So I was keeping track the whole game. Keeping a spreadsheet like this really forces you to slow down your reading and actually think about each post, I recommend it.
Here are my notes for anyone who wants to see them. I think there's nothing there that nobody should see left. Comments are open, editing disabled.
Andrew425, I had been thinking about claiming cop before you claimed, but you claiming really did "play right into scum's hands" as it were.
TheDarkStar, I chose you for the fact that killing you wouldn't make anyone suspicious. Sorry that it played into your mortality streak.
Persus, I don't think I could have pulled off that cop claim gambit without replacing you. Thanks.
The Soldier, I actually had money with my coworkers on whether or not you would see through my ploy. I guess I lost a couple bucks. Meh.
Pisskop, I hope you play again sometime soon. I had fallen for the same meta mistakes in my previous game, and really wanted to talk to you about it. I'd definitely be willing to hav a rematch with you.
4maskwolf, laughing at the deadchat. I could have sword post 213 would have been the post that killed me. It didn't. Nobody batted an eyebrow where I could see. In the deadchat.... You guys knew if I kept talking that way it would get me killed. And you dismissed Tiruin as being not scum. Goodgame.
Tiruin, thank you for introducing me to the local meta last game... and getting me lynched there. And for working with me here.
And a great thanks to everyone else who made this cop claim fun, and made keeping track of posting a little easier.