Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Persus13]

Extend. I'm really busy right now (although getting lynched would make it easier on me).

[ToonyMan]

I think it's inevitable him being lynched at this stage, but I'm getting that persistent feeling that I'm making a huge mistake and scum are going to grab a sudden win from left field like in almost every other damn game.

Uh yeah, I feel like that'll happen with lynching Persus13 after doing Hapah the day before.

Seriously, it's bugging me how in-sync 4maskwolf and IronyOwl are.

And also counter 4mask's oppose extension. A town player shouldn't speak those words. I want to see what Persus13 has to say.

[ToonyMan]

I swear to God if it's a conventional cult that managed to nab a vigilante on the first night again...

[Mephansteras]

I swear to God if it's a conventional cult that managed to nab a vigilante on the first night again...

Monster Hunters can't be converted any more. That caused too many unbalances in the game.

[4maskwolf]

Meph: The extension went through, there are two votes for (technically three and one oppose, if you count Toony's oppose oppose as an extension vote).

[4maskwolf]

Also, I may as well preemptively request replacement should the game be extended another time or I not die overnight/get lynched.  I'm out of wifi range all of next week.

[4maskwolf]

Meph: can I send in a night action now and my replacement override it should I need a replacement before night ends?

[IronyOwl]

Meph:  If the Dark Magus comprises a standard scum team, do they have a standard (sharable) scum kill?

Kill based Scum teams all have a sharable kill, yes. Conversion based teams would not have this, of course.

Meph: Would a lone Mentor-type role expected to recruit an apprentice count as kill-based or conversion-based?

Extend. I still think it's Persus and Toaster, but this has made me nervous enough to just give it another day. We can shorten once Persus' said his piece.

[4maskwolf]

Meph:  If the Dark Magus comprises a standard scum team, do they have a standard (sharable) scum kill?

Kill based Scum teams all have a sharable kill, yes. Conversion based teams would not have this, of course.

Meph: Would a lone Mentor-type role expected to recruit an apprentice count as kill-based or conversion-based?

Extend. I still think it's Persus and Toaster, but this has made me nervous enough to just give it another day. We can shorten once Persus' said his piece.

Okay, this use of the role "mentor" is really bugging me.  There is a difference between a lone charismatic cultist style role with a nightkill and a mentor.  A mentor is specifically a role that can convert another player if they don't have a partner, gains a nightkill when and only when they have a partner, and the mentee dies if the mentor is killed.

Also, the whole "mentor" role was just something I threw out as something to chew on for day 4.  I don't actually think there is a true mentor role in the game.

[IronyOwl]

Okay, this use of the role "mentor" is really bugging me.  There is a difference between a lone charismatic cultist style role with a nightkill and a mentor.  A mentor is specifically a role that can convert another player if they don't have a partner, gains a nightkill when and only when they have a partner, and the mentee dies if the mentor is killed.

Also, the whole "mentor" role was just something I threw out as something to chew on for day 4.  I don't actually think there is a true mentor role in the game.

I've been thinking of them as Sith, and thus a true Mentor or close enough. And also it's easier to call it a Mentor than a lone charismatic cultist style role with a nightkill.

That said, what do you think we have here and why?

[notquitethere]

So when Persus becomes free we want to hear the background details from their role PM and any additional details Meph wants to tell them.

[Mephansteras]

The Scribe's Tally Sheet
IronyOwl: ToonyMan
Persus13: 4maskwolf, IronyOwl, Toaster, zombie urist


Day has been Extended to ~4pm Pacific Friday. There will be no more extensions this day.

Meph: can I send in a night action now and my replacement override it should I need a replacement before night ends?

 

Yes, you can.

I don't suppose TheWetSheep is back?
 
 

Meph:  If the Dark Magus comprises a standard scum team, do they have a standard (sharable) scum kill?

Kill based Scum teams all have a sharable kill, yes. Conversion based teams would not have this, of course.

Meph: Would a lone Mentor-type role expected to recruit an apprentice count as kill-based or conversion-based?

 

If they gain a kill while as a team, or have a kill & a one-shot convert like the Charismatic Cultist, they would count as a kill-based scum team.

[IronyOwl]

Okay, good. Still on track for Toaster killing Reverie while Persus RB'd 4mask. Even though my gut still doesn't like that RB claim.

[ToonyMan]

Okay, good. Still on track for Toaster killing Reverie while Persus RB'd 4mask. Even though my gut still doesn't like that RB claim.

And we're going to lynch the role-blocker first?

[IronyOwl]

Okay, good. Still on track for Toaster killing Reverie while Persus RB'd 4mask. Even though my gut still doesn't like that RB claim.

And we're going to lynch the role-blocker first?

As opposed to the Thief, yes.