Earl heads downwards, intent on checking out the state of the hull...
As his boots leave the last stair, entering the lower cargo hold, they splash in about a foot of cold ocean water. It makes him shiver. He investigates the hold and finds the hull has sustained a number of sluggish leaks, the worst being a large jagged cracked that starts near the ceiling and runs zig zag all the way to the floor. Salty water slowly trickles in as he watches...which really reminds him of the full force of the ocean on the other side of this thin wooden skin they call a boat.
He can see a few loose items floating about here and there, though most of the barrels seem intact. One of the barrels sports a fat black rat chewing industrially on a cork. It notices you enter, pierces you with beady red eyes-then seemingly dismisses you, unafraid.
---The rest make their way up to the deck where they find...a remarkably lack of hurry or concern. Most of the sailors seem at ease and sure footed, even in the terrible storm-all going about their tasks with easy professionalism. In the far distance, across the surging waters-a black pinnacle of stone that is probably an island, can be seen.
Captain Catherine herself is hanging idly up in the rigging (the sails are drawn very tight) enduring the wind and the rain and thunder and lightning-shouting and cursing at the fury of the storm, for some reason.
"...Do yer worst! Come on, is that the best you can do!? Bring it all down if ya like, you son of a poxy whore! I'm still here! Ya ain't never gonna break Catherines Luck!!!" ...
Which is to say, by the way, that you're all being soaked to the bone.