The question was more, why exactly did you say "traitor" in singular? It isn't like "enemy" or "scum" where they have the same plural and singular forms, while it's typical for a mostly-vanilla 12-person game to have 3 mafia. Meanwhile, you say "traitor" as in "serial killer" or the like.
Never really thought the wording was crucial. If you're trying to say it's some kind of scum slip (I don't see how as Urist just confirmed in the flavour that there are traitors), it's not.
No, I'm saying that you're possibly an assassin (serial killer), which would definitely explain the slip. Of course, it could be a mistyping, but you can never know for sure.
I don't like this RVS question after RVS ended.
Does RVS have a time limit?
and
makeinu: If you were scum and picked as king, who would you try to get lynched and why?
I don't like this RVS question after RVS ended.
Do you earnestly believe there's enough material on the floor to make informed decisions about who is scum and why? If so- who do you think is scum, and why?
As I was told before, RVS ends when people start getting suspicions. And that asking random questions after there's a sizable amount of content is created seems to be lazy. Asking
random questions is "lazy" because you should be asking questions to people who have done something not-to-par. We don't have enough material for pinning the scum tag on anyone, however pinning the "watch this guy" tag is definitely possible.
What are other people's thoughts on the thing about multiple factions?
As I said, I'm pretty sure we have more than one faction with a chat.
How'd you get to this conclusion? Also stop using the tongue smiley so much.
and
As I said, I'm pretty sure we have more than one faction with a chat.
Oh?
You wouldn't be a member of one of these chats, would you?
Sorry, it's a (possibly bad) habit. I just use it when I'm being less serious.
As I already said, it's because we were told "people with a chat". Also, it would fit Wuba's role character.
And Jim, I wouldn't. What sense would there be in saying that I am?
TolyK:
If it's mostly for this post, then I find it kinda strange. Of course, it does seem like he doesn't want to be blamed for a mislynch (he pretty much said it explicitly there, didn't he ), however don't you think it's natural for people to not want to have an "hung innocent" on their conscience? Also, do you think there's anything else we can "try" to set a foundation for D2 other than asking questions?
I'm not convinced he's hunting on his own much either. And it may be natural for people to not to want to feel bad, but too bad- he's in charge, he needs to act like it.
Normally I'd say something about voting patterns, but it may be a bit silly here. Besides hunting, looking at chief suspects is the best bet, though it is blunted in this format.
Gotcha.
If it's mostly for this post, then I find it kinda strange. Of course, it does seem like he doesn't want to be blamed for a mislynch (he pretty much said it explicitly there, didn't he ), however don't you think it's natural for people to not want to have an "hung innocent" on their conscience? Also, do you think there's anything else we can "try" to set a foundation for D2 other than asking questions?
You're explaining a new player's attitude. New players hesitate because they don't want to be wrong and don't want to face the backlash of being wrong. Inexperienced scum players hesitate even more.
Except that mislynches happen and are a regular part of the game of mafia, even amongst reasonably competent town players. If Cheeetar suspected somebody and if it appeared to be legitimate and genuine suspicion, and it turned out that it was a mislynch, he would face little backlash for his decision. There's no reason to be uneasy, except if he has no suspects (scummy) or he's afraid of backlash (also scummy).
Exactly. And the reason why Cheeetar's suspected is because he's not suspecting anyone, or at least not pressing anyone.
TolyK:
You didn't answer me about your top two suspects.
SBC - worried about revealing his role, citing previous situation where he was scum for his actions
Imp - uncharacteristic lack of posts, but waiting to hear more from her before i decide on this
This was to me? My answer's pretty typical - SBC and Cheetar/Caz tied for second.
TolyK
TolyK
Tolyk:
If you were one of the assassins, and had to make the choice of whom to kill right now, who would it be? Why?
Huh. I could tell who I wouldn't (the King, since he's being very thoughtful ), but who I would kill... Jim? I don't really have all the information I need, but I'd be afraid of playing scum against Jim.
1. I see uncertainty, and I see Jim. Does Jim relevant to uncertainty?
2. Also why specifically Jim?
3. Also2: Anything on your mind or are you not curious on asking us things? What are your thoughts on the Kingmaker setup?
(1) Kinda - since I don't have information today, I would kill the guy I'd most be afraid of as scum. (2) He's that guy in this case, because he is very experienced and (afair) pointed me out as scum way too easily. >.> Also, as he said, he's usually strongly condemning and pushing, which really gets my on the edge regardless of faction.
(3) I wanted to finish rereading before asking questions (rather, I make questions as I reread). I already shared my thoughts on how it's different to play a Kingmaker, or do you mean something else?
1. That...really is unfair.
2. Jim? Yeah, restating: Unfair. You panic on being 'pointed out as scum'? Could you explain what that meant?
...
'my on the edge'? What?
3. Good! Now why do you think killing who you feared is a better idea than anything else?
Agreed that it's unfair, but that is exactly how I would think.
Uh, because I would be less nervous and less likely to slip?
Tiruin
PFPI disagree that flavour is separate from mechanics. Our roles were based on the heraldry we submitted, which was all flavor. If mechanics/roles were based on flavor, then can the two really actually be separate?
I thoroughly disagree with this. We're talking about Webadict making the roles.
You know when Webadict makes the roles.
Hilarious stoofs happen.
Meaning: No, really. Flavor =/= mechanics =/= abilities.
I bloody know.
I'm guessing you probably got one in your role? (Joke question, to make that clear)
PPE: Bah, long post.
...No, I am serious with what I said. Do you KNOW what Vector wrote in my role? No, no you don't.
So I'm saying it there right there and right then.
Why don't I have any serious question from you?
Also: You've never seen long posts. :I
No, I guess I haven't seen long posts, it's just longer that what I'm used to.
I don't currently have time to ask you serious questions at the moment, sorry.)