Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

Import YG2 stuff to YG-lite

9 (27.3%)

Import YG2 stuff to YG-lite

10 (30.3%)

Start from scratch for YG-lite

4 (12.1%)

Start from scratch for YG-lite

3 (9.1%)

Do both

5 (15.2%)

Do both

2 (6.1%)

Total Members Voted: 18

[Happy Demon]

Actually, maybe I should just have Si opt out of the council vote, and just make her own planet, regardless of which choice wins.

[Stirk]

Actually, it's as if people decided they will be only be making 1 pile of rocks, and they all work together, then get angry because someone made another pile of rocks.
The council is about collaborative actions, so it shouldn't even be concerned about what a single god is doing.

But if it's that bad, I can make it a secret action.

Assuming this scenario came to pass:

We all voted on having one planet. He decides "I wanted more planets than this" and makes another one.

That is annoying to me.

If we had all voted on three planets, and we decided "I want less planets then this" and combined all three, it would be equally annoying.

It isn't my character that is annoyed, it is me. The Council really has nothing to do with it. The general thing is that the majority would agree on a setting (Number of planets being a very important part of the game world), and he would go against that as a member of a minority for no real reason.

[tntey]

Actually, it's as if people decided they will be only be making 1 pile of rocks, and they all work together, then get angry because someone made another pile of rocks.
The council is about collaborative actions, so it shouldn't even be concerned about what a single god is doing.

But if it's that bad, I can make it a secret action.

Assuming this scenario came to pass:

We all voted on having one planet. He decides "I wanted more planets than this" and makes another one.

That is annoying to me.

If we had all voted on three planets, and we decided "I want less planets then this" and combined all three, it would be equally annoying.

It isn't my character that is annoyed, it is me. The Council really has nothing to do with it. The general thing is that the majority would agree on a setting (Number of planets being a very important part of the game world), and he would go against that as a member of a minority for no real reason.

That's true.

[Rolepgeek]

Actually, maybe I should just have Si opt out of the council vote, and just make her own planet, regardless of which choice wins.

Why do you need your own planet?

You realize that unless you make either a shitty race or use up nearly everything you have, you won't actually be able to use it, right?

Or prevent other gods from doing so?

[tntey]

Actually, maybe I should just have Si opt out of the council vote, and just make her own planet, regardless of which choice wins.

Why do you need your own planet?

You realize that unless you make either a shitty race or use up nearly everything you have, you won't actually be able to use it, right?

Or prevent other gods from doing so?

Yeah, why would you need other planets?

[Happy Demon]

Actually, maybe I should just have Si opt out of the council vote, and just make her own planet, regardless of which choice wins.

Why do you need your own planet?

You realize that unless you make either a shitty race or use up nearly everything you have, you won't actually be able to use it, right?

Or prevent other gods from doing so?

Yeah, why would you need other planets?

Well... Si isn't very much for sharing. Or talking, or voting, or being part of a council.
She's more of a rogue deity, excluding herself from the council.

But...

Would you trust a god which abandons the council? Would you help a god that abandoned the council, if she were attacked, by a council member?
Would you even trust them to not attack you? Would you attack them before they can attack you?
Basically, Si is an easy target if she leaves the council, one you can easily kill, and nobody would mind.
Heck, you could even smash whatever planet she makes, and nobody would even bat an eye.

[Vgray]

I fully expect people to start leaving the council as soon as Creation is over.

[Rolepgeek]

Yeah, and when you're using up Ichor like crazy, you're putting yourself in a poor position to be such a rogue god.

So again, why do you need your own planet? Is Si just not willing to share, ever?

[tntey]

I would like to make some sub councils.

[Happy Demon]

I fully expect people to start leaving the council as soon as Creation is over.

And I expect some to stay, and hunt down the ones who left.

Yeah, and when you're using up Ichor like crazy, you're putting yourself in a poor position to be such a rogue god.

So again, why do you need your own planet? Is Si just not willing to share, ever?

Well, it's not entirely sure if I will make her create her own planet. But sharing would almost necessitate talking, and Si's not the one to talk.

[tntey]

Yeah, what's the point of the council after creation?

[Stirk]

Well... Si isn't very much for sharing. Or talking, or voting, or being part of a council.
She's more of a rogue deity, excluding herself from the council.

But...

Would you trust a god which abandons the council? Would you help a god that abandoned the council, if she were attacked, by a council member?
Would you even trust them to not attack you? Would you attack them before they can attack you?
Basically, Si is an easy target if she leaves the council, one you can easily kill, and nobody would mind.
Heck, you could even smash whatever planet she makes, and nobody would even bat an eye.

That doesn't give you a reason to make your own planet. If everyone makes their own planet, this game isn't any fun. Personally, the Don isn't about to let you have your own planet untouched, he will, at the very least, take some of it for his own turf. You don't expect everyone to just let your planet waddle along, ignored by all Gods, do you?

Like I said, if you really, really want to make your own place, why not just content yourself with a small moon that doesn't annoy everyone?

I fully expect people to start leaving the council as soon as Creation is over.

As do I. Won't be much of it left, it is technically just a Pantheon anyway.

[Rolepgeek]

I fully expect people to start leaving the council as soon as Creation is over.

I won't be. There's no real reason to. You only pay for things you support, after all. Leaving just means you can't vote on what does get passed.

I don't really see why you think the Council members would hunt down everyone who left like bloodthirsty beasts, though. Why would they need to or care to?

[Happy Demon]

You're putting words in my mouth now, please stop that.
I never said she would be ignored, I never said all the gods should make their own planets.

I fully expect someone to kill her and take her planet, I expect her to be made an example of (if she makes her own planet).
I never expected Si to survive.

[DreamerGhost]

Creating an extra planet is not quite the same as combining three. In one scenario, creations of others are left untouched.