Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Silthuri]

Commencing read-through tomorrow morning. I've got a few things to get done for school tomorrow because work and severe RL issues have held me up all weekend.

[Cheeetar]

Unvote TDS.

TDS: You played in the first GBU game. What has changed between this version of the game and that version of the game that makes you feel so uncertain in how we should treat the third parties?

4maskwolf: What reason would town have for not wanting to establish a consistent approach to dealing with the third parties?

[4maskwolf]

4maskwolf: What reason would town have for not wanting to establish a consistent approach to dealing with the third parties?

The scum are actually in more of a position to want the third-parties gone, since they have more to lose from shooting the ugly or getting shot by the bad.  So I say we leave them to do their own thing and focus on the actual task of finding scum.

[Silthuri]

Pfp

Silthuri.

Unvote.

Curse college and its never ending work!

[4maskwolf]

Hmm...

Everyone: Ask the player beneath you in the list a question.  Last player in the list, ask the first player a question.

TheDarkStar: What makes you so uncertain about the third-parties.  Why do you feel that they are important?  Don't you think it's more important to find scum?  Do you believe that the town power roles could be helpful in the gameplay?  And, most importantly, how's your quicktopic going?

[origamiscienceguy]

Tiruin, Which person in this group do you think has shown the most aggressive and reserved tactics so far?

[Cheeetar]

4maskwolf: What reason would town have for not wanting to establish a consistent approach to dealing with the third parties?

The scum are actually in more of a position to want the third-parties gone, since they have more to lose from shooting the ugly or getting shot by the bad.  So I say we leave them to do their own thing and focus on the actual task of finding scum.

And this means town should not have a consistent approach to dealing with third parties because...?

[4maskwolf]

4maskwolf: What reason would town have for not wanting to establish a consistent approach to dealing with the third parties?

The scum are actually in more of a position to want the third-parties gone, since they have more to lose from shooting the ugly or getting shot by the bad.  So I say we leave them to do their own thing and focus on the actual task of finding scum.

And this means town should not have a consistent approach to dealing with third parties because...?

Because every game is different, every situation is different, and it's pointless to fuss over the future.

[TheDarkStar]

TDS: You played in the first GBU game. What has changed between this version of the game and that version of the game that makes you feel so uncertain in how we should treat the third parties?

It's been a long time since the first GBU and I died early enough in that game that I didn't see how things went (except for the final result, of course).

TheDarkStar: What makes you so uncertain about the third-parties.  Why do you feel that they are important?  Don't you think it's more important to find scum?  Do you believe that the town power roles could be helpful in the gameplay?  And, most importantly, how's your quicktopic going?

They are important because some of them have kills and all of them have votes. To me, scum is more important. Except for the Guardsman, the town power roles are marginally useful at best. And of course, my quicktopic is fine . How's your's?

[Cheeetar]

4maskwolf: What reason would town have for not wanting to establish a consistent approach to dealing with the third parties?

The scum are actually in more of a position to want the third-parties gone, since they have more to lose from shooting the ugly or getting shot by the bad.  So I say we leave them to do their own thing and focus on the actual task of finding scum.

And this means town should not have a consistent approach to dealing with third parties because...?

Because every game is different, every situation is different, and it's pointless to fuss over the future.

This is a very poor argument for thinking that discussing best practices is scummy, 4maskwolf.

[4maskwolf]

Now that's just blatant misrepresentation.  I never said it was scummy, I said it was a waste of time and we should focus on scumhunting,

[4maskwolf]

Oh, and TDS, mine is quite good, although it's lonely with only me in there.

Yes, I created a quicktopic so I could talk to myself about the game.  What of it?

[Peradon]

Silthuri: When is your schedule open? (just asking this to fulfill 4mask's request.... I really dont have anything to ask you.)

4mask: Are you saying that we should not look for 3rd parties at all? Not even the Bad, which is basically a SK?

[4maskwolf]

I'm saying that at the moment, the scum are the town's concern, not the third-parties.  They can sort themselves out well enough.

[Cheeetar]

Probability of 4maskwolf being a third party rising...