Extend as well.
NQT:
Toast
Important: I define "scum" as "anti-town" instead of "Mafia team."
OK. I'm town though and have never claimed otherwise. On what basis do you make your attack? You've never denied being a necromancer or ghoul, should I vote you for that?
I think the basis is quite clear; you were asked twice if you were third party and both times did not respond. That's a huge attention-grabber for me.
I didn't say I wasn't because no one asked me. (Since you will) No, I am not third party. No, I am not scum. Yes, I am town.
I'm not basing my scum reads primarily on player's reads: those reads just present starting points for cases and a judge of player engagement which is the strongest town tell.
So are most played non-engaged? How does that affect your methodology?
No, most players are moderately engaged and some players are only lightly engaged. It's not just the reads I look at, but also (mostly) the cases people actually press.
Alrighty, but your definition of engagement isn't coming across well.
Unvote NQT. I still don't trust you a bit and wouldn't lament your demise a bit, but there's better targets. That said...
ZU
NQT I'm basically 100% sure is SK or at least anti-town. I'm not prioritizing SK over cult because no one's given me convincing evidence that a cult exists. The only evidence is "no NK" which could be explained by so many other factors.
This is a Supernatural game with no kill on the first night and you're not concerned about a cult? Essentially what you're saying is that there's a necromancer/ghoul who was messing with bodies last night while the scum team had their kill protected against. Is there any other possibility other than cult?
I don't see how the underlined bit is relevant to what you're saying at all.
TheWetSheep is doing everything he can to avoid being in the limelight and not commit; the kind of behavior I expect from a cult leader.
Toony:
@Toaster:
Toony: So where's the Toony Tunnel on ZU?
Hmmm?
Your world-famous tunnel attack you unleash on people. I have yet to see anything like that level of commitment out of you this game. What's going on?
Hapah:
Anyone who has been in Supernaturals before or read the previous ones: Have there ever been instances of people with multiple roles? Not like a Cult Sexton (since I think Cult is just an alignment thing and not an ability thing in and of itself), but something like a Sexton-Sage or similar.
No. You're also correct about the alignment being just alignment and not an ability- we've had Cult Sextons, Vampire Warlocks, and Werewolf Priests, as well as town versions of all three.
Flabort:
Meph(+Toaster) Since it shows who edited a post last, could Meph spoiler Toaster's big jarring image? It clashes horribly with the dark background.
I probably should have shrunk that a bit more; sorry about that.
Toaster Why do specifically suspect the four people you do? Have any of your other reads changed since last time you posted them?
Toaster, Jim What about NQT and Persus justifies your votes?
Sheep I covered in my
last post, plus the bit above where I vote him. Toony is also above; basically, he's being quiet and thoughtful for a player who is typically loud and in-your-face. You I also covered in my
last post. NQT is wholly visible above- I could see him either as SK or at least part of a conversion-cult.
TheWetSheep, Hapah, ZU, Persus, IG Is it crazy that I suspect Toaster and Jim of being a scum team together? Is my case against either of them stupid or unconvincing? What are your feelings on Jim? On Toaster?
It's worth pointing out that Jim and I are best Mafia e-bros, and we always treat each other like that.
Ottofar and
Persus:
Flabort, rolefishing, buddying and lampshading. Just migrained, will post a real post in the evening.
Extend.
Extend.
I'll post more later today, but I'm sticking to flabort for now, for saying odd things.
You both damn well better use the extend time.
I hate to say anything pro-IG, but it occurs to me that we have a known dead serial killer, an almost-certain living one, a likely conversion-cult, and whatever IG is. What are the odds that we have
four anti-town factions? A bit low, I'd say. IG's not a friend, but he may indeed just be an annoyance rather than a threat.