Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Teneb]

Oh you mean tests. I thought you meant the final rounds of the game.

...Final rounds?

It's D3. There have been 2 nights and 2 lynches so far. All lynches were town. So out of 7 players, 3 are cultists. If we hit town today, we end up with a 3v3 situation. I don't know if cult wins then, but they certainly win when they do their convert and it ends up being 4v2. If we hit a generic cultist and cult still wins in 3v3... we are fucked. Either we hit the cult leader or we lose. And that's a 1/7 chance.

Tiruin sorry missed that bit about my logic behind voting you. Basically my logic was you have a very high skill level as you have been in more than 20 games therefore you would find it easy to fake being town.

That's... pretty WIFOM. I myself have resigned to the fact that I cannot look town most of the time. Experience is no guarantee of any alignment. Though rarer, I've also seen cases where someone in their first game outplayed everyone.

Though this is hypocritical as it gets, roo has done nothing in this game but spread ambiguity around and ask to be converted. Due to the lack of any leads that I can see, and this smelling like a gambit to look like (bad) town (because I know roo isn't bad, just possesses a non-standard style), it warrants a vote. 

[Jack A T]

If we hit a generic cultist and cult still wins in 3v3... we are fucked.

Cult wins in a tie like that.

[origamiscienceguy]

Oh you mean tests. I thought you meant the final rounds of the game.

...Final rounds?

It's D3. There have been 2 nights and 2 lynches so far. All lynches were town. So out of 7 players, 3 are cultists. If we hit town today, we end up with a 3v3 situation. I don't know if cult wins then, but they certainly win when they do their convert and it ends up being 4v2. If we hit a generic cultist and cult still wins in 3v3... we are fucked. Either we hit the cult leader or we lose. And that's a 1/7 chance.

Tiruin sorry missed that bit about my logic behind voting you. Basically my logic was you have a very high skill level as you have been in more than 20 games therefore you would find it easy to fake being town.

That's... pretty WIFOM. I myself have resigned to the fact that I cannot look town most of the time. Experience is no guarantee of any alignment. Though rarer, I've also seen cases where someone in their first game outplayed everyone.

Though this is hypocritical as it gets, roo has done nothing in this game but spread ambiguity around and ask to be converted. Due to the lack of any leads that I can see, and this smelling like a gambit to look like (bad) town (because I know roo isn't bad, just possesses a non-standard style), it warrants a vote.

I haven't been keeping much track of this game, but If we still have the Jailer, hitting a generic cultist could still work.

[Teneb]

Oh you mean tests. I thought you meant the final rounds of the game.

...Final rounds?

It's D3. There have been 2 nights and 2 lynches so far. All lynches were town. So out of 7 players, 3 are cultists. If we hit town today, we end up with a 3v3 situation. I don't know if cult wins then, but they certainly win when they do their convert and it ends up being 4v2. If we hit a generic cultist and cult still wins in 3v3... we are fucked. Either we hit the cult leader or we lose. And that's a 1/7 chance.

Tiruin sorry missed that bit about my logic behind voting you. Basically my logic was you have a very high skill level as you have been in more than 20 games therefore you would find it easy to fake being town.

That's... pretty WIFOM. I myself have resigned to the fact that I cannot look town most of the time. Experience is no guarantee of any alignment. Though rarer, I've also seen cases where someone in their first game outplayed everyone.

Though this is hypocritical as it gets, roo has done nothing in this game but spread ambiguity around and ask to be converted. Due to the lack of any leads that I can see, and this smelling like a gambit to look like (bad) town (because I know roo isn't bad, just possesses a non-standard style), it warrants a vote.

I haven't been keeping much track of this game, but If we still have the Jailer, hitting a generic cultist could still work.

No, they'd have to hit the leader. Only the leader converts, if I recall correctly.

[Teneb]

EBWOP: Or, I guess, the target of the leader. But certainly not a generic cultists.

[origamiscienceguy]

No, I mean if we hit a generic cultist, and te game dowsn't end, it means that we have a jailer still. And the jailer can either hit the cult leader or his/her target at which point, we would be in the same situation as today. Alternatively, we could get lucky and hit the leader and make the game a lot easier.

[Jack A T]

Mod note: If there are three cultists and three town left, whether or not a jailer lives, cult wins.

[Teneb]

So either we hit the leader now, or we lose. Great. It's LYLO and I am certainly not confident on our odds.

[Deus Asmoth]

In that case, there's no point in lynching roo, since he's guaranteed to not be the leader. unvote for now.

[Tiruin]

PFP because reading back (will make formal post on Monday)
The one bonus I subtly mentioned (indirectly) when speaking about Roo's Power in D1 is...the mere fact that he can't even be the CULT LEADER but may be Cult.

Though this is hypocritical as it gets, roo has done nothing in this game but spread ambiguity around and ask to be converted. Due to the lack of any leads that I can see, and this smelling like a gambit to look like (bad) town (because I know roo isn't bad, just possesses a non-standard style), it warrants a vote.

Why're you voting Roo, and on what grounds does a person who seems to be going against their wincon [if town], or being generally silly deserve a vote? Emphasized in orange, the latter portion is a pretty blatant note.
The question is how do you see such behavior?
Why are you voting Roo when you note the above, in blue?

[Tiruin]

Mod note: If there are three cultists and three town left, whether or not a jailer lives, cult wins.

Also for you newbies, I'll list it out
4v3; SUPPOSING THE CULT LEADER HAS HIT IN ALL PREVIOUS NIGHTS (hence the 3), then we assume this is LYLO. Otherwise, we have another day [which should not be the status quo in thought, because of the valid danger here, and the obvious note that the Jailer doesn't know if their target was truly protected/stopped or not...So its a blank lead).

Now, note if we hit a cultist today.
4v2, cult leader targets (supposing Jailer succeeds//fails--this is the only portion, in relevance to the current discussion, where this would make any sense as a 3v3 would make an obvious 'CULT ALL VOTE THIS GUY', ending in a no-vote...unless cult somehow doesn't work out)
Main point: Treat today seriously because I'm seeing a lack of activity here.

- roo

- Peradon
- Teneb
- origamiscienceguy
- Generally me
- Deus Asmoth
- Tiruin

Everyone: Im interested in your review of the latter days, including today.

To those who voted Roo: What made you think that he was a good target to vote? And was this an impactful vote, or a placeholder?

[Generally me]

What does WIFOM mean cuz I see it everywhere

Tiruin review of the last few days... Well we lynched the wrong people and that's about all I got.

Teneb why did you vote Roo when you yourself said that if we didn't get the Cult leader we would lose. And Roo is guaranteed not to be cult leader?

[Jack A T]

What does WIFOM mean cuz I see it everywhere

Stands for Wine In Front Of Me, defined as "the circular reasoning that results from trying to determine the choices of an opponent who acted with full knowledge that his behavior would be subject to scrutiny."

[Teneb]

Teneb why did you vote Roo when you yourself said that if we didn't get the Cult leader we would lose. And Roo is guaranteed not to be cult leader?

Because I'm a moron who forgot roo started as confirmed town.

Unvote.[/url] Need to reread.

[Peradon]

Ok, well, I have already voted tiruin based on a lack of content in her posts. But seeing as how this is LyLo, I'm going to Unvote. My top two scumpick's right now, are Tiruin and Deus Asmoth. I already said why I dont trust Tiruin, and Deus Asmoth has.... done what exactly? I dont actually recall him being here much.

Deus Asmoth:What have you contributed to the game so far?