Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Mamobo]

Vote Count
------------------------
-> FallacyofUrist --6-- Jim Groovester*, Maximum Spin*, Toaster*, A_Curious_Cat*, EuchreJack*, EuchreJack*,
EuchreJack        --2-- Fluffe9911*, ToonyMan*,
juicebox          --1-- notquitethere*,
Lenglon           --1-- TricMagic*,
notquitethere     --1-- hector13*,
Toaster           --1-- Knightwing64*,
A_Curious_Cat     --0--
Egan_BW           --0--
Fluffe9911        --0--
hector13          --0--
Jim Groovester    --0--
Knightwing64      --0--
Maximum Spin      --0--
ToonyMan          --0--
TricMagic         --0--
No One            --0--

Not Voting        --4-- Egan_BW*, FallacyofUrist*, juicebox*, Lenglon*,

9 to Hammer. Day ends on April 20, 2023 at 19:00 Central Daylight Time (6 hours and 57 minutes remaining.)

[Jim Groovester]

I'll go verify that Egan_BW's brief effort at the start of Day 1 is better explainable in the context of a mason team, because from my recollection of the rest of Day 1 there is very little in terms of associative tells that tie you together with Egan_BW which would otherwise look scummy but are also consistent with a mason team.

So I briefly skimmed the game looking for anything that would tie Egan_BW and FallacyofUrist together as a team and didn't really find anything, which isn't surprising given Egan_BW's lack of activity. So literally the only thing to go off in support of FallacyofUrist's mason claim is the little hint he dropped about it a day or two ago.

I don't believe it. And if it's true then my understanding of the game is fundamentally wrong and I don't think that's the case since my read on FoU is screaming to me that he's scum, so I'm going to do something stupid that I shouldn't probably do.

THUNDERDOME ME FALLACYOFURIST

MANO A MANO

THE GAME WHERE YOU'RE TOWN WITH EGAN_BW IS NOT THE GAME WE'RE PLAYING

[FallacyofUrist]

Nah, I’m dead.

But you know Jim, Jim, Jim

Is there any reason I shouldn’t take you down with me, if I’m going to die anyways?

[Maximum Spin]

Lenglon, I think, mentioned death millers before. I would have assumed these weren't on the table in a non-bastard game. If they are, I have deep concerns about the current gamestate, while if they aren't I think everything's fine.
webadict, are death falsifiers on the table?

[hector13]

Okay this might be sleep inertia and distractedness talking, but if we’re going to eliminate a claimed Mason, would we not be better eliminating the less active one so the more active one is confirmed town?

If they’re lying scum then it doesn’t necessarily (super power role game aside) matter which order they go in.

[Lenglon]

Jack: In other circumstances, I'd be taking that vote as an amusing joke. In these circumstances, it's sketch. I wasn't happy with ya anyway, and my vote needs a place to be. Enjoy!

Lenglon, I think, mentioned death millers before. I would have assumed these weren't on the table in a non-bastard game. If they are, I have deep concerns about the current gamestate, while if they aren't I think everything's fine.
webadict, are death falsifiers on the table?

I mentioned them on the side when explaining why inspection results aren't 100% in a BYOR. I don't think we actually have any.

[Maximum Spin]

Okay this might be sleep inertia and distractedness talking, but if we’re going to eliminate a claimed Mason, would we not be better eliminating the less active one so the more active one is confirmed town?

I'd honestly rather have a confirmed Egan than a confirmed Fallacy, provided Egan can actually start being present again.

Lenglon, I think, mentioned death millers before. I would have assumed these weren't on the table in a non-bastard game. If they are, I have deep concerns about the current gamestate, while if they aren't I think everything's fine.
webadict, are death falsifiers on the table?

I mentioned them on the side when explaining why inspection results aren't 100% in a BYOR. I don't think we actually have any.

I understood that. I just mean that you bringing them up is the reason they're on my mind.

[TricMagic]

Nah, I’m dead.

But you know Jim, Jim, Jim

Is there any reason I shouldn’t take you down with me, if I’m going to die anyways?

Take me instead. I'm still waiting on that Thunderdome you promised. (I know you didn't, but better me than Jim right?)

Egan can be eliminated as a lurker, yes. But more likely that trickery is going on I think, the best thing Egan can do to survive is just stay silent so FoU dies instead. Ironically the town response will just get him lynched, so good job FoU.


Also, that Jack vote is a perfect example of my misgivings.

[webadict]

webadict, are death falsifiers on the table?

No.  Flips may be hidden/REDACTED, but they will never be outlight lies.

[FallacyofUrist]

Okay this might be sleep inertia and distractedness talking, but if we’re going to eliminate a claimed Mason, would we not be better eliminating the less active one so the more active one is confirmed town?

If they’re lying scum then it doesn’t necessarily (super power role game aside) matter which order they go in.

Obviously I don’t like the idea of eliminating town. But that logic does make sense, from the perspective of someone who genuinely thinks I’m scum.

[TricMagic]

EuchreJack. Since my vote shouldn't be on Lenglon at this point. No more sheep, only baa.

[Jim Groovester]

Nah, I’m dead.

But you know Jim, Jim, Jim

Is there any reason I shouldn’t take you down with me, if I’m going to die anyways?

NONE AT ALL

BRING IT

Okay this might be sleep inertia and distractedness talking, but if we’re going to eliminate a claimed Mason, would we not be better eliminating the less active one so the more active one is confirmed town?

If they’re lying scum then it doesn’t necessarily (super power role game aside) matter which order they go in.

The thunderdome challenge I just issued aside, I'm okay with doing this.

[Lenglon]

I'd prefer to keep both masons alive personally, but if we MUST lynch one, lynching one that isn't playing the game is better, I will admit.

[notquitethere]

I can't recall a game where killing the mason claim first waa the right move. I'd like to be wrong here, but it seems a ridiculously high risk move for a mafia Fallacy.

[Lenglon]

NQT: I just caught myself fixating on the FoU situation and need to fix it. could you re-summarize, or simply link to where you said it before, your reasons for voting juicebox?