Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[fillipk]

fillipk, do we know what actually killed the human cannon ball and Jack?

They were killed in their trailer, cause of death is pointy things.

[TheDarkStar]

fillipk, do we know what actually killed the human cannon ball and Jack?

I want to theorycraft for a second. I'm fairly sure that TMS is full of shit right now, but he's also unlikely to be scum unless hector's role was designed specifically to throw us off the scent if he got lynched (the part about dying the day after Bingo- there wouldn't be another day if Bingo were scum unless there's another anti town player). So, of the people that are left who can get past a trapeze artist?
-A magician? Yeah, this would seem most likely to me in a vacuum as well, but I know I didn't do it.
-A hypnotist? Actually getting past NQT seems unlikely, but hypnotizing players during the day and making them kill themselves seems possible.
-A strongman? Unlikely.
-A tightrope walker? If the tightrope is higher than the trapeze I guess?
-A lion tamer? Could have sent a lion to kill Jack I guess.

At the minute TDS seems the most likely to me.

If you follow that reasoning, then the sharp object thing would only lead to the lion tamer or the magician - a strongman would strangle/punch someone to death, a tightrope walker would do something with rope (hang them?), and a hypnotist would have to cause a trapeze artist to act against themselves with sharp objects.  NQT not noticing anything makes me suspect that it was the magician (who would have a number of ways to kill people - sawing in half, making important organs disappear, etc). Or NQT could be lying (an untrackable SK seems a bit powerful in a setup like this), but it seems less likely.

So Deus Asmoth, you're the magician, correct?

[TheDarkStar]

Remember that as an SK any of them could've just ditched their stuff and grabbed a knife, though. Hanging someone whose resisting isn't exactly untrackable, so...

First sentence: True - unvote while I think about things.
Second sentence: What do you mean?

[TheDarkStar]

That's why I doubt that O. Wilde is the SK, yes.

[O.Wilde]

Ok, so day is gonna end pretty soon. Here we go.

ATH - I am on the fence about you. I found you rather suspicious earlier for being the only claimed VT, but now Deus has also claimed VT that's no longer an issue. Town leaning. You are not voting right now.

BHK - You aren't voting right now, why not?

Deus - Lurker Mc. Lurkington. Currently voting TDS.

NQT - Confirmed town, currently voting Deus.

TMS - I think you're another jester with a suicide thing, which is why you're scrambling to get lynched. Voting Self. Of course, could be bluffing Jester, but I doubt it.

TDS - Lurker Mc. Lurkington V.2. Not currently voting.

Honestly, I'm not entirely sure to proceed at this point, so I'm gonna hash it out like this. The Dark Star: Reading back on your posts, I've found pretty much nothing of any value. You barely post, and when you do, it's small nitpicks or semantics. I've never really seen you go after anyone either, it's all a bunch of little worthless chatter. I think you're scum.

[O.Wilde]

EBWOP RE: The one person who asked my about my night action.

I do have a night action, however I neglected to use it last night due to idiocy on my part, so I have no results so far.

[fillipk]

Day 2

"Well this has been productive, are you guys any closer to finding the killer?  Well hurry it on up."


TheDarkStar - O.Wilde, Deus Asmoth (2)
Deus Asmoth - notquitethere, (1)
Abstracttraitorhero (0)
TheMoonlitShadow - TheMoonlitShadow, (1)
O.Wilde (0)
notquitethere (0)
BlackHeartKabal (0)

Not Voting - TheDarkStar, BlackHeartKabal, Abstracttraitorherop

2 extensions left
0/3 to extend
0/4 to shorten

Day ends on Monday, February 8^th 8:00pm PST

[fillipk]

...

'Day ends on Friday Monday 8th 8:00pm PST'

"Its the killer out there, he's on my nerves messing with my ability to speak coherently, find him."

[BlackHeartKabal]

BHK - You aren't voting right now, why not?

I thought I was voting TDS, wasn't I?

[Deus Asmoth]

You haven't voted at all today as far as I can see. Do you think TDS is the scummiest player?

[TheDarkStar]

Well looks like Fillipk overlooked it as well, which means you're probably lying. So give us a quote from earlier or... bandwagoning much? Same with what you did the last day...

So why aren't you voting for BHK if you think he's lying?

BHK: Explain?

[TheDarkStar]

Because BHK obviously isn't scum. After all, he told was the first to claim a role before knowing that roles came with set alignments, and he even claimed a role that could easily be the SK.

This seems to indicate that he would be the SK?

[Deus Asmoth]

Because BHK obviously isn't scum. After all, he told was the first to claim a role before knowing that roles came with set alignments, and he even claimed a role that could easily be the SK.

...this doesn't make any sense. How would the lion tamer easily be the untrackable SK? Why would he claim a different role than his own when someone counterclaiming him would just most likely wind up with him dead? How does the roles having set alignments make any difference when we don't know what the set alignment for any role besides NQT's is?

[BlackHeartKabal]

Well looks like Fillipk overlooked it as well, which means you're probably lying. So give us a quote from earlier or... bandwagoning much? Same with what you did the last day...

So why aren't you voting for BHK if you think he's lying?

BHK: Explain?

I had no problem claiming that I was the lion tamer. I was the first to claim it because that's what I am and I was asked.

Now, the untrackable SK thing. Untrackable SK wouldn't be in such a small setup, that's stupid. I'm pretty certain a large cat killing people under orders would be easily trackable and give very unique flavor (ex. this guy was mauled by a lion ).

And now you're voting me. So many other suspects that make far more sense, and you vote me. Might as well vote NQT. You're backed into a corner, aren't you, TheDarkStar? I'm playing scenarios through my head and I can't see why a townie would make such a move, unless you're honestly convinced I'm an SK.

Are you convinced i'm an SK, truly?

Well, i'm convinced that you're scum. It makes sense. A "mysterious hypnotist", that makes you do what you want. In flavor, that sounds like someone who's out for themselves, separate from the others.

The Dark Star's play, and his role? Three theories.

1. He is the Town Roleblocker, and has messed up badly.
2. He is a scum role that can manipulate or redirect the actions of others.
3. He is the Serial Killer.

It makes a lot of sense for the SK to appear... eager to hunt the SK. So I'm going to go with the third theory.

[BlackHeartKabal]

Well looks like Fillipk overlooked it as well, which means you're probably lying. So give us a quote from earlier or... bandwagoning much? Same with what you did the last day...

So why aren't you voting for BHK if you think he's lying?

BHK: Explain?

I had no problem claiming that I was the lion tamer. I was the first to claim it because that's what I am and I was asked.

Now, the untrackable SK thing. Untrackable SK wouldn't be in such a small setup, that's stupid. I'm pretty certain a large cat killing people under orders would be easily trackable and give very unique flavor (ex. this guy was mauled by a lion ).

And now you're voting me. So many other suspects that make far more sense, and you vote me. Might as well vote NQT. You're backed into a corner, aren't you, TheDarkStar? I'm playing scenarios through my head and I can't see why a townie would make such a move, unless you're honestly convinced I'm an SK.

Are you convinced i'm an SK, truly?

Well, i'm convinced that you're scum. It makes sense. A "mysterious hypnotist", that makes you do what you want. In flavor, that sounds like someone who's out for themselves, separate from the others.

The Dark Star's play, and his role? Three theories.

1. He is the Town Roleblocker, and has messed up badly.
2. He is a scum role that can manipulate or redirect the actions of others.
3. He is the Serial Killer.

It makes a lot of sense for the SK to appear... eager to hunt the SK. So I'm going to go with the third theory.

Whoops, TheDarkStar