Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Imperial Guardsman]

Roleclaim here.
Im a cannibal.
I kill my target and steal one of their abilities. Unless a doctor fesses up and claimed a protect on DS last night, TheDarkStar is the PRINCE MAFIA!

[TheDarkStar]

Roleclaim here.
Im a cannibal.
I kill my target and steal one of their abilities. Unless a doctor fesses up and claimed a protect on DS last night, TheDarkStar is the PRINCE MAFIA!

Considering that I'm about to be modkilled, that should be easy to test.

Also, you could have been redirected.

[Silthuri]

First off, I'd like to role claim. I am an Angel. I was the one who protected TDS last night.

NQT:

Everyone - why didn't you  break the tie yesterday? So, my excuse is that I wasn't about to post at the end of day. I'm not sure MOWE and Flabort have that excuse.

This isn't really a reason, but the tie just didn't register in my brain, as my brain is mush during the morning or within the first 3-4 hours of waking up.

Flabort:

Flabort:

MOWE is not as strong a player to be hiding scumminess right now.

I'm confused as to what you're trying to say here. Am I not strong enough to be a good scum player and thus I would be radiating scumminess if I were scum? How did you arrive at this conclusion?   

As far as I've seen, without getting game specific, and from other player's reactions to my prior question, if you were scum in this game, it WOULD be more obvious. Are you upset that I can't detect a trace of scummitude from you?

I don't mind you not finding me scummy, because I'm not scum. My issue is with you going so far as to say when I'm scum, I'm obviscum.

Short on time. Will post more tomorrow.

[TheWetSheep]

I WANT TO ROLECLAIM.
I am a purple goo. If you target me, you will be a purple goo and I will be you.
I used to be... a MUP confused 50% PGO. If you targeted me, you had a 50% chance of dying; if I targeted you, I did something random to you.
TheWetSheep is town. Which confirms that you do not have a vote-based action. However, TWS is also a MUP confused 50% PGO.

I'll confirm this, I was Purple Goo, am now MUP 50% confused PGO.

NQT

Unvote

Don't have time, but will tomorrow.

[flabort]

Imperial Gaurdsman, why should I believe you about Dark Star?
The Dark Star, why SHOULDN'T I believe Gaurdsman?

[Imperial Guardsman]

Imperial Gaurdsman, why should I believe you about Dark Star?
The Dark Star, why SHOULDN'T I believe Gaurdsman?

Because when Im maf, I rarely lie, I like to manipluate others to my best ability. Also, a rolecop on me could entirely screw me, too.

[TheWetSheep]

Looks like NQT is mafia.

I'm not, because I was inspected.
Flabort isn't, since he is confirmed to have inspected me.
MOWE's not, because she is confirmed to have protected TDS.
IG is probably not, because that would be a ridiculous fakeclaim.
TDS could be, but will probably be modkilled so it doesn't matter.

That leaves only NQT.

[notquitethere]

Sheep

Looks like NQT is mafia.

I'm not, because I was inspected.
Flabort isn't, since he is confirmed to have inspected me.
MOWE's not, because she is confirmed to have protected TDS.
IG is probably not, because that would be a ridiculous fakeclaim.
TDS could be, but will probably be modkilled so it doesn't matter.

That leaves only NQT.

I like your attempt at reasoning things through here, but there are so many possibilities you're not considering:

First, you assume that the kill was a deliberate mafia attack, which is something we simply don't know at this stage.

You're right that Flabort MUP'd you. A potentially fatal move with plenty of plausible deniability.

IG might be telling the truth and still be the Prince: he could have attempted to kill Darkstar and when, during the day, he noticed someone else is a killer he decided to claim.

As you say, TDS may be the killer, and he might be replaced rather than modkilled so maybe we shouldn't be so quick to rule him out.

MOWE might be a Golem, automatically protecting TDS, leaving her free to night kill.

You could be a ninja.

ROLE CLAIM

I'm an amnesiac and I asked Persus to give me a totally random role, so I've no idea what I am. Understandably, I did nothing last night. However, my role might have had some terrible auto attached to it (perhaps accounting for the kill?), I won't know until I regain my memories.


Night Plan Time

We've got enough claims to attempt a proper co-ordinated night plan.

MOWE can protect Flabort, so Flabort the goo can confirm MOWE's role
TheWetSheep should MUP me: that should either Inspect of Kill me, showing everyone my alignment either way


Darkstar is presumably modkilled today
The too-dangerous-to-live Imperial Guardsman should be lynched today

Hopefully one of them will be scum, if not we'll find out through the Plan and know who to lynch on Day 3.

[flabort]

MUPing you would also have the possibility of roleblocking or doing nothing, which would mean your alignment is NOT revealed.

[notquitethere]

Roleblocking would still work with the plan, but yeah, the 1/4 chance of doing nothing isn't great. Do you have a better plan?

[TheWetSheep]

Haha. No.

You cannot pick 'Cult-type', 'Secret', 'Psychotic', 'Amnesiac', or 'Mystery' roles.

Also, why would you?

I like your attempt at reasoning things through here, but there are so many possibilities you're not considering:

First, you assume that the kill was a deliberate mafia attack, which is something we simply don't know at this stage.

You're right that Flabort MUP'd you. A potentially fatal move with plenty of plausible deniability.

IG might be telling the truth and still be the Prince: he could have attempted to kill Darkstar and when, during the day, he noticed someone else is a killer he decided to claim.

As you say, TDS may be the killer, and he might be replaced rather than modkilled so maybe we shouldn't be so quick to rule him out.

MOWE might be a Golem, automatically protecting TDS, leaving her free to night kill.

You could be a ninja.

We do know it was a Mafiakill, since everyone has claimed and nobody has claimed that kill. There's only the extremely improbable possibility that it's you.

Your reasoning on flabort doesn't work. Why wouldn't he kill me and claim his mup rolled kill?

IG's doesn't work with the unaccounted kill.

TDS: sure, but let's not lynch him yet.

MOWE/me: That's just really improbable. You being mafia is much more probable.

Night Plan Time

We've got enough claims to attempt a proper co-ordinated night plan.

MOWE can protect Flabort, so Flabort the goo can confirm MOWE's role
TheWetSheep should MUP me: that should either Inspect of Kill me, showing everyone my alignment either way


Darkstar is presumably modkilled today
The too-dangerous-to-live Imperial Guardsman should be lynched today

Hopefully one of them will be scum, if not we'll find out through the Plan and know who to lynch on Day 3.

No.

You are by far the most likely mafia, so we lynch you. It's not lylo; why are you so averse to being lynched?

[Imperial Guardsman]

TDS dies from modkill and NQT just made an IMPOSIBLE claim. Unvote TDS, NQT

[Silthuri]

NQT

I believe that you are the most likely scum.

I think it was highly probable that ToonyMan was killed by mafia. No one claimed to have killed him, which is what someone would have done, presumably, if they had killed him. Not to mention that killing a really good player is a scum thing. You're trying to send attention elsewhere by pointing out ways in which everyone could be lying.

[notquitethere]

Pfp- my claim isn't impossible. Just like last round Persus has decided to nerf my role by making me an amnesiac. I was an amnesiac before and, unlikely as it sounds, I am again.

OP is out of date as you all should know as there are no banned roles in Prince mafia, ask Persus if you like. Hell, I'll do it:

Mod, are there banned roles in Prince mafia?

I'm adverse to being mislynched because I know it's a mislynch.

Sheep, you make a good point about Flabort's MUP'ing, but the rest still stands.

IG, read the last round I was in and you'll see this isn't an impossible claim.

MOWE, I can see why you'd think that but I don't believe you've really appreciated all the possibilities here. Also, you're talking exactly how a Golem would talk: what have you got against having your role confirmed?

Incidentally, I'm not pulling the amnesiac thing out of thin air: I breadcrumbed it in my first post today, as you can see by looking at the first letter of each sentence.

[4maskwolf]

Mod, can you send me a list of currently active players and players in the waitlist so I can update the OP?  Thanks.