Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[TheDarkStar]

Kilojoule:

quote author=Kilojoule Proton link=topic=144554.msg5726695#msg5726695 date=1413074501]
Vote Scripten, because only scum would make random accusations like that.
[/quote]

Why didn't you vote?

Scripten:

Huh, interesting. Kilojoule Proton (Do you mind KP?) is actually pinging my scum radar pretty solidly with those posts.

What is it exactly that makes him scummy? Similarly, what scumtell do you think is most important?

Illgeo: What's the best way to scumhunt, in your opinion?

Salsacookies: It's MyLo (you + 3 others). One is scum, but you don't know who, and one person has claimed cop. No one seems very scummy. What do you do?

GayArchaea: If you were the jailor, would you prioritize jailing to protect or jailing to block?

Eyjafjallajökull: Can I call you Eyja? Also, if you were a rolecop, would you check the person that everyone finds scummy or the less scummy person that fewer people suspect?


Responses:

Everyone: what are your expectations for the match?

New people panic (regardless of alignment), one of the experienced people (maybe me, yet again) dies tonight, and then it goes downhill from there. If we're lucky, we lynch at least one of the scum by day 3; otherwise, we're at LyLo.

Everyone: Hey, glad to be playing with you all.

On to the question: What's your experience with mafia?

I've been playing for about 10 months so far, in which time I've played 10-25 games (I lost count). I was scum for my first 3-5 games, and then I've been town ever since (except for that one school and meteor one and then the most recent BYOR).


PPE: 4 posts were written while I was writing this; I'll read and respond to them later after I read over them.

[TheDarkStar]

Kilojoule:

Vote Scripten, because only scum would make random accusations like that.

Why didn't you vote?

Scripten:

Huh, interesting. Kilojoule Proton (Do you mind KP?) is actually pinging my scum radar pretty solidly with those posts.

What is it exactly that makes him scummy? Similarly, what scumtell do you think is most important?

Illgeo: What's the best way to scumhunt, in your opinion?

Salsacookies: It's MyLo (you + 3 others). One is scum, but you don't know who, and one person has claimed cop. No one seems very scummy. What do you do?

GayArchaea: If you were the jailor, would you prioritize jailing to protect or jailing to block?

Eyjafjallajökull: Can I call you Eyja? Also, if you were a rolecop, would you check the person that everyone finds scummy or the less scummy person that fewer people suspect?


Responses:

Everyone: what are your expectations for the match?

New people panic (regardless of alignment), one of the experienced people (maybe me, yet again) dies tonight, and then it goes downhill from there. If we're lucky, we lynch at least one of the scum by day 3; otherwise, we're at LyLo.

Everyone: Hey, glad to be playing with you all.

On to the question: What's your experience with mafia?

I've been playing for about 10 months so far, in which time I've played 10-25 games (I lost count). I was scum for my first 3-5 games, and then I've been town ever since (except for that one school and meteor one and then the most recent BYOR).


PPE: 4 posts were written while I was writing this; I'll read and respond to them later after I read over them.

EBWOP for the missing bracket.

[GayArchaea]

(Yeah, KP along with Kilojoule, KJ, or Kilo are probably all sufficiently unique and identifiable.)

I defend myself with the argument that the role I play is essential for the town*.To lynch me would be to deplete you collectively of a necessary part of defending against scum. At the moment, I will not shift my vote, as it is said that the dice do not lie.

* Although the same could be said of an average townsperson at a LYLO (?)

KP, this leads me to believe you have a power role at best, so you're now a target of the dreadful mafia. A slip of the tongue perhaps, but do not reveal what possible information you have. The reveal, if it is as I suspect, would only be making a clear target for scum.

GayArchaea: If you were the jailor, would you prioritize jailing to protect or jailing to block?

I would prioritize jailing to protect whoever I think may be town, because it would lower the chance of the mafia killing a townie during the night.

[Kilojoule Proton]

I understand, thanks.

[GayArchaea]

I understand, thanks.

I would've unvoted here, but please answer the question TheDarkStar gave to you. It is considered scummy to ignore questions targeted towards you, unless you had already answered the exact same question in the thread.

[Scripten]

What is it exactly that makes him scummy? Similarly, what scumtell do you think is most important?

Depends on the context. Evasiveness or opportunistic actions at this point. Hence why I made my vote more serious than RVS.

[Kilojoule Proton]

Kilojoule:

Vote Scripten, because only scum would make random accusations like that.

Why didn't you vote?
...

To be honest, I had no idea about the distinction between scumhunting and D1 lynches.

[GayArchaea]

Fair enough, Unvote.

Salsacookies: If you were scum and had to choose between the two styles of play: would you be cautious or would you be reckless?

[Illgeo]

Everyone: What's your experience with mafia?

One game: BM 48 as Scum.

Everyone: what are your expectations for the match?

Because both scum and townies are equally newbies, I think it's hard to predict anything at this point.
But I hope we'll have much fun.

Illgeo: What's the best way to scumhunt, in your opinion?

Pay close atention to everyone and look for scumtells.
If you can't find any - pressure people until someone showing them.
If you can - pressure that person until he drops enough scumtells for everyone to see and lynch him.
Scripten: Will your play change because you have seen my scum play last game?

[Salsacookies]

GayArchea For me being scum, cold and calculating, watch the dominos fall from panic and anxiety. How about you, and were you expecting me to confess something? Yes, I did it, I ate the last sweetroll. Also, if it's anything like Psycho Murderers, the big guy with a oil barrel will light himself on fire and literally break the game.

TheDarkStar If there is any trouble of telling whose who, cop is scum, because only scum would say he's not, unless he doesn't say anything, to make you think he's nothing, but on the right foot, there's the possibility of....

Worldmaster27 Ive been playing Psycho Murderers a RTD/Mafia game.

[Urist Imiknorris]

No editing please. Double posting is totally fine here.

[GayArchaea]

GayArchaea For me being scum, cold and calculating, watch the dominos fall from panic and anxiety. How about you, and were you expecting me to confess something? Yes, I did it, I ate the last sweetroll. Also, if it's anything like Psycho Murderers, the big guy with a oil barrel will light himself on fire and literally break the game.

personally I'd be somewhat reckless in order to try to blend in better. I also wasn't trying for a confession, The questions here might help us later on.

Unvote.

[Kilojoule Proton]

So will we end up lynching anyone after all? It looks like there is no consensus at the moment.

[Worldmaster27]

We probably will end up lynching someone, either as a random lynch near the end of the day or because we think someone is scummy.

Just because we haven't all voted for someone yet doesn't mean we aren't going to try and lynch.

Unfortunately not much discussion is going on, and that won't help. As such...

Eyja: Why haven't you posted yet?

4mask + TDS: Any IC advice to give at the moment?

Salsacookies: What would you say is the most important scumtell to look for?

Illgeo: Do you plan to be more active in this game than BM48? How do you think to best go about doing this?

Scripten + GayArchaea: Since I can't think of any questions to ask you two, do you have any for me?

[GayArchaea]

Well then, Worldmaster27: Assuming you're a mafia goon, and there are five townies left, who would you kill in the night: the one you suspect to be the cop, the one you suspect to be the jailkeeper, the one who is rather suspicious of you, the one who somehow managed to not get lynched, or the one who (foolishly) believes you're town?