I don't care if Egan claimed all of specialised-miller-space, they're rare enough we're entitled to rule out Egan making an improbably good guess that the game has specialised millers and going all-out with a D1 claim.
I don't accept this.
and I'm not convinced that you accept it either.
NJW: On what basis are you assuming Egan's extraordinary claim's extraordinary nature implies the truth of said extraordinary claim?
On none, because I am not. The post before yours makes this clear Egan is only telling the truth in two of three plausible scenarios - and I don't necessarily think they're all equally likely. Like MaximumSpin, you misrepresented me. Kindly do not.
NJW: There are four possibilities, not three:
1) Egan town FoU town. - possible, and not under dispute
2) Egan town FoU scum. - you are advocating for this
3) Egan scum FoU scum. - you have acknowledged this, and it's not under dispute.
4) Egan scum FoU town. - You are dismissing this for no reason, and your dismissal of this is the entire thing I'm pressing you on.
I'm not misrepresenting anything. You are dismissing out of hand option 4, and you have stated that your reason for doing so is
that it is to aduacious to be true. I consider this reason completely unacceptable.
Unlike you, I am not willing to assume that Egan is town if NJW is killed and flips town, the contrapositive of what you have been asserting. If you dismiss option 4, then such would be a logical necessity. I will not humor attempts to set up treating Egan as full-cleared by mafiakilling FoU.