Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Dustylou2]

Geen: I still have questions I need you to answer. (Reply 195) Please give actual detail and reasoning.


I still need an answer from you too, Deathsword.


I don't think it needs to be said even more, but yes, Prod borno. So much. Mod-ninja'd.

[Teneb]

Dustylou2: I am going to assume the following question is the one I missed.

Why exactly were you suspicious of Mr. D? Looking back through the thread, you've barely even spoken to him, and LurkerTracker says that you've never even FoSed him, let alone vote him.

During D1, and while looking through it after N1, it seemd to me as if Mr D was buddying up with KF by trying to defend him from Boltur's demands to answer his question. Then he was replaced by Geen, who is now just sitting there doing nothing.

Also, stop just asking people whom they are suspicious of and hunt. In fact, who are you suspicious of? Why? And why are you being so passive?

Boltur:

-quote pyramid-

Stop lying. You revealed them after that. Why only promise if you could deliver your suspicions back then ?

Tell me, where did I lie? I said I'd like my suspicions with questions and a vote. I voted and questioned you. Then you asked whom I was suspicious of, at which point I pointed out that I had just said I suspected (and still do) you. How is that a lie?

I disagree, i forced him to react and i believe what happened next wouldn't take place if i had not attacked him. His responses only reinforced my opinion and if questions asked by others wouldn't be enough and i have been able to post back then i would continue.

While it was your demanding him to answer your question that caused him to panick, it doesn't excuse you from just sitting back and let other people pressure him for you.

Yes. Seriously though i meant that i'm not seeing why are you voting me. Because i asked that double question ? Or because i have not scumhunted despite the fact that  kingfisher would not have lashed out in #138 if i did not attacked him. Or what ?

Just because he lashed at out at one question from you, doesn't mean you scumhunted. One question, and then prodding someone to anwer a question, doesn't equal scum-hunting. I am voting because I think you are scum that is trying to go unnoticed by asking as few questions as you can without exposing yourself. I believe I made my reasons for voting and suspecting you quite clear.

Hapah:

Two out of seven isn't enough for an Extend, and at the time of your first post it was only me pushing for the Extend. We didn't get the required three until Dusty AND Jim both voted for the Extend, Dusty's post coming after yours.

So there weren't enough votes, and you didn't vote for the Extend.

There were still more than 18 hours left then, which, in my opinion, meant that there was enough time to decide if an extend would be actually needed or not.

It does, however, look like I misread that page. Your extend vote was indeed the first.

[Geen]

It feels like he's trying to push us to kill each other to me.

Kay, I'll answer da questions, gimme a few minutes.
Ya, I have played mafia, first time IRL was when I was around 5, and it was called Werewolves but it was the same thing.

EDIT: Either that or he seems to want Boltur dead for suspecting him.

[Shakerag]

It feels like he's trying to push us to kill each other to me.

Kay, I'll answer da questions, gimme a few minutes.
Ya, I have played mafia, first time IRL was when I was around 5, and it was called Werewolves but it was the same thing.

EDIT: Either that or he seems to want Boltur dead for suspecting him.

Edits - Editing posts is prohibited. Do not edit your post for any reason, even if your post comes out as a trainwreck of formatting, spelling, punctuation, and/or grammar. The preview button exists; use it.

[Jim Groovester]

It feels like he's trying to push us to kill each other to me.

This is mafia, not a cuddlezone.

You can't win if you don't kill people. Wanting people dead is the norm.

[Geen]

True. Hmm, any arguments for who to vote against?
Oh god, sorry! I was trying to avoid a doublepost.

[Jim Groovester]

You can read the thread and peruse the arguments that players have made against each other. If you find one that is agreeable to you, you can vote with that player.

Or you can employ the vastly more preferable option of making an argument for yourself.

Nobody's going to spoonfeed you scumhunting and people will suspect you if you expect that to happen.

[Phantom of The Library]

Geen: I want you to read the rules which are found in this post. 

A good number of mods would have had you mod-killed for editing your post in-game. This is a BM, so I'm going to be lenient and let you off with a warning, but you should read the entire OP before you do anything else.  Forum mafia is very different from RL mafia, the core concept is the same, but the execution is very different. 

[Geen]

Shitshitshit sorry, was half-asleep, have had lots of caffeine now and actually have rules stored in brain.

[borno]

Sorry, I've had a friend over, and couldn't post while he was here.

Boltur:
You accuse DS of lying, but don't do anything about it? Usually lying is a pretty big scumtell. And instead of pushing him really hard on why he is voting for you, you politely ask why. It's as if you're afraid to draw attention to yourself.

Borno: Are you content with current votes ? State your suspicions.

I am currently suspicious of you.

[Geen]

Sorry, I've had a friend over, and couldn't post while he was here.

Boltur:
You accuse DS of lying, but don't do anything about it? Usually lying is a pretty big scumtell. And instead of pushing him really hard on why he is voting for you, you politely ask why. It's as if you're afraid to draw attention to yourself.

Borno: Are you content with current votes ? State your suspicions.

I am currently suspicious of you.

Wait, what if it's a set up to make them look like they're town but not actually kill each other and both are reapers? CONSPIRACY THEORY GO.

[Teneb]

Wait, what if it's a set up to make them look like they're town but not actually kill each other and both are reapers? CONSPIRACY THEORY GO.

Geen, that is WIFOM. Also, try to take the game more seriously.

Kay, I'll answer da questions, gimme a few minutes.

And the answers, where are they?

[Jim Groovester]

Wait, what if it's a set up to make them look like they're town but not actually kill each other and both are reapers? CONSPIRACY THEORY GO.

Or, what if their argument is genuine? BETCHA DIDN'T THINK OF THAT.

Have you even bothered to read the rest of the thread yet? You need to get on that. Like right now.

[Dustylou2]

Unfortunately, I don't have enough time to do mafia games any justice, due to RL circumstances. As such, Unvote and Request Replacement. This game has been really fun, and I'm sorry I have to do this. Hopefully I'll be able to play again, once RL sorts itself out.

[wsoxfan]

Could I join the replacement line? I know I can't replace Dustylou2 because BMG is first, but otherwise, it would be great to have it.