Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Urist McCoder]

my only experience is from reading through one or two of the previous bms.

[FallacyofUrist]

The immediate vote for hiddenleafguy wouldn't work as a defense in more advanced games with more advanced players, but I agree that here it might have worked. Might.

Okay, notquitethere, start talking before we lynch your head off. Notquitethere, please respond.
Sorry for assaulting you if you are town, but you and hiddenleafguy reek of scum. For that matter, that first vote there just makes you seem more scummy.

Okay everybody, NQT and hiddenleafguy are the scum team. Or at least I believe they are.

(Er... how can I put more pressure on NQT? The only things I can do to him are posting and voting, and more posts might serve the opposite purpose of what I intend. And my vote's already on him.)

___
Response to Graknorke:

This is my first game of forum mafia. I have however read several pages worth of mafia theory at the wiki. And many, many, interesting and complex non-beginner games have also been read by me here in the pursuit of knowledge.

While I'm at it, Graknorke, I'm going to recommend that you vote for NQT(notquitethere) and later hiddenleafguy as a result of evidence posted by me and Urist McCoder.

[Graknorke]

Wait I missed that last one up. Meant to ask if you're sure your mask isn't green. Because it's like The Incredible Hulk. But now that I missed the proper window and had to explain the joke it's not funny anymore.

[FallacyofUrist]

... minor scumtell there. Eh. Carry on.

Are you going to vote or not?

[Urist McCoder]

fallacyofurist I didn't realiz your vote was already on NQT

[Urist McCoder]

at this point I really want to hear from NQT

[FallacyofUrist]

Point ho. One vote on NQT isn't enough pressure.

Come on, people, vote for the guy, let's get him hurting! Let's get him talking!

[Graknorke]

FallcyofUrist, it shouldn't be expected of you to outright tell someone else who to vote for. Honestly your entire thing comes across to me as an attempt to domineer the path of the game with minimal justification. So far all we have is hiddenleafguy having very little idea how to play Mafia, and you accusing an IC of being scum.

[FallacyofUrist]

Okay.
First up, please spell my username correctly.
Second up: I'm telling people to vote NQT because I think he's scum. I don't think that telling other people who to vote for is a bad thing. This isn't a game where votes can be forced onto people with role abilities. Make your own choices, just note that I want you to vote for NQT.
Third up: This whole thing may be invalidated when NQT gives a response... or just made more valid instead.
Fourth up: oi you, perhaps defending your scum partner? You've given me something to think about.

NQT and hiddenleafguy? Or NQT and Graknorke?

Fifth up, if you'll read the op you'll notice that IC players have the same chance of being scum as any other. Some past games have even had both ICs be scum. Bad luck, those.

[Urist McCoder]

graknorke makes an interesting point and you are coming off as a little bit scummy fallacyofurist

you posted while I was typing fallacyofurist so what I said above seems even more true now.

[FallacyofUrist]

hm. I suggest you read my reasoning.

Look. If I was scum, I wouldn't be dumb enough to directly attack an IC(or if I was the other scum would likely advise against it).

Welp.

[Urist McCoder]

Look. If I was scum, I wouldn't be dumb enough to directly attack an IC(or if I was the other scum would likely advise against it).

WIFOM much

[Graknorke]

Fifth up, if you'll read the op you'll notice that IC players have the same chance of being scum as any other. Some past games have even had both ICs be scum. Bad luck, those.

Aye, but NQT was really just doing IC things. Asking lots of questions to try and prompt people to discuss things. It's hardly suspicious in itself.

Second up: I'm telling people to vote NQT because I think he's scum. I don't think that telling other people who to vote for is a bad thing. This isn't a game where votes can be forced onto people with role abilities. Make your own choices, just note that I want you to vote for NQT.

You can't just say to vote for someone though. You need to actually reason it out. Your evidence is flimsy and everything after it looks to be trying to quickly drum up support for your proposal before anyone really critically thinks about it.

Fourth up: oi you, perhaps defending your scum partner? You've given me something to think about.

If we're looking at scum teams, you jumped on Urist McCoder's vote pretty quickly, and since you began piling on NQT he's agreed with everything you've said as well. At least, up until right now where there's a chance of you coming under scrutiny. Coincidence? Probably not. I feel like one of you is a disgrace to Luchadore-kind, and right now you're looking like the more dangerous of the two with your attempts at quickly dictating a common consensus.

[Urist McCoder]

I don't quite understand what you mean buy the other IC would advise against it fallacyOfurist

[Urist McCoder]

wow reading back through that me and fallacyofurist really do look like a scum team