That's some real Nazi shit.
It's really not even close.
Republicans voted to throw her out of her committee assignments. Her constituents elected her, and she hadn't broken any rules, so I think that's more than might be expected of Dems, who won't even censure their own over antisemitic comments.
Besides that point, your reply consists of moving the goal posts and no true Scotsman fallacy. If you want to say that Republicans fall in line every time, then you can supply the data.
Lol, "republicans voted to throw her out". Let's look at the exact vote. 230-199, with 11 republicans voting to remove her. Sounds a lot like democrats voted her out. Also, haven't we gone over this exact topic before? This is what I mean by "falling in line". There should be no question that Greene is fucking insane. But republicans will vote to keep her, because they want power. Another vote is slightly better for them so fuck morals.
And if you don't see how blaming Jews for causing natural disasters isn't neo-nazi rhetoric, then I suggest you take some time looking up how neo-nazis talk in their circles. It's just constant blaming the jews for everything and denying the holocaust... But maybe you think I am saying this demonstrates she is a nazi, and I'm not. I'm saying she is repeating neo-nazi rhetoric. Either way, 199 republicans showed approval of that.
"fall in line" is a VERY vague term, and I have provided examples as to why I think it qualifies. If you want to dilute what I meant down to "different parties vote differently" then no shit. No one would say otherwise. If a party often didn't vote together, they wouldn't really be a party in the first place. You posting irrelevant data because you uncharitably interpreted what I meant doesn't mean I am performing a no true Scotsman fallacy because I am not adhering to what you define "fall in line" as.
And just to finish this off. Your accusation of anti-Semitic comments refers to pointing out Israel's war crimes = anti-Semitism. Which is stupid. The country of Israel doesn't represent the race of Jewish people and trying to attach the two together is wrong. We've also already had this argument.
Author
Topic: AmeriPol thread (Read 4468382 times)