Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Phantom]

The group I used to play tabletop games with, actually.
There's was a total of six people in it, not including myself, so I'll refer to them as A, B, C, D, E and F.
We were kinda around and playing games together for almost two years now, so I got some kind of attachment with them. But, nonetheless, there's always problems.
See, despite being around for that long, we actually got into plenty of arguments, but people insisted to me that it was all fine. Some things happen, Person F gets booted for a while, I was like the only person that kept contact with him for that time until he came back.
Overall, status quo remains until Person A threatens to leave unless I am removed from the group. I get removed, all goes fine for him, I still remain in contact with the others, despite all the shiftiness of how it was handled. But, it doesn't stay all too peaceful for too long.
Since I was keeping in contact with Persons B-F, Person A wasn't satisfied with them not cutting all contact with me. So, for himself, he decided to leave it forever and remove+block everyone skype and steam too.
I thought it was over then. Then Person B, someone who I considered to be a true friend, notices, and gets mad at me for not giving up on staying in contact with the group and causing A to leave, and has proceeded to refuse to talk to me wholesale, in which I oblige him and refuse to initiate contact with him either.
Person C insists I give it a chance still. D, E and F are neutral. Three outsiders insist that I should leave due to all the drama.
What should I do?
Addendum: This all stems from me being far too confrontational, which C and E think I have been managing to control much more easily, however, it is not the same view for the rest. I do admit to being a particularly abrasive person.

Spoiler: Person A Leaving (click to show/hide)

I'm thinking about leaving the group. My goal, which was to get Phantom out of my life, has failed, and yesterday I learned he's still playing X, which was my last little hanging-on point. I haven't managed to remove him from my life, as you guys all still talk to him and play games with him. However, I can hardly ask you and everyone else to just up and stop talking to him (which I hoped would have happened when we 'removed him'), so I'm going to take it upon myself, and do what's best for me.

Spoiler: Person B's reaction (click to show/hide)

[11/2/2013 4:20:01 PM] B: So we lost A.
[11/2/2013 4:20:07 PM] B: Well, that's fucking wonderful.
[11/2/2013 4:20:26 PM] Phantom: Again, I'm sorry
[11/2/2013 4:20:34 PM] B: Fuck yourself.
[11/2/2013 4:20:39 PM] B: Go do it.
[11/2/2013 4:21:33 PM] Phantom: Well, obviously you aren't in the mood to accept my apologies
[11/2/2013 4:21:46 PM] B: I don't particularly want them either.
[11/2/2013 4:22:11 PM] Phantom: Okay.
[11/2/2013 4:22:17 PM] B: You drove out one of my friends by being an ass to him, and you're probably still going to be an ass in the coming months.
[11/2/2013 4:22:25 PM] B: All that's changed is we've lost news.
[11/2/2013 4:22:31 PM] B: God damn it.
[11/2/2013 4:23:16 PM] F: B.
[11/2/2013 4:23:16 PM] Phantom: Would you prefer it that I left too then? That is the logical conclusion.
[11/2/2013 4:23:25 PM] F: A is being ridiculous too.
[11/2/2013 4:23:44 PM] F: He was having no interaction with Phantom like he wanted, Phantom wasn't talking to him.
[11/2/2013 4:23:51 PM] B: A is attempting to remove someone from his life. That's a valid thing to do.
[11/2/2013 4:23:55 PM] B: He however, is gone.
[11/2/2013 4:23:56 PM] F: That wasn't enough for HIM.
[11/2/2013 4:23:59 PM] B: I didn't say i wasn't angry at him too.
[11/2/2013 4:24:13 PM] B: And that is incredibly depressing.
[11/2/2013 4:25:15 PM] Phantom: I'm not going to argue with you if you want me out. Remove me whenever you want and cut off contact if you want A back.
[11/2/2013 4:25:36 PM] B: He won't be back.
[11/2/2013 4:25:53 PM] B: You fucked that up by clinging to the fucking group when we asked you to leave.
[11/2/2013 4:26:46 PM] Phantom: Fine. Clearly I am not wanted. I will find the door.
[11/2/2013 4:27:42 PM] B: Do I speak for everyone?
[11/2/2013 4:27:45 PM] Phantom: I can't leave groups on mobile.
[11/2/2013 4:27:47 PM] B: No, I do not.
[11/2/2013 4:29:02 PM] B: All I'm doing, is predicting that you will refuse to change, blame your problems on other people, and continue to be the same abrasive person you were before. And all that will have changed six months from now, is that we no longer have A.
[11/2/2013 4:29:35 PM] Phantom: Yeah, but you were the person I respected the most. And with what I did, I am valid to have lost that.
[11/2/2013 4:30:30 PM] Phantom: Since it's clear this resentment is going to last, I might as well leave
[11/2/2013 4:30:46 PM] Phantom: Phones dying
[11/2/2013 4:32:35 PM] Phantom: There is really nothing more for me to say besides repeating "I'm sorry"
[11/2/2013 4:35:19 PM] Phantom: So, yeah. I fucked up, so fuck me. I'm sorry to have made everyone lose a friend because I couldn't get the memo.
[11/2/2013 4:37:06 PM] Phantom: And for that, I too come away poorer in all but filth.
[11/2/2013 4:41:42 PM] B: FYI, my shit's going on hold for now.
[11/2/2013 4:41:50 PM] B: Fuck this, that, and the guy next to it.
[11/2/2013 4:41:58 PM] B: I aint running shit until I get my head straight.
[11/2/2013 5:55:10 PM] Phantom: There is no amount of "I'm Sorry" that I can say to fix this. I think it's best I stay away for the month.
[11/2/2013 5:55:17 PM] *** Phantom has left ***

[ChairmanPoo]

Without knowing the background I can't really ground myself on much, but on principle I'd refuse to make any concessions to people of A and B's dickishness, and would probably stay around out of spite.

[Eagleon]

You've obviously pissed off a buttload of people you don't know (or they have, behind your back) for whatever reason. The key thing to remember in this type of situation is that the people you -do- know might not consider them 'outsiders'. Your best bet might be to leave and let things cool down for a bit. Nothing need be permanent. And if you really are being an abrasive confrontational ass:

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

my advice is to stop. It does nothing for you, it does nothing for them, it does nothing. What's the point? Pick your battles, listen to people carefully and with some sort of tentative respect for them to build on, and if you must call someone out, call out their ideas, not them personally. Difficult distinction to make, but it kind of makes the difference between this and people actually listening

[Phantom]

And to further explain the reason for B's anger, it's because the work of 2 weeks had gone to waste. Well, for now. Person A came back after a day, D-F continue to be neutral.

[nenjin]

They sound like a bunch of lamers. Seriously. I've lost one childhood friend via stupid drama, but we still manage to talk to each other, even share a friendly conversation from time to time, despite all that went down between us. That's called being adults. Your friends sound like teenage drama queens.

Not knowing what you did to A, it's hard to say whether his reaction is justified. But if the neutrals think that A is overreacting, and B is overreacting by extension, then I'd consider them the most rational touch point of the group. (C and E, who seem to not have taken sides or ended up on A's shit list.)

Case in point. B is just angry, and tells you to go fuck yourself. It doesn't matter how rational they seem otherwise, that's dick behavior that's solely focused on his loss, his boo-hoo. Do you really care to associate with people like that in your life? I think you can do better. Group meltdown is never, ever a pleasant experience, even from the sidelines. But it seems like your lynch pins, for lack of a better term, were kind of clique-y douches. That makes the consequences seemingly inevitable, in my mind. If they didn't flip at you for this one thing you did, it would have been another. Or it would have been someone else.

So personally, I'd move on, and file this away in your life experiences on group dynamics. Check back through what you did so you learn something about yourself instead of completely writing it off as someone else's failing. Stay in touch with the people that were cool throughout this little ordeal. The thing with empathetic people, or at least people who always want to try to make a situation right, is they often fail to pick up on the cues that they should walk away. It seems this is well beyond that point. When people are getting crazy/irrational-angry, there is no benefit to hanging around.

And FWIW, even adults act this way sometimes. For example, I've been playing the middleman between two 30-somethings, both friends, who have developed a one-sided dislike of the other over something as trivial as LoL (really the root cause is they're both know-it-alls and one of them happens to be a very vocal know-it-all. A recipe for disaster when it comes to LoL.) A case of "I refuse to play with this guy, or even acknowledge his presence in person." Some people just take a very hardline stance over the most trivial things, and there's little you can or should do about it. (The phrase "removing x from my life" is typically reserved for drug addicts, physically abusive relationships, exploitative and destructive relationships and the like.) Most people simply don't talk to the people they don't like anymore. People that go far so far as to make public declarations of severing ties are, IMO, likely control freaks or drama queens or both.

[Phantom]

I decided for the betterment of all involved that I am to leave. It was the advice given to me, and with the signs of A, and talks with all the others, nothing was to be gained by staying anyway. A still would have been furious if I had been in a game, associating with the others, even on a day where he was not involved. The others assured me that nothing can be done to make A resolve things. I believe that now.

On the plea of, 'this shit is whack, I ain't seeing clearly, and neither are any of you', I departed.
There begs the problem of a Line Regiment I'm in with B, C and F, but it should be easier to participate and ignore them than it is to have the chance to talk to them at any other time.

Spoiler: A Different Response On A Different Medium (click to show/hide)

"In a last ditch attempt, I tried to get everyone in the group together to talk to A. They all insisted they couldn't do anything to get A to talk, and further explained how I or they couldn't participate in games with me on the chance of A becoming mad and cutting off nearly all contact again. And, with much pain, they explained to me how any of my perceived slights against A were unfounded, since 'A was never serious'. It went on, nothing was resolved, and I had to resort to the advice."

Spoiler: To detail my crimes (click to show/hide)

I am a very, hot blooded person, if that speaks for anything. At some times, I am calm and collected, and generally agreed upon to be more enjoyable. When riled up/angered, I tend to explode and act irrationally. On several occasions, I have gotten angered to the point where I found it safer to separate myself from them than to stay. I will detail those over.

Spoiler: My slights (click to show/hide)

On several times, I have taken offense to A being inconsiderate. One, being the usual chiding over not having a girlfriend, angered me to the point of separating myself because A would not drop it. The second time was when people were joking about Muslims, A comments on my country in particular and I ask him to drop it, since some loved ones had died relating to what he joked about, and he told me he 'don't give a shit'. Lastly, as a general thing, I tend to support other less popular parts of history rather than Europe or the US, and that has gotten me into arguments on more than several times, with one time angering me enough to separate again. A has been fed up with these separations, and my anger problems, and refused to associate with me as a result.

[acetech09]

At work, can't read it all. But it seems like you were posting about how to prevent/deal with a group splintering apart. But the group seems pretty (no offense) lame and full of stupid dynamics and tensions. If I was involved with something like that, I'd not worry about trying to keep it together, leave, and let them deal with it.

P.S. You really, really, really, really, seem to be overthinking this. Don't always try to rationalize everything in detail.

[nenjin]

A sounds like a charismatic asshole. There are those that draw people to them by dint of their personality, and their faults get excused because they're the glue that brings people together. When a "friend" won't back off after a sincere request, they're not really a friend. And people that won't rightly call them on their BS because they're afraid of being on the "out" aren't really friends either. They just happen to be the nicest of a bunch of groupies.

So yeah, you're doing the right thing. And maybe, just maybe, evidence that you don't worship this person might cause other people to rethink why they overlook their faults. Either way, move on.

[Phantom]

Hi, here I am again. I managed to get away from the group, on less than peaceful terms than I hoped.

But here I am, I'm actually satisfied with my life from here on out. Except for one tiny thing.

I participate in a line battle group for Mount and Blade: Warband. Just a group of friends playing together and such, and one thing comes. I still have the rules for a homebrew section of an RPG that Person B worked on. I notify Person B that I still have them. I'm no plagiarist. And I'm no thief.

And now they're trying to kick me out of a the group, three to one. At least, among me and their group. I actually have people to stand up for me now. A good five, at least, but there's far more than that in the group. What the hell do I do from here?

[Yoink]

That does seem pretty damn ridiculous.
Your friends want to ostracize you because you still possess a set of RPG rules from some previous group? Or am I missing something here?

[Toady One]

(removed unrelated nonsense, one mute, one warning)

[nenjin]

Hi, here I am again. I managed to get away from the group, on less than peaceful terms than I hoped.

But here I am, I'm actually satisfied with my life from here on out. Except for one tiny thing.

I participate in a line battle group for Mount and Blade: Warband. Just a group of friends playing together and such, and one thing comes. I still have the rules for a homebrew section of an RPG that Person B worked on. I notify Person B that I still have them. I'm no plagiarist. And I'm no thief.

And now they're trying to kick me out of a the group, three to one. At least, among me and their group. I actually have people to stand up for me now. A good five, at least, but there's far more than that in the group. What the hell do I do from here?

Let them make asses out of themselves, and others do the fighting for you. You should endeavor to rise above the drama and show you're a more mature person. Answer questions and explain the situation if people ask, otherwise, just don't acknowledge it.

[LeoLeonardoIII]

Is anyone else wondering why A cares whether Phantom is still friends with his friends? If A never interacts with Phantom, why should he care? What do you think, Phantom?

[Phantom]

Honestly? I think it was because he was a control freak. He didn't seem to like anything not going his way and pretty much was only pleased by the fence sitters and sycophants. I'm kinda happy that I got away from them, and I'm perfectly content of letting them make themselves look like asses. I wish I could forgive them, but now I realize both of our faults. It wasn't worth it.

[QuakeIV]

Read this.  Yeah fuck those guys.  A was a real shitface, B was a shitface as a direct result of apparently seeing something good in A, and everyone else was too tolerant of the whole situation.