Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[TricMagic]

(1) BluarianKnight- EuchreJack
(1) EuchreJack- hedgrow
(0) prefuzek -
() Magma Mater
(1) webadictFallacyofUrist - prefuzek
(4) hedgerow- Roden, FallacyofUrist, ToonyMan, Magma Mater
(0) Roden-
(0) Rolan7-
(0) ToonyMan[Veteran Player]-

The day grows short, and though some extend time, eventually, that time runs short. In the end though there is no true majority, hedgerow is determined to be the mafiahacker among them.
hedgerow has been trimmed from the pool of players. hedgerow was a 1-shot Bulletproof Townie.

[FOOLS!] static.
{Shut it hacker. I'm confident this is only the first step to your defeat.}

Night 1 ends at 10:10 AM Central Time. Or if all Roles send in their actions.

[TricMagic]

The Night lifts the darkness, and a new day dawns to find the mafiahackers. However, you are one shorter for it. BluarianKnight was sent to the Junkyard next night, crushed by a suit of armor. A somber tune plays. [BluarianKnight was a Vanilla Townie.]

As Rolan7 is no longer in play, they no longer count for victory conditions. This may change if another takes up the torch before the day ends. Due to Vet suggestion, Rolan7 has been Modkilled by the Whitehat. They were a Vanilla Townie.

This now counts as Mislynch and Lose.(Or MYLO. In comparison to Lynch or Lose[LYLO] where you have to lynch.)

() EuchreJack-
() prefuzek -
() Magma Mater
() FallacyofUrist -
() Roden-
() ToonyMan[Veteran Player]-

4 to Hammer.

Day 2 has started, and will end on Monday, 6:30 PM Central Time.

[EuchreJack]

@Toonyman [Veteran Player]: Any advice for what we should be doing Day 2? I've actually never gotten this far...

[ToonyMan]

(This was written during Night 1.)

I need to address something first.

Spoiler: @Hedgerow: (click to show/hide)

@Hedgerow:
You need to claim since you're the top wagon and day ends soon. If you're actually a PR we don't want to vote you.

I need to?

I don't need to be lynched, so make sure you check out my role after you guys bandwagon.

Yes.

You need to claim if you're a town PR and about to be mis-lynched.

A town PR in this setup should never be getting lynched during the day. The fact this happened blows my mind, however I shouldn't be as surprised since this is a newbie game so I'm going to chill and take deep breaths. I'm not sure why you didn't claim as a PR so let me explain why you should claim 100% of the time so you can reflect and improve as a player.

By honestly claiming a town PR you become confirmed town, nobody will be able to vote you anymore. This reduces the possible number of players that could be mafia and increases town's chances of eliminating mafia during the day. Town cannot eliminate mafia during the night, only mafia can eliminate town. By not confirming yourself as town with your PR and allowing yourself to be killed, you were willingly reducing town's chances of hitting mafia on D1.

On top of that, you were the 1-Shot Bulletproof Townie. You were by far the best town PR to out themselves, if they had to out themselves! The BP would take two nights to kill and it's simply not worth it for mafia if they know who the BP is. Yes, you give up the ability to take them by surprise and soak up a kill for one night, but the tradeoff here is that you don't die and a mafia possibly does instead. So the BP gets to stay alive while also being a confirmed town. You would have been alive for the entire game until town won or lost at lylo, you would have likely been there for all of it as a confirmed, voice of reason.

I've edited this down to be less harsh, you don't want to hear my initial reactions to your flip. Please remember this advice if you roll a PR again.

On review, knowing that you were the BP now makes your actions during D1 make more sense. I still don't suspect Roden though. In fact, I don't strongly suspect anyone on your wagon.

Moving on...

Spoiler: N1 Thoughts (click to show/hide)

Hedgerow was the 1-shot Bulletproof Townie, that means the setup has left either a Town Jailkeeper and Mafia Roleblocker, or a Town Tracker with two Mafia Goons. Mafia know who their team's roles so they now know the setup for this Matrix6 game.

Players left are:

BluarianKnight
EuchreJack
prefuzek
Magma Mater
FallacyofUrist
Roden
Rolan7
ToonyMan

I suspect Jack or Magma will be the mafiakill target tonight. It's possible I am as well, but I don't expect it.

I strongly town read Roden/Jack/FoU.

This leaves two mafia inside Blu/Pref/Magma/Rolan.

I find Magma the least suspicious out of these four.
Rolan is a wild card that needs to be filled.

Therefore, I want to see a Blu or Pref lynch on D2 or maybe Rolan.

I think the likely mafia team compositions are:

Blu/Pref
Blu/Rolan
Pref/Rolan

I need to go over their ISOs and the fact that Hedgerow is confirmed town.

I'm surprised by the Bluarian kill. This must have been a "looking for the other PR" kill or they wanted to remove someone from my FoU/Blu/Me lylo list so thanks for that.

This leaves my POE - or Process of Elimination - with Pref/Magma/Rolan.

@TricMagic:

As Rolan7 is no longer in play, they no longer count for victory conditions. This may change if another takes up the torch before the day ends.

If no replacement is found for Rolan7, this could count as Mislynch and Lose.(Or MYLO. In comparison to Lynch or Lose[LYLO] where you have to lynch.) Note this only applies if Rolan7 is town.

No. This isn't acceptable. You can't gimp town today if Rolan is town and force us to vote no lynch. That's not fair.

[ToonyMan]

@Toonyman [Veteran Player]: Any advice for what we should be doing Day 2? I've actually never gotten this far...

Boycott until Tric changes the rules.

Why do you think Bluarian was killed?

Do you also think the two mafia are inside Pref/Magma/Rolan?

[EuchreJack]

@Toonyman [Veteran Player]: Any advice for what we should be doing Day 2? I've actually never gotten this far...

Boycott until Tric changes the rules.

Why do you think Bluarian was killed?

Do you also think the two mafia are inside Pref/Magma/Rolan?

Blue was killed because the scumteam is dumb.  I was going to post D2 "Hey, Blue must be mafia because I'm still alive!  Any combination that doesn't include Blue would kill me as confirmed town, since they can't push the vote onto me, and they know there is no doctor or bulletproof.  Only Blue, whom I suspected, would keep me alive.  Any other scum team would want me dead, and Blue getting suspected would just be gravy."
...and then BLUE is dead.

Scum team is most likely Pref & Magma.  Or, it doesn't matter if one of them is scumbuddies with Rolan7, since Rolan7 is out.

I support the boycott.

[TricMagic]

Very well then. Though I did note the whole bastardized bit given this isn't a situation I am normally prepared for. Not enough experience.

Rolan7 has ben modkilled. Rolan7 was a Vanilla Townie

So now it is officially MYLO.

[EuchreJack]

@Tric: You Bastard 

Nah, it seems fair enough to me.

[TricMagic]

Toony is the Vet. His word counts double given I don't have much 'on the fly' GMEXP.

[ToonyMan]

Very well then. Though I did note the whole bastardized bit given this isn't a situation I am normally prepared for. Not enough experience.

Rolan7 has ben modkilled. Rolan7 was a Vanilla Townie

So now it is officially MYLO.

lol

[EuchreJack]

@Toonyman: Why do you see Pref & Magma as a team, as opposed to either player being on a team with someone else, like FOU for example.

[ToonyMan]

So now it is officially MYLO.

I don't think Tric intended this, but they may have mod-slipped the setup is a town Tracker with two Goons because it's not technically MYLO if the town has a Jailkeeper and stops/protects the mafiakill tonight. I'm okay with pointing this out since the mafia know the setup now anyway.

@Toonyman: Why do you see Pref & Magma as a team, as opposed to either player being on a team with someone else, like FOU for example.

I'm about to watch stuff with some people but I can respond more when I'm back in an hour or two.

[TricMagic]

To be honest, it's bedtime and I go a bit crazy. I am not the bastion of green advice you are toony.

You should probably assume it is anyway, since if it is you had better hit the right button. And not the red one, or was it green?

Anyway, Goodnight.

[EuchreJack]

@Toonyman: No problem, we certainly have the time.  Especially since No Lynch has at least marginal strategic use.  Advice on voting in this situation would be appreciated.  I'm probably going to be leery of voting too soon.

[ToonyMan]

Quick post first.

@Toonyman: No problem, we certainly have the time.  Especially since No Lynch has at least marginal strategic use.  Advice on voting in this situation would be appreciated.  I'm probably going to be leery of voting too soon.

We don't vote anyone today. If we're wrong we lose now thanks to the modkill.

We vote for no lynch (or sleep I've seen it called) and force the mafia to clear another player by killing them. But first we need to have some discussion to determine the scum.

If the mafia team isn't Magma/Pref then I can only conclude my re-evaluation was wrong and that the team really is just Jack/FoU. I highly doubt Roden is mafia unless they are playing me hard.

It's straight up these two combinations in my opinion:

Magma/Pref - high likelihood
Jack/FoU - low likelihood

FoU can't be mafia with Magma or Pref because both were trying to kill FoU at the end of Day 1.
I don't think Jack is mafia anymore and this read is stronger than my town read of FoU.
Roden I strongly town read.

I will be exploring Pref/Magma interactions to see if there's anything decisive.