Operation Magnetboot Deception: [9] +Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum +10ebbor10 +Worldmaster27 +Elephant Parade +Solymr +flameboy99 +Tomcost +Tophat +Arcvasti -monk12
Ciro & Riltia jump off Airship Together: [9] +Objective +Shadestyle +Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum +Omeganaut +birdy51 +Fniff +flameboy99 +Elephant Parade +Randomino
Bring up Ecco's meeting with Cain in rhyme: [9] +monk12 +flameboy99 +Toaster +Furturka +flabort +Arcvasti +Shadowhammer +Randomino +Kevak
Store Goombess in Illborn Exchange: [8] +Randomino +monk12 +Solymr +flameboy99 +Tomcost +Worldmaster27 +Tophat +fractalman
Flee: [2] +Elephant Parade +Kevak
Rap Battle of Doom: [6] +Shadestyle +javierpwn +Omeganaut +Wolfkit +Randomino +Aedel +Lordslowpoke +birdy51 -Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum -flabort -Fniff +flameboy99
Continued Defiance: [4] +flameboy99 +NAV +Shadestyle +RAM +Kevak +birdy51 +Arcvasti -Execute/Dumbo.exe -Solymr -fractalman
Diplomacy Oric: +Wolfkit +Toaster +fractalman
Gather KitKat Ashes: [2] +Elephant Parade +RAM +Kevak +birdy51 +fractalman -Arcvasti -Execute/Dumbo.exe -Solymr
Windirection Riltia: [2] +Tophat +Arcvasti
Kill Goombess, retrieve Essence: [1] +Elephant Parade
Produce mental image of SLAPPIN THAT SUCKAH.: [1] +Eotyrannus
Claim Riltia is Loot, not Ally: +javierpwn [1]
Kill Cherish and Al: [1] +Elephant Parade
Push Oric off Airship: [1] +flabort
Astral Influx to Ciro: [1] +Elephant Parade
Taunt Oric: [-3] +LordSlowpoke -Solymr -javierpwn -fractalman
+1 to gather Kit Kat ashes. It's worth a shot, if we can revive her.
-1 to fleeing or battling in any way. I really doubt we can escape the ruler of the Warrens or defeat him with our current level of strength.
-1 to defiance or diplomacy or negotiation. I really feel like we won't be able to talk our way out of this one. He looks pissed af.
+1 to storing Goombess.I feel like storing or killing Goombess to get her essence to revive her later is risky. If Oric is only intending to kill illborns, then yes, we save a party member. If not, we lose a living party member. Also however, Oric could choose to kill the person holding the Exchange or the essence, which would destroy the item, and we would lose both party members. However, I'd like to try and save party members if there's a chance that we can, so that's why I +1'd it.
The top three suggestions seem to all have equal chances of succeeding, so I'm gonna hold my vote on those for now.