I'm pretty sure it says in the description that just once, the person can be brought back to life after dying (that's the limited immortality I spoke of). Yeah we do use stealth a lot but we don't need Alice specifically to use stealth that much. It's usually just us. I'm not saying we never need her to be stealthy just saying the need for her to be stealthy isn't really any stronger than the need for any other member of our group. It is also important to keep in mind we just got another stealthy female capable of being transformed into a consort. This one might even be better in that regard although honestly we have relatively little to go on as far as guessing how skilled she is. Last thing, I want to be flexible and reach an agreement with everyone as often as possible. I personally do not think the Left Stone is the best gift for Alice. I also think it could be put to better use elsewhere. I understand you feel strongly about converting Alice, specifically with the left stone gift, even though I disagree. So yeah I was trying to suggest a decent compromise but you seem to dislike my suggestion. Do you have another gift you'd like to use other than the left stone that we might all be able to agree on?
Alice would lose her woodlore and stealth abilities to the Phoenix gift. Alice actually has stealth and such; we can't expect our new consorts to learn stealth and whatnot right off the bat.
The Left Stone isn't ideal, but it's honorable; if Alice is willing to take the responsibilities of helping to repopulate the night troll race, and Nocteclaw doesn't advise against it, I see no reason to not give her the gift. As I suggested, but didn't outright state, Foghorn would probably appreciate it if we appreciated her daughter enough to give her such an important gift. Of we decide against the Left Stone for some reason, though, I suggest using the Bloodlust gift, which doesn't conflict with her abilities. Or maybe Inferno's Embrace or Amnesia, which also don't conflict with her abilities or degrade her. Remember, while Foghorn claims not to care about Alice anymore, she's still his daughter and he's still human.
The mermaid seriously advised us not to pray to Nocteclaw without adequate training. If you wanna risk we may do that... but I suspect that failure will lead to seriuos problems
Hm, forgot that. Did she mean "Asking for aid" prayer or "What people do IRL" or "Ask for advice" prayer?
Problem with impregnating consort with the left stone
And Alice is smart enough to have kids (Besides I know that she'll answer something like - "I don't want to but if that will be required I'll do" + night troll instincts will kick in + I think that some lesbian trait is likely)
And we do need to convert Alice now,and if you all are so opposed to the left stoning let's use the combat gift... But don't delay conversion further.
And force the elf to stay, not kill but let it see how her friends get eaten\converted and generate sweet fear... Then release a mad elf
Why do we need to convert Alice while she's unconscious? Couldn't we at least wait until she's awake so it's less...creepy?
And why be mean for da evulz? I think there's plenty of fear in the elves who know they're next.
Why waste time and wait until Alice recover? And why do we need to go back to the tower? We need to keep terrorizing the retreat.
With an increasingly pregnant consort and a bunch of loot? We should drop at least the loot, prisoner(s) if any, and Gwen off at the more defensible location. Anyways, the elves know we're here, we can't stay until Alice heals...
I have AN IDEA!
As we know, while we convert someone we deconstruct them... Let's try to combine 2 elves while they are blobs. And use the puppeting gift, in that way we may get big night troll consort with split personality, probably mad, but loyal and obedient...
...
I don't know...
So I propose
1) Force the elf at exit to stay and watch
2) Let Gwen enjoy the meal
3) Combine the rogue elf, the axeelf and gift of puppetry in one new consort
Then we'll decide what to do with Alice
I'm not sure about 3, and am against 1. 2 and 4 are fine.
I suggest that we wait until we can talk to Alice about having kids. For now, the rogue or the abomination.