How do we (by which I mean me and you, @Hector) kill Moonlit tomorrow?
I'm willing to give it a go, if consensus goes that way, but obviously we'd need another day anyway.
(And I've yet to distinguish between you and Moonlit, also. I mean, I generally like Captains better than Politicians, but... well, tomorrow's another day.)
But, so I have it straight (and with the correct F-names, this time!) alleged Historian Fish is going to try to kill off alleged Pacifist Fallacy, but just to make sure, one of me/you/Moonlit are going to also vote against Fallacy. The other two vote against Fish (again, just to make sure). And if either of those survive the night, we know there's something wrong (they didn't have really have any votes upon them!) and deal with it accordingly.
But if tomorrow happens (which you say it will, but if you're not right about then I'm really not sure what situation we're now in... so I'm forced to accept the premise) with just us three then... we shall see what needs doing. I honestly can't commit to either plan, right now. (There's a night first but should I happen to need avenging, rather than merely provide assistance in prosecuting the wrong'un, I hope the remaining survivor can do something about it. As I'll try to do if I discover either of you two dead and flipped as innocent and thus definitively pointing to the other as the Big Bad. Worst case scenario, you start hitting each other, instead, just to soften each other up for heroic/nefarious reasons of your own, right?)