Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

@Jack:
Why didn't you claim on Day 3?

Also, I want you to explain the reasoning for your Vector votes on Day 2 and Day 3. They seem unnatural and random.

[ToonyMan]

What makes you think Knightwing jailkeeped?

I am completely guessing.

[EuchreJack]

Also, sorry I wasn't around much during Day 4. I was working a lot.

[EuchreJack]

@Jack:
Why didn't you claim on Day 3?

Also, I want you to explain the reasoning for your Vector votes on Day 2 and Day 3. They seem unnatural and random.

Ah, missed Day 4 questions.  Yay.

Vector looked scummy, so I voted them.  Web looked scummy, and seemed to be working with Vector.

[TricMagic]

What makes you think Knightwing jailkeeped?

I am completely guessing.

You're already outed, so nope. A jailkeep wouldn't have killed the target. Unless Knightwing is third party.

[ToonyMan]

You're already outed, so nope. A jailkeep wouldn't have killed the target. Unless Knightwing is third party.

Fuck you. I'm busting my ass to help town. Even if you believe NQT's incorrect claim it still means I'm not mafia, I think the only third-parties that would want to help mafia in this situation would be a second mafia-ally or a Hunter targeting town.

Spoiler: Look at my Day 2 reads (click to show/hide)

I've colored players that have flipped so far.

Day 2 Reads

Likely Town
Jim - I think they're town, gave me deez nuts, Tric inspected them as town
Juicebox - roleclaim feels very honest, reaction to me claiming Forceful Sentry looks very genuine, their cases have been weak though, is cleared by NQT as either non-killing town or third-party
Knightwing - very town, claimed SK-miller, seems to be thinking for themselves
Tric - general behavior, claimed early, don't really feel like they're lying even with the D2 mess up
Nakeen - I really think they did try to delay me N1, actions seem to make sense, looks like they're acting alone
TolyK - I feel like they're town, gave me a choice last night, claimed miller only under pressure on D1 which isn't great, but I want to like them
NJW - probably town? I mostly liked them on D1 and they really want to thunderdome Webadict which I respect

Fringe
NQT - is playing like complete poo poo, could just be town!NQT on a really really bad week, has misread the game at least half a dozen times it's kind of insane, is putting in a lot of effort even with the wheel spinning
Vector - not sure

Suspicious
Jack - very quiet for Jack, has a wait and see approach to the game, passive, I don't think their action on NQT is very strong as a clear even if confirmable by NQT
Webadict - I kept off Web on D1 since I wanted to see if mafia would kill him N1, that didn't happen, NJW really fucking wants him dead, Webadict is doing that thing where he spews a ton of bullshit and I think he's caused more harm than good in this game so far

I'm trying to find mafia. I only chose Juicebox over Jack (or NQT) on D4 because of incredibly unlucky circumstances and Vector's well played shading of Juice on D1.

NJW being alive after a kill targeting them and also being roleblocked makes me think they were jailkeeped, how is this unreasonable during the time Knightwing isn't here to confirm?

In addition, while I'm thinking about that...

@MOD: If a player none'd are they still notified that they were roleblocked?

[Jim Groovester]

I made a pretty angry rant after the day ended about how unfair this Final Countdown mafiakill is, but because the night took so long I've cooled off and don't think I should post it unless people want to see mad Toony. I think it would be a waste to complain about it at this point and I'm just gonna try to play this game out.

I want to see mad ToonyMan.

Jim, notice anything weird happen?

Negative.

Jim, are you the godfather? Seems like it's your fire that burned NJW, unless one of deez nuts also did something fire-related.

Negative.

Unless the On Fire! status spreads somehow which it does not indicate it does, then nothing in my role would cause NJW2000 to be on fire from anything I did to him.

[TricMagic]

You're already outed, so nope. A jailkeep wouldn't have killed the target. Unless Knightwing is third party.

Fuck you. I'm busting my ass to help town. Even if you believe NQT's incorrect claim it still means I'm not mafia, I think the only third-parties that would want to help mafia in this situation would be a second mafia-ally or a Hunter targeting town.

Spoiler: Look at my Day 2 reads (click to show/hide)

I've colored players that have flipped so far.

Day 2 Reads

Likely Town
Jim - I think they're town, gave me deez nuts, Tric inspected them as town
Juicebox - roleclaim feels very honest, reaction to me claiming Forceful Sentry looks very genuine, their cases have been weak though, is cleared by NQT as either non-killing town or third-party
Knightwing - very town, claimed SK-miller, seems to be thinking for themselves
Tric - general behavior, claimed early, don't really feel like they're lying even with the D2 mess up
Nakeen - I really think they did try to delay me N1, actions seem to make sense, looks like they're acting alone
TolyK - I feel like they're town, gave me a choice last night, claimed miller only under pressure on D1 which isn't great, but I want to like them
NJW - probably town? I mostly liked them on D1 and they really want to thunderdome Webadict which I respect

Fringe
NQT - is playing like complete poo poo, could just be town!NQT on a really really bad week, has misread the game at least half a dozen times it's kind of insane, is putting in a lot of effort even with the wheel spinning
Vector - not sure

Suspicious
Jack - very quiet for Jack, has a wait and see approach to the game, passive, I don't think their action on NQT is very strong as a clear even if confirmable by NQT
Webadict - I kept off Web on D1 since I wanted to see if mafia would kill him N1, that didn't happen, NJW really fucking wants him dead, Webadict is doing that thing where he spews a ton of bullshit and I think he's caused more harm than good in this game so far

I'm trying to find mafia. I only chose Juicebox over Jack (or NQT) on D4 because of incredibly unlucky circumstances and Vector's well played shading of Juice on D1.

NJW being alive after a kill targeting them and also being roleblocked makes me think they were jailkeeped, how is this unreasonable during the time Knightwing isn't here to confirm?

In addition, while I'm thinking about that...

@MOD: If a player none'd are they still notified that they were roleblocked?

Congregation also acts as a bulletproof, once.

[ToonyMan]

I made a pretty angry rant after the day ended about how unfair this Final Countdown mafiakill is, but because the night took so long I've cooled off and don't think I should post it unless people want to see mad Toony. I think it would be a waste to complain about it at this point and I'm just gonna try to play this game out.

I want to see mad ToonyMan.

Maybe. I'm getting mad.

Congregation also acts as a bulletproof, once.

You're right. I missed that because it's been a fucking week.

[TricMagic]

Just to check NQT, do you still have that kill for today?

[Knightwing64]

Every action that targeted Jack instead went to Toony

[TricMagic]

So, we kill Knightwing then? Jim's action got randomized after all.

Question is, who else walks the plank?

[ToonyMan]

Every action that targeted Jack instead went to Toony

Makes sense. You don't trust me and trust Jack for some reason.

So, we kill Knightwing then? Jim's action got randomized after all.

No. I think Knightwing is probably town.

I don't believe mafia have any incentive to try to kill at this point. This is confirmed by Nakeen who claims Jack's N3 action was not a killing action. I don't believe there was a mafiakill even performed on N3 and there couldn't have been a mafiakill on N4. Maybe mafia tried to kill me on N3 and Knightwing blocked it, but this is also unlikely as Vector probably truthfully claimed they tried to Congregate me on N3.

I believe Jack killed Max on N1 (they were not redirected by Knightwing, they clearly went for Max while Vector tried to Congregrate Webadict for later) and that Jack probably tried to kill on N2, but was blocked by Jim.

Tric, why didn't you try to kill last night?

[notquitethere]

Arr, it be entirely possible to have been redirected to a 3rd party. Or some lubber mighta framed ye. Arr, I could have been redirected to KnightWing, if he be telling the truth of his claim.

Mafia most definitely wouldn't appear as Omega, kill or no kill, that I be certain as the sea is wet. Unless they have a miller effect, alas (but look where that horrible thinking led to with poor mate Juicebox). I really did double-check the sextants, maps, and the role pm too!

[ToonyMan]

You seem very concerned.