Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Criptfeind]

I got Mr. P as Town.

Got him as Scum.

It appears that you have a 2/3 chance of being scum then.

How do you figure?

There are 2 town roles that would give him that. There are 4 scum roles where he may lie about that.

[Toaster]

True, unless you're naive, Double AA is sane, and Person is scum.

[Criptfeind]

Okay. Well.

I have no freeken clue. I guess the only thing I do know is that I am not insane. Sigh. I think I will wait for more people to post before I start trying to find out probabilities.

[Diablous]

And if Insane is multiplying result by -1, and neutral is 0...?

So, an insane cop gets neutral result from a third party? Interesting.

There's no town role that causes a townie to come up third party. So, going by that, either Org is a third party, or Mr. P's lieing.

Okay. Well.

I have no freeken clue. I guess the only thing I do know is that I am not insane. Sigh. I think I will wait for more people to post before I start trying to find out probabilities.

How do you know you are not insane? You got a town result from Mr. Person. That just tells you that you are not paranoid.

[Criptfeind]

How do you know you are not insane? You got a town result from Mr. Person. That just tells you that you are not paranoid.

Sorta the point of the thing you just quoted.

[abculatter_2]

I only barely understand the sanities, though that mathematical approach to them Redwarrior mentioned sounds intriguing. I'll see if i can figure it out before one of you posts an explanation.

EDIT: Seems I'll have to wait for that explanation...

Also, what the fuck does the hippy do besides hug trees and smoke pot?

[Double A]

There's only one way to know if Mr P is scum or not, but it's not very pretty.

I only barely understand the sanities, though that mathematical approach to them Redwarrior mentioned sounds intriguing. I'll see if i can figure it out before one of you posts an explanation.

EDIT: Seems I'll have to wait for that explanation...

Also, what the fuck does the hippy do besides hug trees and smoke pot?

Trade rope reed.

[Diablous]

I only barely understand the sanities, though that mathematical approach to them Redwarrior mentioned sounds intriguing. I'll see if i can figure it out before one of you posts an explanation.

EDIT: Seems I'll have to wait for that explanation...

Also, what the fuck does the hippy do besides hug trees and smoke pot?

3 things.

1. Editing posts is not allowed in Mafia.
 
2. The hippy causes all cops who investigate him to be stoned. He wins when all cops are stoned.
 
3. The sanities are kinda simple. Sane cops find out what the alignment of the person they inspect is. Insane cops find out the opposite alignment. Naive cops always get town results, no matter what the actual alignment is. Paranoid cops always get scum results, no matter what the alignment. Half sane switches between sane and insane.

[Criptfeind]

There's only one way to know if Mr P is scum or not, but it's not very pretty.

Not quite true, at this point it may be better to lynch Org and find out the sanities of thous that investigated him. But we cant know until more people post what they got. I don't think everyone has posted yet, have they?

[Diablous]

Everyone has posted.

Since none of the sanities would cause a townie to get a neutral result from another townie, I'm doubting that Mr. Person lied. Strikes me as too risky. People would know that he lied if Org is killed and turns up townie. So, I will cast the first vote and vote Org. I think he is third party, and his death will help me, Mr. Person, and abculatter_2 figure out our sanities.

[Double A]

I only barely understand the sanities, though that mathematical approach to them Redwarrior mentioned sounds intriguing. I'll see if i can figure it out before one of you posts an explanation.

EDIT: Seems I'll have to wait for that explanation...

Also, what the fuck does the hippy do besides hug trees and smoke pot?

3 things.

1. Editing posts is not allowed in Mafia.
 
2. The hippy causes all cops who investigate him to be stoned. He wins when all cops are stoned.
 
3. The sanities are kinda simple. Sane cops find out what the alignment of the person they inspect is. Insane cops find out the opposite alignment. Naive cops always get town results, no matter what the actual alignment is. Paranoid cops always get scum results, no matter what the alignment. Half sane switches between sane and insane.

Half-sane doesn't sound very fair.

[Lonewolf I]

Everyone has posted.  Here are the claims.

Criptfiend -> Mr. Person (Town)
Mr.Person -> Org (Neutral)
Jokerman-EXE -> Double A (Scum)
Toaster -> Jokerman-EXE (Scum)
Lonewolf I -> Diablous (Scum)
Org -> Diablous (Town)
Double A -> Mr. Person (Scum)
Diablous -> Org (Scum)
Bandages -> Mr. Person (Town)
abculatter_2 -> Org (Town)

The only one out of the ordinary is Mr. Person's claim that Org is neutral.  I say we pick two people other than Mr. Person, Diablous, and abculatter_2 to investigate Org tonight.  One who got a town result, and another who got a scum result.  The rest investigate as they please.  I will be very interested in hearing Mr. Person's results tomorrow.  As for lynching Org, I don't think this situation is extreme enough to merit that course of action.  A plot by scum to claim those they want lynched as neutral seems too easy to me.  We should stick with the tradition of nolynching until harder evidence presents itself.

[abculatter_2]

1. Editing posts is not allowed in Mafia.
 
2. The hippy causes all cops who investigate him to be stoned. He wins when all cops are stoned.
 
3. The sanities are kinda simple. Sane cops find out what the alignment of the person they inspect is. Insane cops find out the opposite alignment. Naive cops always get town results, no matter what the actual alignment is. Paranoid cops always get scum results, no matter what the alignment. Half sane switches between sane and insane.

1. Woops, forgot about that

2. Holy shit that's awesome

3. Ah, okay.


Also, I too vote for nolynch.

[Diablous]

A plot by scum to claim those they want lynched as neutral seems too easy to me.

I doubt that's happening. No sanity causes you to think that a townie is neutral. So, if we lynch someone that is stated to be neutral, and he flips town, we know that the person who claimed the guy to be neutral must be lieing.
 
 
I guess we should get some more info before we kill someone. Unvote. No lynch.

[Criptfeind]

Up to three people are going to die a night. I am not sure if we can waste a town controlled lynch or trust the scum to kill the people that need to die for the most information to come up.