Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Elephant Parade]

Sorry for double-posting, but I'm not sure that editing is allowed.

Since the Best Friend doesn't lose upon death, they still don't have much of a reason not to claim. This may be a problem.

Unless I misread something and they actually do lose upon death.

[hector13]

Sorry for double-posting, but I'm not sure that editing is allowed.

Since the Best Friend doesn't lose upon death, they still don't have much of a reason not to claim. This may be a problem.

Unless I misread something and they actually do lose upon death.

Needs a new rule then. BF needs to stay alive to win.

Never mind!

[MeimieFan88]

Sorry for double-posting, but I'm not sure that editing is allowed.

Since the Best Friend doesn't lose upon death, they still don't have much of a reason not to claim. This may be a problem.

Unless I misread something and they actually do lose upon death.

The BF does lose upon death

[Elephant Parade]

Wait, no. If they claim and reveal the Lover, the Lover will be voted; if they claim without revealing the Lover, they might die before they get the chance.

If anything, the Best Friend is practically useless now. At best, they might be able to convince the Hero not to kill the Lover--but then, isn't the Lover likely to get voted out by the Clones? Best Friend is just a WIFOM generator now; it's interesting, but probably not all that useful for the person who actually has it.

Sorry for double-posting, but I'm not sure that editing is allowed.

Since the Best Friend doesn't lose upon death, they still don't have much of a reason not to claim. This may be a problem.

Unless I misread something and they actually do lose upon death.

The BF does lose upon death

Eh. Since actually using their role is likely to get them killed, or even cause them to lose outright, I think this may be a bad thing.

[Terra162]

What is WIFOM?

[Elephant Parade]

What is WIFOM?

Wine In Front Of Me. I haven't played a ton of Mafia, so I'm not 100% sure on exactly how it's used, but I think it means "which glass is the poison in"-style confusion, where you're trying to figure out whether somebody would lie, or lie about lying, or whatever, based on little actual evidence. I think it's used a bit more broadly than that, though.

[Ama]

....This game is going to end fast.

*Flails about while shooting Playergamer*

[Playergamer]

Okay, I'm a Clone, good choice.

Note: That guy is still BF. That was true.

[Terra162]

Oohh! No! My identity has been given away! NOOOOOO!!!

>..<

[Elephant Parade]

This is kind of like Mafia if both factions were uninformed. The Hero is basically the scum, but they have no idea who the other members of their team are. The Clones are townspeople, but they're all trying to look like they're not--except now they also need to look like they're not not Clones, since the Clones have a kill. I think that both sides having a kill is the thing that will separate this from Mafia, even after people figure out the best way to play.

Oohh! No! My identity has been given away! NOOOOOO!!!

>..<

Nice claim. Enjoy your Clone-kill/suspicious Hero-kill.

[Peradon]

Ok, I wont roleclaim, but I can say that LuckyKobald is not BF. Nice try Kobald.

[Cryxis, Prince of Doom]

Oohh! No! My identity has been given away! NOOOOOO!!!

>..<

Damn you!
I pressed that while my family was sitting down watching a movie

[MeimieFan88]

....This game is going to end fast.

*Flails about while shooting Playergamer*

Playergamer has been eliminated... they were not the Lover!

Non-Hero players remaining (9):
hector13
LuckyKobold
Terra162
anailater
Cryxis, Prince of Doom
Peradon
Elephant Parade
Kevak
HugoLuman

Hero can eliminate again in 22 hours.

[WillowLuman]

Well, rather than make any claims as to a role, I'll just come up with some more ingenious ways of getting rid of people.

Try this one:

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

[hector13]

"I'll turn him into a bug, then I'll put that bug in a box, and that box in a bigger box. Then I'll mail that box to me, and when I get it I'LL SMASH IT WITH A HAMMER AHAHAHAHAHA!!"