Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Jack A T]

Also, TheDarkStar, you never said why you jumped in to answer a question aimed at Tack.  Would you mind telling me why you did so?

[mastahcheese]

mastahcheese: If you are willing to do so, would you mind telling us who your assorted target ideas were and why you planned to target them?

Well, I was going to hold off for a bit on that, since there are 3 sappers, me, Leafsnail, and (if TDS is telling the truth) former-objective.
I was going to keep it a secret, but now that I think I'm not going to be counter-sapped by scum, I'll tell you.

I Day Sapped Leafsnail, he was telling the truth, I have the full 8 points that he had, he was telling the truth on that.
I sapped him so I could get the points before scum came along and did so, and I used my 2 scans on 4maskwolf and The DarkStar.
4mask has 1 point, not surprising.
But there is something interesting.

TheDarkStar: Care to tell me how you got those 4 points if you only just now got the sap?

[Jack A T]

TheDarkStar: Care to tell me how you got those 4 points if you only just now got the sap?

mastahcheese: Much as I dislike taking questions directed to others, having 4 points fits TheDarkStar's claim.  5 points to start + Merc, Miller, Hardcore, Dense = 9 points.  Changeling costs 4, leaving 5.  No gain overnight due to Dense, and the use of Changeling costs 1 point due to Merc.

[Leafsnail]

TDS: it's really bizarre that you're joining Tack in banging the TACK IS CONFIRMED TOWN drum.  As if it's impossible that Jack AT (who publically targeted Tack) was converted, or that Tack (a claimed cop) was converted, or that the incredibly vague flavour cop could mean something else.  Also I'm not trying to get him lynched, I'm just saying he's clearly scum.

[Tack]

You liar. I went off on a TANGENT on how I thought Miller would be a dumb idea.

I will be surprised if you flip town, Tack.

Hmm.
That's NativeForeigner's list.
If you look back at my last-completed list, you aren't on it.

Nice attempt to start a bandwagon though. Those three bloodthirsty voters would've jumped right on, considering the "every man for himself" attitude I'm getting from this townteam.

[Jack A T]

Tack: Why Native?  Why no vote?

Tack: I am aware the game has changed since I asked you these.  However, you never answered them.  Would you be so kind as to do so?
Also, you're being a twit.  Stop it.

Tack: My questions.

[Tawa]

You liar. I went off on a TANGENT on how I thought Miller would be a dumb idea.

I will be surprised if you flip town, Tack.

Hmm.
That's NativeForeigner's list.
If you look back at my last-completed list, you aren't on it.

Nice attempt to start a bandwagon though. Those three bloodthirsty voters would've jumped right on, considering the "every man for himself" attitude I'm getting from this townteam.

What?

Oh, that's Foreigner's list.

Sorry 'bout that, Tack.

Anyway...

NATIVEFOREGINER, I WILL BE SURPRISED IF YOU FLIP TOWN!

[Tack]

Dear god Tawarochir, aren't you playing the 'VI' card a bit hàrd?

Jack A T
I'm pretty sure I answered those first-day questions, but ok.
Native was inactive on the first day, plus your name in red makes you quick to reply, usually.
The non-vote before then was because it was the first day and I didn't have enough information to make informed decisions. Therefore I non-voted, because better that than starting a bandwagon on a random.

Leafsnail I 'threw away' cop by claiming because at that point I had equal amount of votes as P-Luke and was getting gangbanged by questions. I figured if I got lynched I'd only be hurting my team, but if I got night killed, I'd be 'wasting' a kill- this being because as a townie my investigative skill isn't up to par, and I realize that.

But right now I feel that I'm being a bad townie, and you're being a good scum. You've made every perfect step since being forced to claim, and you seem sure in your belief you'll finish the day without being lynched.

Jim my flavour inspect had me appear as town, and I wouldn't have had the points to buy innocent if I'd gone scumcop.
Ego complex- I have no idea. I thought cops were a big deal. Every other 'strong' power is like a shot in the dark- like leafsnail's badly aimed recycle, if his town claim is even right.
But again, I said before the game that I'm generally bad at mafia. So I may have overestimated the importance of my role.


So, to use the 'logic' and 'widely available' information which Jim so hates.
If the changeling took objective's innocent, and gave objective his miller, rendering them both moot:
That means that every scum took innocent.
It also means that there's one miller claim where there isn't a miller anymore.
Two, if we count Tawarochir apparently crying uncle.

Which leaves us with two scum on the miller side, one scum being objective, and one on the non-miller side.

So by law of plausibility, unless NativeForeigner is a scum fortune teller for whatever reason, and as if Tawarochir was scum it would be silly to put himself under the spotlight, Then MyOwnWorstEnemy is the other scum.

But that's making a lot of assumptions on the hearsay of a lot of equally suspicious people, so I'm pretty loathe to back it up.

[Tawa]

"VI"?

[Tack]

"Village Idiot"
Or are you going to vote me for calling you that?

[Tack]

EBWOP
Also I'm terrified of the idea of having a scum fortune teller.

[Tawa]

What?

I'm not going to vote for that.

Although it is a bit insulting that you'd think I'd vote you for that.

[TheDarkStar]

TDS: it's really bizarre that you're joining Tack in banging the TACK IS CONFIRMED TOWN drum.  As if it's impossible that Jack AT (who publically targeted Tack) was converted, or that Tack (a claimed cop) was converted, or that the incredibly vague flavour cop could mean something else.  Also I'm not trying to get him lynched, I'm just saying he's clearly scum.

How is he "clearly scum"? I see a big jump from "possibly converted" to "scum for sure". Also, what was your reason for recycling him?

Also, why aren't you trying to get scum lynched? Because Objective is the non-converting non-recycling scum, it's important to lynch either of the other two first. What's your reasoning?

[TheDarkStar]

Also, TheDarkStar, you never said why you jumped in to answer a question aimed at Tack.  Would you mind telling me why you did so?

I answered it for two reasons: First, I was pointing out a flaw in his logic. Also, I was trying to remind people that I am still here.

[4maskwolf]

You know what I hate about games like this?

Some people pay too much attention to the meta of the game and not enough attention to the scumhunting.