Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[FallacyofUrist]

Thus, the waiting game. In which we wait for him to return.

Thankfully, we have, literally, days of time to wait(if we have to).
Hm. fillipk, any reasons you have of your own for jumping on the bandwagon?

[TheDarkStar]

It certainly feels like a bandwagon on Moonlit, since one of the major persecutors of him (me) isn't even voting him, and the other (FoU) expressed it as a pressure vote.  Otherwise people have kinda just gone 'well okay' and voted him.

Given two scumteams, a bandwagon is pretty much unavoidable every day for the first few days.

[FallacyofUrist]

righttt... this is going to add so many layers of thought. So much confusion.

The Moonlit Shadow and fillipk, please respond.

[kilakan]

It certainly feels like a bandwagon on Moonlit, since one of the major persecutors of him (me) isn't even voting him, and the other (FoU) expressed it as a pressure vote.  Otherwise people have kinda just gone 'well okay' and voted him.

Given two scumteams, a bandwagon is pretty much unavoidable every day for the first few days.

Than in your opinion is the bandwagon indicative of who could be scum?  Do you think those who jumped on the wagon are more likely to be scum, or less likely?  What is your favorite icecream, vanilla, chocolate or furred?

[kilakan]

righttt... this is going to add so many layers of thought. So much confusion.

The Moonlit Shadow and fillipk, please respond.

As long as no one kills me the first night i am very intrigued to see how the two scum teams and the town end up working this out.  However I still think night one kills will probably be me and you.  Based solely on the fact that there is a minimal amount of scum hunting happening from the others.

[fillipk]

Thus, the waiting game. In which we wait for him to return.

Thankfully, we have, literally, days of time to wait(if we have to).
Hm. fillipk, any reasons you have of your own for jumping on the bandwagon?

first off give me more then a half an hour to respond I'm not always on.

Second I am jumping on the bandwagon because the moonlit shadow is the other suspicious person and an easier one to lynch, later we can always go back and get Roo when we have more information.

[Arcvasti]

Thus, the waiting game. In which we wait for him to return.

Thankfully, we have, literally, days of time to wait(if we have to).
Hm. fillipk, any reasons you have of your own for jumping on the bandwagon?

first off give me more then a half an hour to respond I'm not always on.

Second I am jumping on the bandwagon because the moonlit shadow is the other suspicious person and an easier one to lynch, later we can always go back and get Roo when we have more information.

Yeah, if I had to vote now, based on the information I currently possess, I'd lynch The Moonlit Shadow. Roo is kinda suspicious too, but not as overtly or immediately suspicious. Not sure whether ["They" being The Moonlit Shadow, not Roo]their suspiciousness is from being new to Mafia or being a scum. My personal theory is that its both, but I've got little besides gut instinct and dubious "evidence" to support it.

[Varee]

Well why are you guys taking RVs so seriously. Many people (including me) barely even posted much and it not lynch Roo or lynch TMS.

@Doctor. So about your theory on me being scum, do you still believe that after the day's discussion? Also why didn't you put a second vote on someone during RVS and believe in your randomiser?

Varee

PS am just pointing out there is other option.

[Comrade Shamrock]

First of all, holy cow this has started!

Second of all, what the hell is going on here?! Just because he's not responding doesn't mean you can't question the others on something, anything.

filipk:
What kind of of reasoning is this?

Second I am jumping on the bandwagon because the moonlit shadow is the other suspicious person and an easier one to lynch, later we can always go back and get Roo when we have more information.

What kind of reason is that?

Sigh this is why I don't always play mafia games because of the day one lynch or no lynch, anyway I've been right more times then wrong so I'm not second guessing myself, if you can find a way to save yourself go ahead but my gut is telling me Roo is scum.

What makes you think Roo was scum in the first place? First apparently it was just a OMGUS (self-admitted) vote and then it stuck. If you thought he was bad there should have been something to make you think that way. This is as vague as you can get.

Persus:

Hello Everyone, there's a lot of faces I don't know here. What's your experience with Mafia prior to this game, and do you have any experience with Bay12 mafia?

6 games on bay12. 4 scum games, 2 town. Plus whatever I have now.

What are your feelings on the situation?

[FallacyofUrist]

Second I am jumping on the bandwagon because the moonlit shadow is the other suspicious person and an easier one to lynch, later we can always go back and get Roo when we have more information.

... you have got to be kidding me. That isn't a reason, that's "KILL HIM NOW!" logic. What is even... I don't even...
Seriously? Even a noob could know not to say that! You voted him partially because he's easier to lynch? You do realize scum focus on easy lynches. I'm going to unvote The Moonlit Shadow(for the moment) and apply a nice shiny pressure vote fillipk. Honestly, the reasons people use these days!

The bandwagon on the Moonlit Shadow has served its main purpose now: Scum Bait. And, good sirs, fillipk walked right into it.

[fillipk]

Looking back now I realized I messed up but that's the same reason why I'm town, as someone pointed out scum tend to stay quiet and avoid drawing attention to themselves for the exact reason of me, they get noticed and could be lynched which is dangerous to them since there are like 2 on each team.

The reason I jumped on the bandwagon was so we had a day 1 lynch and moved on, we have no info besides what people post anyway is just as good as say picking someone who hasn't posted at all, Roo and the Moonlit Shadow got jumped on by me, because Roo voted me, probably randomly so I admit I overreacted, voting Moonlit Shadow was me trying to end the day so we could get more information, I'm not 100% new to mafia which is why I hate the first day and want to lynch someone and get over it.

[FallacyofUrist]

...

I hate the first day and want to lynch someone and get over it.

I'm going to let anyone who wants to read that be the judge of how scummy(absurd) that is. Have you heard of the concept of a "Hammer" in mafia, fillipk?

[fillipk]

to be honest no I've seen it mentioned but not really honestly you can go ahead and lynch me I'll enjoy watching this to see how my side, the town, can pull it off.

[FallacyofUrist]

... in my last finished game I learned a bit about the "trying too hard to appear town" tell. You've already claimed town(effectively), fillipk, why do you emphasize it?

[fillipk]

last ditch effort to save my life?  I've seen this situation before where its really hard to appear innocent my only defense is that I'm acting like a stereotypical town in my first bay 12 mafia game.