Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

Yay

6 (46.2%)

Nay

7 (53.8%)

Total Members Voted: 13

[Demonic Spoon]

Fellow Players, can I make a tower following the planet rules?

Since apparently everyone needs to approve before I do anything not explicitly allowed by the rules. Can't say I'm really a fan of this approach to running a game, no creative freedom to make non-standard planets for you godling!

[hector13]

They are specifically rules for making planets. There's nothing to interpret, even creatively. Is the tower a planet?

[Kilojoule Proton]

Andres: That was intended as a jab at having two races named humans, but I like your alternate interpretation. Of course, future YGs run by me (if any at all, given shady conspiracy squad or ecosystem builder seem like fun alternatives to a fifth YG attempt) will surely block such things as boring normal planet-star systems that resemble the realistic case, living creations named humans, and other minor things like that.

Demonic Spoon: OK, then. To be fair, the total surface area of Mars is comparable to the area of the Pacific...

piratejoe: Why me?

Fiery Death: It looks like I didn't. The corrected entry is Luuc (Judgment, Underworld) 4/21E

[piratejoe]

Of course, future YGs run by me will surely block such things as boring normal planet-star systems that resemble the realistic case, living creations named humans, and other minor things like that.

Im going to take a quote here, if everyone's special no one is.

piratejoe: Why me?

Because you are the one who posted the atlas and are the only one who can modify it.

[crazyabe]

Spoiler: THE UNGALITHS (click to show/hide)

Name: "The Ungalith"
Disc: "A group of Truly massive Whale like creatures made for mass advertising"
Traits: "Size_3" "Cha_3" "Dex_-1" "Unnusual form_Color shifting geared towards Advertising" "Flight" "Immortal" "Enviro. Spec. Very high altitudes" "Night Vision"
Price: 4 / 1000 * ([1.5 * 2 * 2 * 2] * 2) * .75 * 1.7 * 1.5 * 3 * 1  * 1.2 * 5 = 3.3048
Amount: 1000 / 1000 * 5

[Stirk]

Fellow Players, can I make a tower following the planet rules?

Since apparently everyone needs to approve before I do anything not explicitly allowed by the rules. Can't say I'm really a fan of this approach to running a game, no creative freedom to make non-standard planets for you godling!

I think it is completely within the rules. But it is completely pointless to have a planet attached to another one? Like, there is really no reason to waste that much essence seeing as it has no benefit. We already have too many planets to keep track of anyway :9.

[Rolepgeek]

Isn't meta knowledge fun? *>_>

*grumbles annoyedly*

[Chevaleresse]

Fellow Players, can I make a tower following the planet rules?

Since apparently everyone needs to approve before I do anything not explicitly allowed by the rules. Can't say I'm really a fan of this approach to running a game, no creative freedom to make non-standard planets for you godling!

I think it is completely within the rules. But it is completely pointless to have a planet attached to another one? Like, there is really no reason to waste that much essence seeing as it has no benefit. We already have too many planets to keep track of anyway :9.

we have two planets

[Stirk]

Fellow Players, can I make a tower following the planet rules?

Since apparently everyone needs to approve before I do anything not explicitly allowed by the rules. Can't say I'm really a fan of this approach to running a game, no creative freedom to make non-standard planets for you godling!

I think it is completely within the rules. But it is completely pointless to have a planet attached to another one? Like, there is really no reason to waste that much essence seeing as it has no benefit. We already have too many planets to keep track of anyway :9.

we have two planets

See? Stirk can't even keep track of how many we have!

[Andres]

Andres: That was intended as a jab at having two races named humans, but I like your alternate interpretation. Of course, future YGs run by me (if any at all, given shady conspiracy squad or ecosystem builder seem like fun alternatives to a fifth YG attempt) will surely block such things as boring normal planet-star systems that resemble the realistic case, living creations named humans, and other minor things like that.

I'm confused. Is the incident with the two groups of humans canon or not?

[Rolepgeek]

Yes, it is canon, and you are making a disproportionately large fuss about it, as well as being rather snippy with the GM who takes time out of his day to run this game for no compensation other than a job well done.

[Demonic Spoon]

Since apparently everyone needs to approve before I do anything not explicitly allowed by the rules. Can't say I'm really a fan of this approach to running a game, no creative freedom to make non-standard planets for you godling!

I think it is completely within the rules. But it is completely pointless to have a planet attached to another one? Like, there is really no reason to waste that much essence seeing as it has no benefit. We already have too many planets to keep track of anyway :9.

Fair enough, but I do want to waste my essence on it

[Andres]

Yes, it is canon, and you are making a disproportionately large fuss about it, as well as being rather snippy with the GM who takes time out of his day to run this game for no compensation other than a job well done.

The whole situation confused me and I asked what was going on. I was then further confused at the answer so I asked if it was canon and therefore something my god might react to or if it was just something funny to read. I wasn't being snippy, Rolepgeek, and I don't appreciate being accused of attacking KJP by asking a few damn questions.

[hector13]

Let's hope RPG doesn't respond. I don't think we need a flame war.

You've each had an angry post. Please to stop now.

[Kilojoule Proton]

piratejoe: I'll consider it. It does mostly involve skimming through past updates and writing blurbs for locations, but I do rather like when players submit deliberately slightly unreliable accounts of events/locations.

Andres: Let's see...
    Disembodied humans graciously treated as normal humans were created by Malakath for all sorts of bizarre experiments. Probably leading to misleading conclusions.
    Smart, wise humans, the first actually providing any worship, got created by Luuc on some woodland island.
    Humans were "given bodies" (aka finally placed in Creation) by Malakath, technically the second to provide worship but by less than a Tick, so it's practically simultaneous.
    A Tick update comes in saying that Luuc's humans "...have yet to do much but try to stir up confusion with the Malakathite humans." In hindsight, this was a poor way to describe what was happening and assigned the blame to them.

At the end of this all, we end up with a mildly confused set of players thinking that Luuc's humans had something to do with Malakath's humans (which would not have happened without either's humans, funnily enough), thus confirming the poorly woorded description with a terrible twist. Also, depending on the consensus, it may be the case that Luuc's humans did in fact stir up confusion with Malakath's humans all along.

Confused?