Cheeetar:
Alright. Going back on my earlier statement that I would execute who I thought was scum as soon as I was certain- I'm going to be executing Jim. Yes, he's a terrific mafia player and he'd be a fantastic boon to town if he was town- the only problem is that he hasn't been a boon as far as I've seen. He's barely been scumhunting and he's been on the lower end of activity in terms of posting. I'm supposed to expect more from him as town, and if he's not done much at all then it's easy to see him as scum trying to slip by unnoticed. Jim: If you are town, use this time to put something concrete down in terms of suspicions. If you flip as town, then we have somebody we know is good at the game and we know we can trust who's laid down very useful Day 1 stuff to work off of... as long as you actually do post usable stuff.
While I sort of get what you're saying, this is like some sort of retrograde appeal to authority in "He's good but not saying much; he must be SCUM!" I don't agree with that logic. Scumhunting across the board has been low, so trying to lynch because you say that one player isn't contributing enough just isn't going to cut it. This choice really seems very arbitrary when compared to the other people with plenty of experience who are contributing less.
I was worried that people who had day activities might use them in attempt to stop the lynch or redirect it. If it happens, though, I suppose that'll be the next King's worry.
Somehow I find this hard to believe.
There will be no time between me making a decision to execute somebody and them being executed. Judgement shall be swift to all traitors. I will, however, let all those I suspect present a case as to their innocence.
What happened to this?
Toaster - A bit of scumhunting, suspicious of me (but everybody seems to be looking at me odd now).
I suspected you before it was cool.
Caz:
Everyone
Would like your thoughts on lynching Jim. Does anyone actually think this is a good idea?
I don't really have any scum reads on Jim, so I can't say I'm in favor.
Persus and
Urist I: Who would you lynch today? I want at least one name that isn't Cheeetar.
Tiruin:
I can vouch for Imp that she sent me a message that she was experiencing residential problems (like, water. Molds. Bad piping. :X)
Sent
you a message? Not the mod or the thread, but in your quicktopic?
Some general reads, since all the cool kids are doing it. If a name isn't listed, there's no real read.
Cheeetar: Poor choice of lynch with poor reasoning. Playing his cards very close to his chest for someone in such a public position.
Caz: Not much concrete here, but is pinging my gut.
Urist I: Has
exactly one post with any real content in it. This is suspiciously low.*
Jim: While I don't have much to say for or against Jim, I don't think his lynch is a good iea.
SBC: I'm feeling new town on this one.
*Cheeetar, why doesn't this ping you? UI is fairly experienced as well.