Spencer, Frell, and Will
You prepare yourself, and inquire about the robes.
"I don't think brown means anything, no. Probably just used by people who don't want to be noticed."
The robed guys look over in your direction, looking around suspisiously.
Bret
You open his hood, revealing a bald, and rather ugly man.
You demand to know why the guy killed the man.
He opens his mouth, revealing a lack of a tongue.
"Ee aad oo eii. Uh asher amaan ee!"
Waaa eeve uh aaahhh!"
You can't tell if he's simply failing to speak properly, or screaming incoherently.
[Escape: 12+2 vs 10= Success!]
He squirms out of your grasp, and starts running off across the rooftop again, towards some tall buildings in the distance!
Robin, Garenth, and Joe
Garenth points a finger at the Robed jerk and a spark of light flies into his eyes, dazing him for [2] rounds!
The Chewing man lays there motionless.
Robin opens up with his second Color Spray, hitting the Red Robed man, and the Captain!
[Will Saves: Red Robed 20!+2=Success! | Captain 19+1=Success!]
It winds up being totally ineffective.
The Red Robed person throws a Ray of Frost at Garenth!
[Ranged Touch: 5-1 vs AC 12= Miss]
It chills the wood of the mast.
Joe grabs at the Captain again [Grapple: 20!+5=Critical!]
Joe lifts the Captain up by the throat, dealing a whopping [16] damage!
You hear a *Snap!* as the Captain's neck breaks!
Garenth: 8 HP [12 AC]
Brown: 0/11 [Knocked Out]
Chewing Man: 3 damage taken [Unconscious: 4 rounds]
Robin: 4/15 HP [13+4 AC]
Red Robed: 8 damage taken [Mage Armor] [-1 Strength][Dazed: 2 rounds]
Joe: 14/22 HP [15 AC]
Captain: [Dead]
Some rules/spell effects may be wrong, as the site I use to look them up (linked in OP) has been shut down (Screw you, WotC!), so I'm going off of my spotty memory.
Correct me if I screw up, and I'll fix it.
Also, holy shit on that roll by the Demi-Orc.