Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Lonewolf I]

Lonewolf, are you the werevampitch or not?

The latter.

Jokerman-EXE - What are the odds we have both a Demon and a Devil in addition to the usual scum, as we did last time?

[Org]

So says the (hopefully) ex-Demon...  At least they helped the town kill off the Werewolf threat!

Seriously though, what did you hope to gain by the question?  If it's that terribly important to your strategy, I'll wait until after Lonewolf I answers you, but I do want an answer.

WHY YOU PHISING?

[Mephansteras]

Unfortunately, Diablous needs to be replaced. Anyone available?

[Toaster]

Janus, are you going to crusade against lurkers as you did in S1?  Do you think it was effective?

[Mephansteras]

The Scribe's Tally Sheet
Archangel: Solifuge
Diablous: JanusTwoFace
IronyOwl: Diablous
JanusTwoFace: Toaster
Jokerman-EXE: Lonewolf I
Pandarsenic: Jokerman-EXE
Solifuge: Mr.Person, Pandarsenic
ToonyMan: IronyOwl


Day 1 ends ~5pm Pacific Friday

A Replacement is needed for Diablous

[ToonyMan]

Watching.

You don't have to post in a thread to get unread replies about it, there's a NOTIFY button on the top-right place.

ToonyMan, what do you think of werewolves?

Pain in asses.

Voting Toaster he looks like scum.

[Jokerman-EXE]

Lonewolf, are you the werevampitch or not?

The latter.

Jokerman-EXE - What are the odds we have both a Demon and a Devil in addition to the usual scum, as we did last time?

I have no idea. I'm not sure how this is balanced or anything like that.

Wait, weren't the two connected in some way? Or was that just the discussion that went on?

[Archangel]

I think I am the only person who hasn't posted, and Nothing so far has caught my eye, so... Pandarsenic, why did you vote for Solifuge when there already was a vote on him?

[Pandarsenic]

Truly random votes disregard the fact of who's already been voted for. Additionally, the second vote on a person always provides a conversation piece.

...

That said, I didn't see the vote on him.

[ToonyMan]

I always say that but no one listens.

[Toaster]

Truly random votes aren't helpful anyway.  Mine are directed for some reason.

Toony- It must have been that dip I took in the pond.  I'll wash it all off.

[IronyOwl]

Unvote

Jokerman-EXE, that's an awfully waffling response, isn't it? Why are you trying so hard to avoid knowing anything about demons?

[JanusTwoface]

unvote

Werevampitch = Werewolf Vampire Bitch, perhaps?

Possible.  Except he said that he meant witches after my post.

So says the (hopefully) ex-Demon...  At least they helped the town kill off the Werewolf threat!

Seriously though, what did you hope to gain by the question?  If it's that terribly important to your strategy, I'll wait until after Lonewolf I answers you, but I do want an answer.

WHY YOU PHISING?

How am I?  And I want an answer Org.

Janus, are you going to crusade against lurkers as you did in S1?  Do you think it was effective?

It depends on how badly people lurk.  Probably, although not right now.  And yes, I think it was effective, we won after all.

Wait, weren't the two connected in some way? Or was that just the discussion that went on?

No connection other than both being third party.  A Demon is a standard SK, a Devil can offer you a power in exchange for your soul and wins when he/she collects enough souls.

And I don't think it's necessarily the case in this game because it's a closed setup, but IMO most of the time if someone asks a question about a scum role (especially if not directed at the mod), than they're usually trying to hide something.

Truly random votes disregard the fact of who's already been voted for. Additionally, the second vote on a person always provides a conversation piece.

I wonder how many people actually random vote randomly though...

It's the third votes (like we had two of last round) that are worrysome (in non-hammer games).

Truly random votes aren't helpful anyway.  Mine are directed for some reason.

A truly random vote with no force behind it isn't helpful.  If you push it, it can be.

[Org]

Strategy implies role.

[JanusTwoface]

Strategy implies role.

You're too obsessed with roles.  The primary goal of mafia is to find the scum, the primary way to do that is during the day game.

And three word answers really aren't helpful.  I'm sure I've told you this before, but saying little (and nonsense being most of that) helps the scum even if you do happen to be town.

Which question are you answering:

Seriously though, what did you hope to gain by the question?  If it's that terribly important to your strategy, I'll wait until after Lonewolf I answers you, but I do want an answer.

If it's this one, than how in the world does an anser to "Lonewolf, are you the werevampitch or not?" help you in the slightest no matter your role?  More importantly, how does it help the town as a whole?  If you can give me a shread of evidence that you could actually gain something from his response, I'll back down, but I really don't think you can.

WHY YOU PHISING?

How am I?  And I want an answer Org.

If it's this one, than I think that you're wrong.  If I could infer your role from your strategy, than I might be role-fishing.  But I'm firmly convinced that you have no such strategy.

Furthermore, you are refusing to answer the earlier question.