Only just realised, after the 4 ninja messages highlit this.)

[Starver]

Tomasque's probably upset that Town won, in a round with only Town in it, distracting him so... 

[hector13]

I had similar thoughts to Starver, worrying about the Evil role having to find the right domino to topple to get the rest of town.

Obviously having TBF and myself not ever wanting to go after one another would make it a little easier for us, but I wanted an evil role to murder horribly

[Tomasque]

Ey you put my name in place of hectors 0_o

I coulda understood mine in place of EP's but

I used a previous round-end as a template and I forgot to finish the changes 

Tomasque's probably upset that Town won, in a round with only Town in it, distracting him so... 

Not gonna lie - I wanted to see bloodshed here.