Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[FallacyofUrist]

WIFOM is usually very bad for town. It is one of the scum's best weapons.

It is circular reasoning caused by trying to predict what someone will do knowing his actions are subject to scrutiny.

[Hiddenleafguy]

My aim in the game is to find all of those scummy wrestler mafia members and lynch them, also to have fun and ya know not get murdered in the middle of the night. My mask is camouflage, since I am Hiddenleafguy.

[FallacyofUrist]

That post says "I'm scum."

Reasons:
1. Passiveness. You could have included some attacks and hunting in that post also.
2. For that matter, active lurking(though I still need more info).
3. You don't have to be alive to win, from what I know(that's only for survivors).
4. And my gut.

[Hiddenleafguy]

Hmm I'm not very angry yet, you won't like me when I'm angry also I could also argue that you are scum because you are aggressive and are accusing me because I didn't accuse someone.
Also the active lurking is because I leave my browser open when i do stuff.

[FallacyofUrist]

...
1. To start with, you could argue that I'm scum because I'm aggressive, but note that scum are mostly more passive than town.
Since you're new: proof: Town in basic games don't all have powers. Since most Town don't have other methods, the best method they have of finding scum is hunting, aggressively. Scum know who the town are, so they need to eliminate the town without being removed-thus focusing on defense, and thus passiveness.
2. Active lurking means making posts without real/relevant content in a Mafia game to avoid being called out on real lurking.
3. Your thoughts are all over the place.
Explain yourself or I'm voting you over notquitethere.

[Urist McCoder]

hiddenleafguy why did you edit your post?

[FallacyofUrist]

I would like to note that post editing is frowned upon in Mafia games for obvious reasons. Considering he's new he might have an excuse for the moment, though.

Hmm I'm not very angry yet, you won't like me when I'm angry also I could also argue that you are scum because you are aggressive and are accusing me because I didn't accuse someone.
Also the active lurking is because I leave my browser open when i do stuff.

I'm going to quote this bit so if you edit it again for some reason we'll know easier. I didn't notice the first time you did it.

[Urist McCoder]

judging from the time stamps he edited it immediately after he posted.

[Urist McCoder]

Noquitehere, can we hear some of your opinions?

[FallacyofUrist]

It was different. I posted my response before he edited. Hm.

Okay, that's it. I'm saying a notquitethere and a hiddenleafguy scum team for the moment. Let's take them down.

Should I keep my vote on nqt or move it to hlg?

[Teneb]

Hmm I'm not very angry yet, you won't like me when I'm angry also I could also argue that you are scum because you are aggressive and are accusing me because I didn't accuse someone.
Also the active lurking is because I leave my browser open when i do stuff.

Please do not edit your posts.

For any questions related to terminology, please read the OP. Seriously, read the OP. Skim it, at least.

It's ok (appreciated, even), but wait until both ICs have a chance to post in response before doing this again.

[FallacyofUrist]

Would a vote count be helpful at the moment?
I'm saying yes. It'll help me to visualize what's going on.

[Urist McCoder]

if you are right about NQT and hiddenleafguy it would be a brilliant move on NQT part to immediately voted for hiddenleafguy. so that later on in the game he could reference that in his defense if someone said that he and hiddenleafguy are the scumteam.

as for who you should vote for Fallacyofurist I would put some more pressure on NQT to see what he does.

[Urist McCoder]

I am sorry about my previous post grammatical mistakes

[Graknorke]

Graknorke, you're scum and you think you know who the jailor and the cop are. Who do you kill first and why?

Would there be any reason to not pick the jailor? This isn't a snarky dismissive answer either, that seems like a bit of a non-question to me.

So, a question for Everyone, what experience have you had with (forum or otherwise) Mafia before now?
Myself, I've been in one BM before, 45. I feel that the experience taught me a lot about holes, digging, and when to stop. Also that 4mask is terrifyingly focused if he sets his sights on you.


And because I just couldn't resist:
Hiddenlefguy

you won't like me when I'm angry