Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Chink]

Boy - Have you read a mafia game on this forum yet?  If so, which one(s)?

Boy: You're a mafia roleblocker. It's Night 1. How would you decide to roleblock?

Boy: If you got a scum inspect result on Night 1 would you claim or wait and try to find the second one?

Mah Boy: Peace is what all true warriors strive for. Let's assume you're the cop and you get an innocent inspection. However you feel like the mafia is onto you but you're not sure. Do you claim or bank on not getting caught?

I've dug up all of the questions directed at Boy I could find.
Griffinpup: I have looked at Toon Mafia VII, but I just skimmed most of that.
Powder Miner: I'd probably pick at random out of those that aren't my scum buddies, as there wouldn't be enough evidence to know who has roles.
WetSheep: Wait. Claiming immediately would cause the mafia to kill/roleblock me next night.
Nerjin: Bank on not getting caught. Claiming someone is innocent exposes that I might be the cop, and is really just too risky in my opinion.

[TheWetSheep]

Griffinpup: OK, I see now. Unvote.

I wouldn't say deliberately, but I haven't given off any scum tells.

Is that for you to decide?

YOU HAVE NEVER STATED REASONS FOR VOTING ME.

Actually, he did. Right here.

Dave: It's getting kind of tiring having to point out questions you've missed again and again. Can you please carefully read the thread and answer all questions addressed to you? Or is there another reason you're not answering questions?


I just got rather short notice that I'll be on a trip soon, leaving Sunday and getting back Tuesday. I won't have internet.

[griffinpup]

I wouldn't say deliberately, but I haven't given off any scum tells.

2. Is that for you to decide?

YOU HAVE NEVER STATED REASONS FOR VOTING ME.

3. Actually, he did. Right here.

2. Yes.  You have no idea what I do deliberately.

3. Hmm.  I assumed that was about IG:

Dave:
What was the longest time period between all my posts?

[Imperial Guardsman]

Also, IG, you realize investigating someone based on their luck in roles is fallacious logic, yes?

Hey, its not end of day and nobody has claimed.
Its either nobody or NQT.

[Okami No Rei]

Day 1 ends on Monday, July 29 at 8:00pm CST

Votecount

TheWetSheep (1) - notquitethere
griffinpup (1) - DaveTheGrave
Griffionday (0) -
Powder Miner (0) -
Imperial Guardsman (0) -
DaveTheGrave (4) - Nerjin, Imperial Guardsman, griffinpup, Powder Miner
Chink (0) -
Nerjin (0) -
notquitethere (0) -

Not Voting - Chink, Griffionday, TheWetSheep

Extend (0/4) -
Shorten (0/5) -

TheWetSheep has Requested Replacement on or before Sunday, August 11.

[Imperial Guardsman]

Y U NO PLAY MAFIA

Also, might want to remove replacement requested from the title...

[griffinpup]

I guess it's the weekend, but still.  Without any activity, and none on the horizon, perhaps we should shorten?

[Nerjin]

Oppose Shorten We don't need to shorten. People are busy so activity WILL be lower. BUT on day 1 we probably shouldn't shorten just in case someone comes in with a good read. Just keep an eye out.

[Powder Miner]

Quick warning before i sleeeeep
I'm doing something for a couple days from monday, so posting will be limited or nonexistent.

[notquitethere]

Griffinpup

Dave: You didn't answer my questions

And you didn't answer mine. Is this deliberate?

TheWetSheep

NQT: We're just coming out of RVS. I unvoted my previous RVS target and decided to go after something a little bit stronger, and I feel like Dave has quite enough pressure on him as it is. Also, see my answer to him for the issue.

Okay, that's a bit more reasonable.

Imperial Guardsman

Its a 50/50 chance hes either a VI or Scum.
Its a 99.9 chance he will be D1 Lynch.

Calling the lynch target and admitting that they're only half-likely to be scum doesn't seem to be a particularly pro-town move. If Dave is lynched and they flip town, it's this sort of pronouncement that will look poorly in your favour. Do you have any reads on the other players?

NQT, because of how he frequently gets power roles/third party.

Ah, you believe in a sort of cosmic luck. It is true that in life I am the third-party, a loose cannon spouting loose canon; a maverick 90 degrees askew from the rest of civilisation. But really, there are probably better reasons to rolecop someone.

Griffionday

Actually there is one situation where it's appropriate to vote for someone that you don't consider the most scummy, that I think Leafsnail brought up in the previous game.  That is when you need to vote for the one of the vote leaders to break a tie, even if neither is the absolute most scummy.  This is to make your vote as relevant as possible.

You're absolutely right, and I should have thought of that. Being the tie-breaker is an important job for a town player and I've been in that situation a few times myself, both successfully and unsuccessfully. In a tie-vote situation, not breaking the tie when you have an opportunity is suspicious act that the other players have grounds to question.

Chink

NQT: You are a generic scum, D1. Who do you want to target N1, and why?

You can just ask the scum IC this sort of thing  . I'd target the most competent town player that is also least likely to be mislynched, which at this stage is probably Powder Miner or Nerjin (assuming that they're town). What would you do?

[Parsely]

((Can I IN, or is this full? :C I've never played Mafia before.))

[notquitethere]

((Can I IN, or is this full? :C I've never played Mafia before.))

((The game is full but you could go on the replacement list. One player is definitely leaving in two weeks. As you're a Bay12 regular and aren't about to disappear like an escaped lunatic, Nerjin might be amenable to you jumping into Elements which is currently in sign-ups.))

[Parsely]

((Can I IN, or is this full? :C I've never played Mafia before.))

((The game is full but you could go on the replacement list. One player is definitely leaving in two weeks. As you're a Bay12 regular and aren't about to disappear like an escaped lunatic, Nerjin might be amenable to you jumping into Elements which is currently in sign-ups.))

((As long as its beginner friendly. All the same I'll probably join either way.))
Replacement list me please.

[griffinpup]

((Can I IN, or is this full? :C I've never played Mafia before.))

Oh joy. Let's let someone who's emotionally driven and can't handle any form of criticism play.  As you can tell, my past experience with gun is... Less then pleasant.  But if he is going to be on the replacement list, doesn't that make him TWS's replacement?

NQT: rephrase your question.  I've been meaning to ask you to do so, but I've forgotten a few times.  Inter-game meta literally means nothing to me.

Oppose Shorten We don't need to shorten. People are busy so activity WILL be lower. BUT on day 1 we probably shouldn't shorten just in case someone comes in with a good read. Just keep an eye out.

But my vote on Dave isn't very likely to move until he INTELLIGENTLY answers my questions.  I see your point, but the same logic could  be applied to endlessly extending the game.

[Parsely]

((Can I IN, or is this full? :C I've never played Mafia before.))

Oh joy. Let's let someone who's emotionally driven and can't handle any form of criticism play.  As you can tell, my past experience with gun is... Less then pleasant.  But if he is going to be on the replacement list, doesn't that make him TWS's replacement?

((Don't.

Apparently you've been hanging onto that worthless argument we had ever since it ended nearly a week ago. I had already forgotten about it. Its in the past, and I have no hard feelings against you for it. You need to let it go Griffin instead of trying to pick a fight.))