Lenglon, What do you think?
You don't have any need to ask this Knightwing. I posted my reads list
here and there is exactly one piece of data we've gotten since then, though I do admit it's a bit of a complex and even now still evolving piece of data. We are getting to see various people's panic behaviors, and what their priorities are under pressure as the moment of the lynch draws near. What's happening right now is the last, and absolutely the most valuable, piece of information we're going to get from Day 1. You should be looking carefully for who is acting out of character for themselves, or changing their tune from the rest of the day as a whole, and be attempting to figure out WHY they're doing that.
As always with most things mafia, and especially with Day 1 things, WHY is the most important question.
Lenglon, What do you think?
I'd suggest using your own reasoning to make a decision instead of relying on everyone else's. You're here to learn, aye? Use the reasoning of others to support your own reasoning, but not to replace it.
You can join Shakerag and push Egan down, or join with Egan and vote me (and tie the vote again, which is bad). Or you can even come up with a third, separate case and see if you can convince people to go along with it.
Your role isn't your only set of powers - your words are power, too. It's up to you to use them well.
This piece of advice may be coming from one of the potential lynch targets, but I will vouch for it being good advice anyway.
Egan - I am voting you because of a couple things. For one, as listed when I posted my reads, I have mixed opinions regarding if you are scum or town whereas for me personally FoU has seemed quite towney with all their interactions, analysis, and generally how they've carried themselves all day today. Secondly, I find FoU's form of miller claim easilly acceptable, far more acceptable than your every extreme one, and I don't consider waiting to make his claim until the middle of the day scummy since there still was plenty of time in Day 1. Thirdly, I dislike the lack of reason you had when you decided to turn on FoU. You had been holding your vote in a very considered fashion all day, but when you finally do place it for the day's end lynch your reasons were literally:
FallacyofUrist
ur scum copying my miller claim, cly
Which honestly is not enough to form a lynch case on someone with. Fourth, as I hinted indirectly when talking knightwing through meta-reads, I've been leaving you mostly alone today to give you the space I thought you would need to provide good reads and analysis, with the expectation that around now you'd have posted something similar to the reads list I posted earlier, showing your in-depth thoughts about each player. This expected analysis never came, which could easilly be a sign of a scum player that think they aren't under scrutiny never actually bothering to build a set of believable reads in the first place.
I also will now put on the table the reason I had you marked as "(L) Special" earlier, which I had previously actively decided to keep to myself until Day 2.
The 5 hammer count was only correct at Day start. All others should have been 6.
...
Noted, and I have a theory about why this might be the case, but would like to keep it to myself until tomorrow.
This theory is that you did not start the day with a doublevote, and that you gained doublevote status with the cost of permanently becoming an omega-miller as a day-activated ability. This theory also was the reason I was prepared to accept your omega-miller claim, it seemed like a reasonable price for the extra power, and to me it looked like a perfectly likely role for a player to have. And so in case you didn't notice, I've been treating you like a Mayor all day, and I kept this theory to myself because I wanted to avoid having you targeted. I personally have no major issue with either of our miller claims in a vaccum.
Author
Topic: Beginner Mafia 2: BYOR Edition - Game Over! (Read 41586 times)