Hey
Darvi!
Remember this?
And when the morning begins, I have to get in
Before sunlight can fall upon my face
You really should be in by now
Superblackcat:
What I think about the night kill - Reading old Scumchats, most recommend to go for players that you think will be a problem for you. Either because they're after you, which can be revealing, or because their active and likely to be of use to Town later in play. Persus was that, whether he was actually already on Scum or not, he was active, analyzing, seemed open minded, rational, interested, was talking to everyone and getting answers in many cases. I was scared he was Scum for a reason I already explained, but man he seems to have been a good pick for nightkill. I posted the most - but he talked to everyone the most. I wish I could trade places with him - maybe he'd have been able to get this Town talking again and I don't see how Town can possibly win this without more people talking more.
Everyone:
Here's what I think of each of the survivors right now:
Darvy - can't tell. Seems to show Town and Scum tells. Seems to have lost interest, or still be drunk on 'the night'. When he was active, seemed to be more focused on teaching us to play than actually playing himself. Did seem to want to teach us to play, thanks for that.
Squill - can't tell, hasn't shown himself clearly enough. He seems to hate to talk, is willing to offer silence, and is apparently willing to accept silence from everyone. That doesn't seem Town to me. He looks great in comparison to Luke, but that's not saying anything. Almost active enough for me to have a feel for - but almost is not quite. May want to catch Scum, but sure not trying to do anything to make this happen/happen more easily.
Rolepgeek - Hasn't really played since the first couple days of the game. Complained about players to focused on semantics (Mr.Zero, me). Launched non-Scumhunting personal attack on me. He sure doesn't seem to care about catching Scum or not.
Deathsword - Can't tell, way idle. Almost no focus on teaching as IC or on scumhunting as player. Probably a pattern for the player as a whole as meta. Cited health and other real life issues limiting playability - but despite that, we need enough activity to judge him on - I haven't had that. He sure doesn't seem to care about catching Scum or not though.
Mr.Zero - I think he's Town. Seems too tunneled on Cat to me, and to unconcerned about telling Scummy from Scum, but that's a pretty common human trait I'd guess. I think he's trying to catch Scum, but that seems to be focused mostly on catching Scummy Cat.
Superblackcat - I've swung around to thinking Cat is Town. Reason being Cat's talked a LOT, he's really shown several parts of how he reasons. I can't tell for sure, but I think Cat just looks scummy and sometimes makes bad choices, but with Town intentions. I'm by no means sure, but I think Cat has shown a pattern of play that I can follow and understand, and following it doesn't point to him as being Scum to me. I don't think Cat could have played as he as if he is actually Scum.
I'm so depressed to be at this point of the game and to have this low level of activity. We're not even getting updates on vote counts, so here's my best attempt at one:
1
1 1 1
| Imp - Deathsword Squill Rolepgeek - Imp Superblackcat - Mr.Zero Mr.Zero - Superblackcat Deathsword Darvi |
not voting: Darvi, Rolepgeek, Squill
Extend - 0/3
Shorten - 0/4
Today will end on Friday, October 18th at midnight PST
So, questions for all:
Why so quiet?
Is anyone happy with the level of Scumhunting happening in this game?
If not, are you intending to do anything to help improve it?
If so, can you help me understand that things are going well, not terribly quiet, and why you think we're not going to a lurky town loss as is?