Shamrock may have been an agressive scumhunter, but he was really, really bad at it. He kept forgetting past events, misinterpreting quotes, and making accusations that we're flat-out untrue.
It's cool to have one super-experienced non-IC player in the game, especially since NQT promotes nonstandard and interesting methods of playing the game, but adding 4mask into the slot? I know we need a replacement, but, well, he's already had a go at replacing in, and this "Beginner's" match is starting to look awfully pro.
Just my thoughts on the matter.
I'm going to drop some reads here, air out my opinions Always good to air opinions. Keeps them fresh.
Scripten: Seems fairly competent, generally knows what he's doing. Oddly insistent about that one D1 question not being a leading question (IMO it was). Concentrated on DA. Votes policy and strategically, see: SBC lead, Comrade vote. Agressive. Seems to be getting emotional in his latest posts w/ Deus - personal involvement? - : Slight town, acting oddly though.
Deus Asmoth: Defensive, and jumpy, seems worried about Scripten's focus on them. Needs to remember to scum hunt as well as defend himself. Seems somewhat focused on protecting self. Slight scum read.
Dorsidwarf: Handsome as ever.
Masked_Krusader[REPLACING]: Odd. Accuses people who question him. Accuses someone for using the RVS as intended. Declares other people to be using WIFOM against him, writes long ranty paragraph which is pure WIFOM. Scummy. Would be voting except they are replacing, and therefore are about as likely to defend themself as a chocolate alarm clock is to ring.
NQT: replaced in for RangerCado, who did hardly anything. Posted a big nice list of analysis. Seems to be focused on voting history as his scumhunting MO, as per usual. Voting DA for being timid, self-preservation focused. Slight town lean, but mostly not enough material to form a proper read.
Scintillininant:Acting odd. Led himself round by the nose after other people D1, voted NL immediately after executedumbo(me). Seems to have samey reasons. Feels off. Slight scum lean.
Cheeeetar: Needs to post more content. Hard to read. Isn't posting much advice, for a registered IC. Has questions on masked, but masked is replacing out. Null read (content-to-post ratio too low).
Ppe: Warning - while you were typing 5 new replies have been posted. You may wish to review your post. Typical.