Bay 12 Games Forum

This looks fun.

In.

Thank god I don't have to think hard this weekend and can just watch anime

If Imp or NJW think Fallacy is scum, they can prove their convictions by hammering.

Or you.

@Tric:
FoU pushed for NJW alongside Max on D2 because eliminating NJW would solve the Bible conundrum they faced and also stop the lynch from being Max. Max also suggested we eliminate Jack or do a No Lynch instead because a no lynch is still better than one of their mafia members being killed. Jack of course claims a lynch-protection, however I still think it would be odd for Jack to be mafia with Max here.

Look at the EoD2 vote count:

Vote Count — Day 2
- Crystalizedmire -
- Elephant Parade
- Euchrejack -
- FallacyofUrist -   
- Imp -
- Maximum Spin - [5] NJW2000, Crystalizedmire, Euchrejack, Tricmagic, ToonyMan
- NJW2000 - [2] Imp, FallacyofUrist
- Toonyman -
- TricMagic - 
- No Elimination - [1] Maximum Spin

This is a confused and paranoid town!Imp voting NJW alongside a mafia!FoU trying to save Max.

Cool.

I hope you discuss the wat thing with CM more.  Love to see you scumhunting more.

So, your reads list, given 2 dead scum, a dead TP, and 8 of us alive with 1 dead town, is that most of us are null to you.  Yuck.

But I'm #2 scummiest to you, and helpfully you say why.

I don't remind you of my FBYOR play, and I discussed ideas about maybe dud sphere explains why 1 kill N1, when we know the Page wasn't in effect.

Re play:  I bet my FBYOR play doesn't remind you much of my catfia play either.  Or that my play in Max's Supernormal reminds anyone who paid attention much of my play in either of those games.  I have differences every game.  If my differences mean scum to you, I wonder if you're take the time to explain to all of us, y'know, put some effort into your 'work'.

Tric was helpful, I am cutting you a lot of slack for reasonable mechanics play.  I don't know, I'm just guessing about you.  Listening to you, you sound like you don't really have a follow on the game.

As for the dud stuff, we had a brief discussion about it:

First, second, third.  Wonder if anyone else think that looks scummy.  Of either of us.

We're probably town chewing on town.  I want you to chew more carefully and thoughtfully of everyone.

I'm incredibly disappointed in you that I'm your second scummiest for that reason set alone.  That's piffle.

It's D3.  And your third scummiest is 'Don't have much to say about him'.  I hope you catch up on the thread or start chasing your cases.  You're sitting there on your thumb waving ideas and not trying to achieve anything except getting ignored yourself.  Thanks, Tric.  I'm noticing.

I don't mean to breathe down your neck, EP.  I expect more of you as the day progresses.

... A question to Toony, and Fallacy. Are those chats mod-confirmed, alignment wise?

No. We're not masons or anything. We just share chats.

Anyway, how's this for commitment eeehh??

FoU

After thinking about it, the easiest answer for why there wasn't a kill last Night, nor even any evidence at an attempt at one, is just that we're out of scum and there's some anti-town third party remaining. For the time being I'll go ahead on that theory, since three scum (or two teams of two) in a twelve-player game, where there is also a third party player already confirmed to exist, would be a bit weighted against the town. I think one neutral third party, one SK, two scum, and eight town is more plausible.

I agree with this assessment if you are town.

Who do you think is SK?

If you could organize thoughts from most to least likely in your opinion that would be even better.

@Tric:
Makes sense. You'll get an Emerald if you do that and I plan on learning the locations of every Emerald tonight too which will confirm you targeted me.

I don't think there will be a tonight though.

I believe FoU is scum because I think their case on me D1 and their case on NJW D2 came from a place of malice as opposed to cluelessness. I also want to believe my D1 vote of FoU was correct all along. I believe it's very unlikely any other player is mafia, so I would need to be convinced that another player is more likely to be scum than FoU at this point.