PFP
Vector: It occurred to me this morning that you having an inspection ability for specific candles also implies that they don't all work the same.
Also, you didn't say it explicitly, but you implied that you got another message from your god this morning. I'm guessing you decided not to share it yet?
Tiruin:Why are you agreeing with Ottofar?
I was actually agreeing with Dariush (whom Ottofar also agreed with).
Ottofar surviving with his white candle snuffed seems to indicate that white candles don't correspond directly to life. What we don't know is whether Ottofar's teal candle is his "life candle", or if it's simply that all one's candles need to be out in order for someone to be incapacitated.
If we light either his green or teal candle, and he revives, then it proves that:
A) His white candle was not directly tied to his life
If we light either his green or teal candle, and he doesn't revive, then it means either:
A) His white candle is directly tied to his life or
B) He can't be revived
Hmm...the only flaw with the experiment is that if he doesn't revive, we don't really know why. Also, he's still "dead".
The upshot is that if he does revive, he might have gained an ability as well. I suppose it means we're gambling with his life for information and a potential ability. I'm not entirely sure how comfortable I am with that.
There's the possibility that things might change enough between today and tomorrow that reviving him may no longer be something we can afford to worry about. I don't want him to be left behind, but ...
Well, the potential gain may outweigh the risks. (I'm still weighing it. I think it needs to be discussed further)
Okami:The fact that Okami has no role abilities (or he's lying) with all candles lit seems to contradict the idea that more candles lit is strictly better.
Where'd you get that idea? I've already said that I do have a role ability.
Wow...I could have sworn...
*scratches head* Man, this game is hella confusing for some reason.
Okay, I whipped this up to help me keep track of all the information going around. Hopefully this will help us all get on the same page.
I'm probably missing half the stuff people have stated. Please let me know what I'm missing and I'll update it.
NQT:Dariush, rudeness is unbecoming. I promised to relight Solifuge's white candle so that's what I'm doing.
Snuff Dariush's White Candle- we can relight your green tomorrow.
You're confused. Dariush's candles have never been affected.
Also, what if lighting Soli's white candle doesn't revive him? What if lighting his green candle does and grants him an ability?
I'd like to see an honest assessment from you about the risks and possible payoffs.
...more coming.